Grade 91 creep strength-enhanced ferritic steel is a critical material in power generation, widely used for high-temperature, high-pressure tubing and piping applications. Its superior elevated-temperature strength derives from a distinctive microstructure of tempered martensite with uniformly dispersed secondary phases (carbides and carbo-nitrides). This microstructure, crucial for reliable service performance, is achieved through precise control of the manufacturing process, including steelmaking, hot forming, and final heat treatment. This investigation builds upon earlier research into the relationship between manufacturing parameters and short-term creep-rupture properties in T91 tubes, and a recent update that included test results exceeding 30,000 hours. This study presents a comprehensive metallurgical analysis of ruptured test specimens. The investigation focuses on correlating manufacturing parameters with not only creep strength but also material ductility and microstructural evolution during long-term exposure, providing valuable insights into the material’s behavior under extended service conditions.

Tenaris' High Oxidation Resistance (THOR) 115, or T115, is a creep strength-enhanced ferritic (CSEF) steel introduced in the past decade. It is widely used in constructing high-efficiency power plants and heat recovery steam generators (HRSGs) due to its superior steam oxidation resistance and long-term microstructural stability, making it a viable alternative to stainless steels at elevated steam temperatures. The creep damage tolerance of T115 has been recently validated under ASME BPVC CC 3048 guidelines, which address safety concerns related to creep damage in boiler components. Testing confirmed T115's consistent creep damage-tolerant behavior, with cross-weld creep behavior reassessed through extensive metallographic examination of specimens from a 1.5-inch thick pipe girth weld, providing insights into creep damage distribution and hardness, and its relative performance compared to Grade 91 CSEF steel.

Modified 9Cr-1Mo alloy steel has been developed over the last few decades and has since gained wide acceptance in the boiler industry for the production of a variety of pressure-critical components, including tubing, piping and headers. The properties of creep-strength enhanced ferritic steels such as grade 91 are critically dependent on manufacturing parameters such as steelmaking, hot deformation, heat treatment and welding. Since the applications for which this material is used impose strict requirements in terms of resistance, corrosion, and creep behavior, poor process control can severely compromise the service behavior. This work discusses the impact of total deformation during the rolling process, and heat treatment parameters on time-independent and time-dependent properties for grade 91. For this study, two heats with similar chemical composition were produced with different reduction ratios: to which, several normalizing and tempering combinations were applied. For each combination, the microstructure was characterized, including evaluation of segregation by metallographic examination, and analysis of secondary phase precipitates by means of X-ray powder diffraction. Mechanical testing and creep testing were performed. A comparison of results is presented, and recommendations on the optimal process parameters are provided to ensure reliable performance of grade 91 material.

A new ferritic steel branded as Thor 115 has been developed to enhance high-temperature resistance. The steel design combines an improved oxidation resistance with long-term microstructural stability. The new alloy was extensively tested to assess the high-temperature time- dependent mechanical behavior (creep). The main strengthening mechanism is precipitation hardening by finely dispersed carbide (M 23 C 6 ) and nitride phases (MX). Information on the evolution of secondary phases and time-temperature-precipitation behavior of the alloy, essential to ensure long-term stability, was obtained by scanning transmission electron microscopy with energy dispersive spectroscopy, and by X-ray powder diffraction on specimens aged up to 50,000 hours. The material behavior was also tested in service conditions, to validate the laboratory results: Thor 115 tubing was installed in a HRSG power plant, directly exposed to turbine flue gasses. Tubing samples were progressively extracted, analyzed and compared with laboratory specimens in similar condition. This research shows the performance of Thor 115 regarding steam oxidation and microstructure evolution up to 25,000 exposure hours in the field. So far, no oxide microstructure difference is found between the laboratory and on field tubing: in both cases, the oxide structure is magnetite/hematite and Cr-spinel layers and the oxide thickness values lay within the same scatter band. The evolution of precipitates in the new alloy confirms the retention of the strengthening by secondary phases, even after long-term exposure at high temperature. The deleterious conversion of nitrides into Z phase is shown to be in line with, or even slower than that of the comparable ASME grade 91 steel.

A new martensitic steel for power generation applications was developed: Tenaris High Oxidation Resistance (Thor) is an evolution of the popular ASTM grade 91, offering improved steam oxidation resistance and better long-term microstructural stability, with equal or better creep strength. Thanks to its design philosophy, based on consolidated metallurgical knowledge of microstructural evolution mechanisms, and an extensive development performed in the last decade, Thor was engineered to overcome limitations in the use of ASTM grade 91, above 600 °C, particularly related to scale growth and liftoff. After laboratory development, Thor was successfully validated at the industrial level. Several heats up to 80 metric tons were cast at the steel shop, hot rolled to tubes of various dimensions, and heat treated. Trial heats underwent extensive characterization, including deep microstructural examination, mechanical testing in the as-received condition and after ageing, long-term creep and steam oxidation testing. This paper presents an overview of metallurgical characterization performed on laboratory and industrial Thor material, including microstructural examination and mechanical testing in time-independent and time-dependent regimes. Data relevant to the behavior and the performance of Thor steel are also included.

A new martensitic steel for power generation applications was developed: Tenaris High Oxidation Resistance (Thor) is an evolution of the popular ASME grade 91, offering improved steam oxidation resistance and better long-term microstructural stability, with equal or better creep strength. Thanks to its design philosophy, based on consolidated metallurgical knowledge of microstructural evolution mechanisms, and an extensive development performed in the last decade, Thor was engineered to overcome limitations in the use of ASME grade 91, yet allow being processed in the same fashion, permitting the re-use of consolidated best practices for boiler fabrication. In order to evaluate the possibility to produce complete pressure part systems, various tests to manufacture components have been performed on Thor pipes and tubes (i.e. finning, bending, welding) and on Thor forged material (i.e. flanges). In all cases consolidated industrial best practices used on ASME grade 91 were applied, and resulting properties met ASME requirements.

A new martensitic steel was developed for power generation applications. Tenaris High Oxidation Resistance (Thor) is an evolution of Grade 91, designed to have improved steam oxidation resistance and better long-term microstructural stability, with equal or better creep strength. Based on consolidated metallurgical knowledge of microstructural evolution mechanisms, and extensive development performed in the last decade, Thor was engineered to overcome temperature limitations of Grade 91, yet it can be processed in the same fashion, permitting the use of existing best practices for Grade 91 boiler fabrication. Welding trials were performed on Thor tubes and pipe using welding procedures that are routinely employed in the construction of Grade 91 steel components. A summary of relevant results is presented, demonstrating the applicability of long-established and tested welding procedures to components manufactured with Thor steel.