The power industry has been faced with continued challenges around decarbonization and additive manufacturing (AM) has recently seen increased use over the last decade. The use of AM has led to significant design changes in components to improve the overall efficiency of gas turbines and more recently, hot-section components have been fabricated using AM nickel-base superalloys, which have shown substantial benefits. This paper will discuss and summarize extensive studies led by EPRI in a novel AM nickel-base superalloy (ABD·900-AM). A comprehensive high temperature creep testing study including >67,000 hours of creep data concluded that ABD-900AM shows improved properties compared to similar ~35% volume fraction gamma prime strengthened nickel-base superalloys fabricated using additive methods. Several different creep mechanisms were identified and various factors influencing high temperature behavior, such as grain size, orientation, processing method, heat treatment, carbide structure, chemistry and porosity were explored. Additional studies on the printability, recyclability of powder, wide range of process parameters and several other factors have also been studied and results are summarized. A summary on the alloy -by-design approach and accelerated material acceptance of ABD-900AM through extensive testing and characterization is further discussed. Numerous field studies and examples of field use cases in ABD-900AM are also evaluated to showcase industry adoption of ABD-900AM.

To improve the economics of critical components, such as receivers and heat exchangers, for Generation 3 (Gen 3) concentrating solar power (CSP) plants, research was conducted to understand how manufacturing impacts the high-temperature performance of various tube production routes. Gen 3 CSP components are expected to require the use of heat-resistant nickel- based alloys due to the elevated operating temperatures in designs carrying molten salt or supercritical CO 2 . INCONEL alloy 740H (alloy 740H) was investigated as an alternative to UNS N06230 (alloy 230) as it possesses superior high-temperature creep strength which can lead to overall reductions in material cost. A key challenge is understanding how autogenous seam welding with and without re-drawing can be used to manufacture thin-wall tubing for CSP receivers and heat-exchangers to further reduce costs over traditional seamless production routes. Alloy 740H welded tube was successfully fabricated and re-drawn to several relevant tube sizes. Since traditional mechanical testing samples could not be removed from the thin-wall tubing, full-sized tubes were used for tensile, fatigue, and vessel testing (internally pressurized creep- rupture) which was critical to understanding the weld performance of the manufactured product forms. The generated vessel test data exhibited a creep strength reduction when compared to wrought product with no clear trend with temperature or test duration. It was found that redrawing the welded tubes improved the creep strength to approximately 82% of the wrought material performance and elevated temperature tensile and fatigue behavior exceeded 85% of the design minimums. Detailed, post-test characterization found that nano-sized carbides formed during the laser seam-welding process remained stable after multiple solution-annealing steps, which restricted grain growth, and impacted the time-dependent performance. This paper will focus on the time-dependent behavior of the examined welded and redrawn tubes, supporting metallographic evidence, and give perspective on future considerations for using alloy 740H in CSP components.

Inconel 718 is a nickel-based superalloy known for its excellent combination of high-temperature strength, corrosion resistance, and weldability. Additive Manufacturing (AM) has revolutionized traditional manufacturing processes by enabling the creation of complex and customized components. In this work, three prominent AM techniques: Laser-Based Powder Bed Fusion (PBF), Wire Direct Energy Deposition (DED), and Binder Jet (BJ) processes were explored. A thorough metallographic analysis and comparison of samples was conducted after short-term creep testing originating from each of the three aforementioned techniques in addition to wrought material. Detailed electron microscopy unveiled equiaxed grains in both BJ and wrought samples while PBF samples displayed elongated finer grain structures in the build direction, characteristic of PBF. The DED samples revealed a more bimodal grain distribution with a combination of smaller equiaxed grains accompanied by larger more elongated grains. When assessing the three processes, the average grain size was found to be larger in the BJ samples, while the PBF samples exhibited the most significant variation in grain and sub-grain size. Number density, size, and shape of porosity varied between all three techniques. Post-creep test observations in PBF samples revealed the occurrence of wedge cracking at the failure point, accompanied by a preference for grain boundary creep void formation while BJ samples exhibited grain boundary creep void coalescence and cracking at the failure location. In the DED samples, void formation was minimal however, it seemed to be more prevalent in areas with precipitates. In contrast, the wrought sample showed void formation at the failure site with a preference for areas with primary carbide formation. Despite BJ samples demonstrating similar or even superior rupture life compared to other AM techniques, a noteworthy reduction in rupture ductility was observed. While a coarse, uniform grain size is generally linked to enhanced creep resistance and rupture life, the combination of pre-existing voids along grain boundaries and the formation of new voids is hypothesized to accelerate rapid fracture, resulting in diminished ductility. This research shows careful consideration is needed when selecting an AM technology for high- temperature applications as creep behavior is sensitive to the large microstructural variations AM can introduce.

Advanced power generation systems, including advanced ultrasupercritical (A-USC) steam and supercritical carbon dioxide (sCO 2 ) plants operating above 700°C, are crucial for reducing carbon dioxide emissions through improved efficiency. While nickel superalloys meet these extreme operating conditions, their high cost and poor weldability present significant challenges. This study employs integrated computational materials engineering (ICME) strategies, combining computational thermodynamics and kinetics with multi-objective Bayesian optimization (MOBO), to develop improved nickel superalloy compositions. The novel approach focuses on utilizing Ni 3 Ti (η) phase strengthening instead of conventional Ni 3 (Ti,Al) (γ’) strengthening to enhance weldability and reduce costs while maintaining high-temperature creep strength. Three optimized compositions were produced and experimentally evaluated through casting, forging, and rolling processes, with their microstructures and mechanical properties compared to industry standards Nimonic 263, Waspaloy, and 740H. Weldability assessment included solidification cracking and stress relaxation cracking tests, while hot hardness measurements provided strength screening. The study evaluates both the effectiveness of the ICME design methodology and the practical potential of these cost-effective η-phase strengthened alloys as replacements for traditional nickel superalloys in advanced energy applications.

Olefin furnaces contain gravity cast U-bend fittings from Fe-Ni-Cr alloys that can experience premature failures due to a combination of harsh service conditions. The fittings undergo steep temperature variations during startup and shutdown, outer diameter (OD) oxidation from furnace flue gases, and inner diameter (ID) carburization from process fluids. As a result, cracking often occurs along large solidification grain boundaries from interconnected networks of carbides and secondary phases. To address these degradation concerns, Wire Arc Additive Manufacturing (WAAM) is being used to produce a functionally graded fitting that provides increased oxidation, carburization, creep, and thermal fatigue resistance. Three welding wire compositions have been designed based on thermodynamic and kinetic modeling techniques to address the appropriate corrosion resistance and mechanical properties needed in the OD, Core, and ID regions of the U- bend fitting cross-section. A Fe-35Cr-45Ni-0.7Nb solid welding wire is being used for the Core section, and metal-cored welding wires based around this composition with additions of Si or Al are being used for the OD and ID sections, respectively. This study involved weldability evaluation focused on understanding the microstructures and potential additive manufacturing printability challenges associated with graded WAAM structures using these welding wires. To achieve this, Cast Pin Tear Testing (CPTT) was performed to evaluate solidification cracking susceptibility of the welding wires. Additionally, Scheil calculations were performed in Thermo-Calc software to predict solidification microstructures. To validate the results, SEM characterization was conducted on cast buttons of each welding wire to identify phases in the respective microstructures. These unique data will help inform WAAM design parameters needed to produce a Functionally Graded Material (FGM) that improves the lifetime of Fe-Ni-Cr U-bend fittings in olefin furnaces.?

Ni-base superalloys used for hot section hardware of gas turbine systems experience thermomechanical fatigue (TMF), creep, and environmental degradation. The blades and vanes of industrial gas turbines (IGTs) are made from superalloys that are either directionally-solidified (DS) or cast as single crystals (SX). Consequently, designing and evaluating these alloys is complex since life depends on the crystallographic orientation in addition to the complexities related to the thermomechanical cycling and the extent of hold times at elevated temperature. Comparisons between the more complex TMF tests and simpler isothermal low cycle fatigue (LCF) tests with hold times as cyclic test methods for qualifying alternative repair, rejuvenation, and heat-treatment procedures are discussed. Using the extensive set of DS and SX data gathered from the open literature, a probabilistic physics-guided neural network is developed and trained to estimate life considering the influence of crystallographic orientation, temperature, and several other cycling and loading parameters.

This study evaluates the elevated temperature mechanical performance of 316H stainless steel produced using directed energy deposition (DED) additive manufacturing (AM) from three separate collaborative research programs focused on understanding how AM variables affect creep performance. By combining these studies, a critical assessment of variables was possible including the DED AM method (laser powder and gas metal arc wire), laser power, sample orientation relative to build orientation, chemical composition, and post-processing heat treatment. Detailed microstructure characterization was used to supplement creep and chemistry results to provide insights into potential mechanistic differences in behavior. The study found that sample orientation was a critical variable in determining lower-bound creep behavior, but that in general the lowest creep strength orientation and the lowest creep ductility orientation were not the same. Heat treatment was also an important variable with as-printed materials showing for specific test conditions improved performance and that underlying substructures formed due to inhomogeneous chemical distributions were not completely removed when using standard wrought solution annealing heat-treatments. The chemistry of the final deposited parts differed from the starting stock and may be an important consideration for long-term performance which is not fully appreciated. Overall, the study found that while all the DED materials tested fell within an expected wrought scatter band of performance, the actual creep performance could vary by an order of magnitude due to the many factors described.

This study investigates the influences of product chemistry and grain size on the high-temperature creep properties of 316 stainless steels by analyzing an extensive range of historical and modern literature data. The investigated 316 stainless steel creep property dataset, including more than 160 heats and 2,400 creep testing data, covers a wide spectrum of elemental compositions and product forms. To perform a prudent analysis of the creep property dataset, a statistical overview was first implemented to understand the data distribution relevant to data sources, chemistries, product forms, testing temperatures, and grain sizes. The creep data of 550°C, 600°C, 650°C, 700°C, and 750°C with ±10°C were grouped together, and the analytical study was performed on each sub dataset to investigate the temperature-specific creep performance. The creep strength was evaluated using the average stress ratio (ASR) between the experimental and predicted creep data of tested 316SS heats. The influence of composition and grain size on the creep strength ratio were evaluated using linear correlation analysis. Effects of specified and non-specified elements including C, N, and B were specifically investigated to understand their impacts on the creep strength with regards to the variation of creep temperature. In addition to the literature data, the most recent EPRI creep data of three commercial heats were used to validate the correlations from the historical creep property dataset.

Advanced power systems that operate at temperatures higher than about 650°C will require nickel-base alloys in critical areas for pressure containment. Age-hardened alloys offer an additional advantage of reduced volume of material compared with lower strength solid solution-strengthened alloys if thinner tube wall can be specified. To date, the only age-hardened alloy that has been approved for service in the time dependent temperature regime in the ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code is INCONEL alloy 740H. Extensive evaluation of seamless tube, pipe, and forged fittings in welded construction, including implant test loops and pilot plants, has shown the alloy to be fit for service in the 650-800°C (1202-1472°F) temperature range. Since, nickel-base alloys are much more expensive than steel, manufacturing methods that reduce the cost of material for advanced power plants are of great interest. One process that has been extensively used for stainless steels and solution-strengthened nickel-base alloys is continuous seam welding. This process has rarely been applied to age-hardened alloys and never for use as tube in the creep-limited temperature regime. This paper presents the initial results of a study to develop alloy 740H welded tube, pipe and fittings and to generate data to support establishment of ASME code maximum stress allowables.

Early supercritical units such as American Electric Power (AEP) Philo U6, the world’s first supercritical power plant, and Eddystone U1 successfully operated at ultrasupercritical (USC) levels. However due to the unavailability of metals that could tolerate these extreme temperatures, operation at these levels could not be sustained and units were operated for many years at reduced steam (supercritical) conditions. Today, recently developed creep strength enhanced ferritic (CSEF) steels, advanced austenitic stainless steels, and nickel based alloys are used in the components of the steam generator, turbine and piping systems that are exposed to high temperature steam. These materials can perform under these prolonged high temperature operating conditions, rendering USC no longer a goal, but a practical design basis. This paper identifies the engineering challenges associated with designing, constructing and operating the first USC unit in the United States, AEP’s John W. Turk, Jr. Power Plant (AEP Turk), including fabrication and installation requirements of CSEF alloys, fabrication and operating requirements for stainless steels, and life management of high temperature components