This paper presents the results of two metals coatings, molybdenum and tantalum, prepared by Controlled Atmosphere Plasma Spray (CAPS) onto Al 6061 substrates that were thermal cycled to calculate the effective coating modulus. Traditional uniaxial tensile testing samples were prepared from thicker duplicate coatings for comparison, as well as to measure thermal expansion properties and oxygen and nitrogen content. The molybdenum samples cut from thicker coatings were un-able to be tensile tested due to their fragility. Thermal cycle testing of molybdenum on an Al 6061 substrate was found to have a modulus approximately 18 to 19% of literature values for bulk molybdenum using the bi-layer beam thermal cycling method. Additionally, non-linear modulus behaviour was observed in the molybdenum sample when enough thermal strain was induced to shift the coating from a compressive to tensile stress state. The tantalum coating was found to have a modulus approximately 42 to 46% of literature values for bulk tantalum using the bi-layer thermal cycling method. Traditional tensile testing measured a modulus approximately 44 to 46% of bulk, which shows good agreement between the two methods and supports that the bi-layer thermal cycling method is valid for plasma sprayed refractory metal coatings.

The aim of this study is to characterize the mechanical behavior of wire-arc sprayed Zn-Al coatings and correlate the results with microstructure via computational techniques. High-resolution microstructural images obtained by SEM were imported into NIST-developed FEA software, which calculates macroscale properties based on user-selected features such as voids, pores, cracks, and splat boundaries. To assess the validity of the approach, elastic modulus was measured various ways and the results compared to the simulated value. Resonant frequency analysis provided the most accurate measurement, which was found to be closest to the simulated value.

ZrO 2 -Y 2 O 3 (YSZ) thermal barrier coatings (TBCs) were manufactured via conventional Air Plasma Spray (APS), Suspension Plasma Spray (SPS) and an additional technology hereby termed Finely-dispersed-particle Air Plasma Spray (FAPS). The FAPS processing employs the exact same classification of finely dispersed particles as used in SPS; however, whereas SPS uses a liquid medium, in the case of FAPS the particles are fed conventionally via a carrier gas into the plasma spray torch by using a newly developed powder feeder for fine (suspension-like) particles (NRC patented technology). These finely dispersed YSZ particles consist of irregularly shaped (fluffy-like) agglomerates made from individual nano-sized particles. The conventional APS YSZ TBC was sprayed via a Metco 3MB torch, whereas, both SPS and FAPS YSZ TBCs were sprayed using the Mettech Axial III torch (using the same set of spray parameters). Both SPS and FAPS YSZ TBCs exhibited porous and vertically-cracked microstructures. The conventional APS YSZ TBC microstructure exhibited the traditional lamellar morphology. Elastic modulus, hardness and thermal conductivity values were evaluated for all YSZ TBCs. Microstructures and phase analysis were investigated via SEM and XRD.

Nanostructured YSZ coatings were deposited by plasma spraying at different pressures and plasma currents. Coatings sprayed at low pressures exhibited fine equiaxed grain structures with consolidated coarser grains and loose-packed nano granules. Especially at the low end of the current range, larger amounts of crystalline grain fell into the nanoscale, significantly reducing the average grain size in the coating. At the high end of the range, the coating exhibited a uniform fine equiaxed grain structure of around 200 nm. Mechanical properties, including average microhardness and elastic modulus, were also measured and compared. LPPS YZS coatings showed slightly higher microhardness, but half the elastic modulus of APS YSZ layers.

This work investigates the fundamental mechanical properties of SPS and APS thermal barrier coatings. SPS YSZ coatings had lower Young’s modulus values and higher interfacial toughness than APS deposited layers. The low stiffness of SPS coatings limits the elastic energy that can be stored in ceramic layers. This coupled with good interfacial toughness might make SPS deposited thermal barrier coatings less prone to delamination due to thermal cycling.

In the present work, YSZ coatings were deposited on graphite substrates by plasma spray-physical vapor deposition (PS-PVD) in order to study the influence of spray distance on microstructure and durability. Four coating samples were examined in detail via SEM and XRD analysis. The results show that the as-sprayed YSZ has a dense lamellar-columnar microstructure with low porosity. Both monoclinic and tetragonal zirconia were detected in the coatings along with ZrO 2 -x, the latter indicating that oxygen loss occurred at short spraying distances. Coating hardness and Young’s modulus were also measured and were found to vary with spraying distance as well.

In this study, an internal injection plasma torch is used to deposit nano-agglomerated YSZ feedstock powders on superalloy substrates at low ambient pressures ranging from 5000 Pa to 6000 Pa. Coatings with unique fully nano-equiaxed structures were obtained when operating the torch below 300 A. With increasing current, up to 700 A, coatings with mixed-grain and eventually large-grain structures were produced. Experimental results suggest that the equiaxed nanoscale structure derives from the original agglomerated nanoparticles that had undergone melting while inside the nozzle of the plasma torch and were subsequently solidified or sintered in the coating. Coating hardness and elastic modulus were also measured and are shown to correspond with microstructure.

This paper examines the microstructure and morphology of zirconia coatings and demonstrates the calculation of elastic modulus and Martens hardness based on instrumented indentation test results. Coatings samples varying in microstructure, phase content, and chemical composition were deposited by suspension plasma spraying using different torches and different suspension formulations. Coatings produced from low-concentration suspensions with submicron-size powders had a columnar structure with long vertical pores between the columns and fine spherical pores within the columns. Coatings made from suspensions with high concentrations of solids and coarser, more irregular powders, on the other hand, were more uniform and their surfaces smoother. They are also shown to be harder and have higher elastic modulus based on indentation test results.

Resonant ultrasound spectroscopy was applied to analyze the elastic anisotropy of thick copper, aluminum, titanium, and nickel coatings prepared by cold spraying and to determine the respective elastic moduli. The results show that the coatings exhibit only weak deviations from perfect isotropy, and the obtained elastic moduli are comparable with those of the corresponding polycrystalline bulks. The increased internal friction observed in some of the studied coatings may indicate grain refinement and consequent grain boundary sliding.

The wear resistance of thermal spray coatings mainly depends on coating properties such as the microstructure, hardness, and porosity, as well as on the residual stress in the coating. The residual stress is induced by a variety of influences e.g. temperature gradients, difference of the thermal expansion coefficient of the coating / substrate materials, and the geometry of the components. To investigate the residual stress, the Impulse Excitation Technique was employed to measure the Young’s and shear moduli. The residual stress was determined by using the hole-drilling method and X-ray diffraction. Pin-on-Disc and Pin-on-Tube tests were used to investigate the wear behavior. After the wear tests, the wear volume was measured by means of a 3D-profilometer. The results show that the value of the residual stress can be modified by varying the coating thickness and the substrate geometry. The compressive stress in the HVOF-sprayed WC-Co coatings has a significant positive influence on the wear resistance whereas the tensile stress has a negative effect.

Spray parameters play an important role on the microstructure and properties of plasma sprayed coatings. Parameters such as spray distance, plasma gas flow and current, raster speed and spray angle all can be varied. In this paper, an integrated study to investigate the effects and influences of spray angle on properties of yttria-stabilized zirconia coatings was carried out with spray angles of 60°, 75° and 90° (to the substrate surface). In situ coating property sensor (ICP) based on beam curvature measurements was used to measure the evolving stress and elastic moduli of the resultant coatings and combined with other characterization tools for thermophysical property and microstructure analysis, such as laser flash and scanning electron microscopy (SEM). The results indicate that the coating with 60° spray angle had the lowest thermal conductivity and more compliant structure. This study seeks to understand the mechanism for this effect and will provide important insight into parametric sensitivities on complex spray parts.

Thermally sprayed coatings are usually defined by their hardness, porosity, roughness and wear resistance. Even though the Young’s modulus is an essential property, which describes the mechanical behavior of the coated components during their use, only few efforts were made to determine this property. The most common measurement methods of the Young’s modulus of thermally sprayed coatings are tensile tests, bending tests, and nanoindentations. During the tensile and bending tests a sliding of the splats can occur due to the laminar structure of the thermally sprayed coatings, influencing the measurement value. When using the nanoindentation test, only the elastic behavior of a single splat can be determined because of a minimal measuring volume. However, the Young’s Modulus of thermally sprayed coatings can also be determined by means of a resonant method, called impulse excitation technique (IET). In this paper, the values of the Young’s moduli of thermally sprayed coatings, measured by several methods are compared with each other and correlated to the microstructure of the coatings, investigated by means of scanning electron microscopy.

Formation of voids is inevitable in plasma sprayed coatings, and the role of voids on coating properties has long been established. In fact, the void content within coatings is often adjusted by manipulating the process parameters to obtain coatings with desirable performance. Quantification of voids via image analysis allows the determination of not only the void content within a coating, but also the spatial distribution of the voids. Void content in plasma sprayed neodymium iron boron (Nd-Fe-B) coatings was varied from 1.8 to 8.2% by changing the standoff distance (SOD). Spatial distribution parameters, including near-neighbor distance (d min ), nearest-neighbor distance (d mean ), and nearest-neighbor angle (θ n ), were determined via the Dirichlet tessellation method. Coefficient of variation (COV) values of d min and d mean allow the determination of inhomogeneity and degree of clustering of the voids within a coating. The θ n values show the anisotropy behavior of the voids within plasma sprayed coatings. The influence of void content and its spatial distribution within the coatings on the microhardness and elastic modulus of the coatings was determined.

To answer current issues adequately considering technical, economic, as well as environmental requirements, material transformation and especially surface treatment industries must be source of innovations to be proactive. As a result, developing new alternative solutions to existing ones had become a top priority. Considering surface treatment processes, conventional ones (thermal spraying, plasma transferred arc) do not allow to consider this approach since the processes themselves (co-treatment of different powders) do not permit to guarantee the initial composition nor do they ensure a sufficient homogeneity to the coating structure. If indeed the dry surface treatment processes have already shown large potential, several limits remain such as an inefficient adhesion, an environmental impact over the life cycle or almost no materials on the market. To overcome these issues hybrid coating technologies (combining several processes) are likely to be developed. From all of them, laser technology seems to be very promising due to its high flexibility considering all the potential parameters (varying power, continuous or pulsed beam, etc.) and the localised treated area. For instance, combining simultaneously a laser with a thermal spray process enables the elaboration of a thick coating showing a good adherence. The ablation laser applied on the substrate surface just before the impacting particles as promoted in the PROTAL process permit to insure a suitable surface state favourable to the particles adhesion. The control of the coating microstructure was not so much studied. That is why, to complete the knowledge in this area, this work aims at studying the influence of laser technology in association with plasma spraying on the coating microstructure and more precisely on the coating mechanical properties. Coatings were characterized by SEM and void content was evaluated through image analysis and Archimedean porosimetry. Mechanical properties were assessed by the four points bending test for evaluating the coating apparent Young modulus.

Plasma generated by an SG-100 torch was applied to spray suspension formulated with the use of ZrO 2 +8 wt% Y 2 O 3 (8YSZ) and ZrO 2 +24 wt% CeO 2 +2.5 wt% Y 2 O 3 (24CeYSZ) as solid phases. The solids have the mean size of about 4.5 µm for 8YSZ and 3.9 µm 24CeYSZ and were obtained by milling of commercial powders Metco 204 NS and Metco 205NS, respectively. The suspensions were formulated with the use of 20 wt% solid phase, 40 wt% water, and 40 wt.% ethanol. The plasma spray parameters were optimized by keeping constant: (i) the electric power at 40 kW (ii) the working gases composition 45 slpm of Ar and 5 slpm of H 2 . On the other hand, the spray distance was varied from 40 to 60 mm and torch linear speed was varied from 300 to 500 mm/s. The coatings were sprayed onto stainless steel substrates to reach the thickness ranging from 70 to 110 µm (8YSZ) and about 70 µm (24CeYSZ). The coating microstructures were analyzed with the use of a scanning electron microscope. Mechanical properties were tested with the use of indentation and scratch tests. The indentation test was carried out with various loads ranging from 100 to 10,000 mN to determine elastic modulus and Martens microhardness. Young’s modulus of the coatings was in the range 71 to 107 GPa for 8YSZ and 68 to 130 GPa for 24CeYSZ. Scratch tests were conducted to determine the scratch macrohardness.

Mechanical and thermal properties of thermally sprayed coatings, especially ceramics, are strongly influenced by cracks and pores that are present in the coating microstructure. In the recent past, there have been efforts to find an analytical model describing the coating properties based on the microstructural characteristics. Various analytical models were developed and published in the literature. In this study, several major models were applied to ceramic and metal coatings to describe their elastic modulus and thermal conductivity. The sensitivity of the models to the variations in the microstructure and relevancy of their use in specific cases were examined. The results were compared with those obtained by FEM modeling and experimentally measured values.

Young’s modulus is not only one of the important mechanical properties of thermally sprayed coatings but also a sensitive indicator of the coating’s microstructural defects. The ceramic coatings studied in this work were based on Al 2 O 3 , TiO 2 and Cr 2 O 3 and prepared by APS (Atmospheric Plasma Spraying), HVOF (High Velocity Oxy Fuel spraying) and suspension-HVOF spraying. The Young’s modulus was systematically studied by laser acoustic surface waves, which is a non-destructive, fast and reliable technique, using two different devices: a tabletop tester for samples and small components (LAwave) and a hand-held portable device. For oxide coatings, it was observed that the results distinctly vary depending on the spray technology. A comparison with the values derived from the instrumented indentation test shows that for most investigated ceramic coatings lower values were measured by laser acoustics. This is due to the influence of the pores and defects in the coatings. The LAwave results are expected to be close to the effective modulus of the material, due to the larger material volume evaluated during the test, which takes the coating defects into consideration.

This paper compares the results of two approaches of instrumented indentation for characterization of mechanical properties of HVOF coatings. Three types of industrially used HVOF sprayed coatings (Cr 3 C 2 -NiCr, WC-Co, (Ti, Mo)(C,N)-NiCo) were selected. The indentation methods applied were: isolated nanoindentation in metallic matrix and carbides with 2 mN peak load and grid indentation with 2 mN peak loads, comprising 400 indentations. The results of the isolated indentation revealed hardness and elastic modulus of the individual phases with surprisingly low standard deviation and in good agreement with the corresponding bulk equivalent. The grid indentation method, based on statistical evaluation of a large number of indentations, was influenced by the carbide-matrix interface, which gave rise to a strong third peak apart from the two peaks corresponding to the hard carbides and softer metallic matrix. This makes the statistical analysis much more complex than using simple bimodal Gaussian fit for separation of matrix and carbide properties. Nevertheless, the results of both grid indentation and isolated nanoindentation compared with microindentation values obtained at higher loads gave important information about the cohesion of the coatings.

NiCrAl/ZrO 2 -8Y 2 O 3 coatings deposited on SUS304 stainless steel and 45 carbon steel substrates were prepared by APS at different preheating temperatures, of which thickness exceeded 1mm. This study analyzed the coatings’ separation from different preheated substrates in the cooling process after spraying due to residual thermal stress. The Young’s modulus of the porous YSZ coatings was calculated and also measured by Knoop indentation methods for comparison purposes. The result indicated that the failure of porous thick YSZ coatings is mainly caused by the cracks nucleation, propagation and coalescence, which is related to the thermal-expansion coefficient difference between substrate and coatings, preheating temperature, porosity of coatings and so on. Due to their increased porosity, the porous and thick YSZ coatings had much lower calculated and measured Young’s modulus values than the sintered YSZ coatings.

The FeAl intermetallic compound coatings were sprayed by low pressure plasma spraying (LPPS), air plasma spraying (APS) and high velocity oxy-fuel spraying (HVOF). The influence of three kinds of thermal spraying processes on the microstructure, microhardness, elastic modulus and fracture toughness of coatings were investigated. The results showed that the APS and HVOF coatings exhibited similar microhardness, about 540HV 0.3 , which is much lower than that of LPPS coatings, 860HV 0.3 . The elastic modulus measured for APS, HVOF and LPPS coatings using Knoop indentation were 96, 84, 176GPa, respectively. The APS coatings were also observed to have lower elastic modulus values in the in-plane direction than those in the perpendicular direction, as a result of microcracks scattered within the coatings. In fracture toughness tests, the LPPS coatings revealed the lowest fracture toughness, as compared with other two spraying processes, indicating low porosity and crack levels are related to low fracture toughness. From these results, it appeared that potential improvements to certain mechanical properties can be achieved using low pressure plasma spraying process.