Advanced ultra-supercritical fossil plants operated at 700/725 °C and up to 350 bars are currently planned to be realized in the next decade. Due to the increase of the steam parameters and the use of new materials e.g. 9-11%Cr steels and nickel based alloys the design of highly loaded components is approaching more and more the classical design limits with regard to critical wall thickness and the related tolerable thermal gradients. To make full use of the strength potential of new boiler materials but also taking into account their specific stress-strain relaxation behavior, new methods are required for reliable integrity analyses and lifetime assessment procedures. Numerical Finite Element (FE) simulation using inelastic constitutive equations offers the possibility of “design by analysis” based on state of the art FE codes and user-defined advanced inelastic material laws. Furthermore material specific damage mechanisms must be considered in such assessments. With regard to component behavior beside aspects of multiaxial loading conditions must be considered as well as the behavior of materials and welded joints in the as-built state. Finally an outlook on the capabilities of new multi-scale approaches to describe material and component behavior will be given.

A new nickel-based superalloy, designated as GH750, was developed to meet the requirements of high temperature creep strength and corrosion resistance for superheater/reheater tube application of A-USC power plants at temperatures above 750°C. This paper introduces the design of chemical composition, the process performance of tube fabrication, microstructure and the properties of alloy GH750, including thermodynamic calculation, room temperature and high temperature tensile properties, stress rupture strength and thermal stability. The manufacturing performance of alloy GH750 is excellent and it is easy to forge, hot extrusion and cold rolling. The results of the property evaluation show that alloy GH750 exhibits high tensile strength and tensile ductility at room and high temperatures. The 760°C/100,000h creep rupture strength of this alloy is larger than 100MPa clearly. Microstructure observation indicates that the precipitates of GH750 consist of the precipitation strengthening phase γ’, carbides MC and M 23 C 6 and no harmful and brittle TCP phases were found in the specimens of GH750 after long term exposure at 700~850°C. It can be expected for this new nickel-based superalloy GH750 to be used as the candidate boiler tube materials of A-USC power plants in the future.

The harsh operating conditions of Advanced Ultra-Supercritical (A-USC) power plants, i.e., steam operation conditions up to 760°C (1400°F)/35 MPa (5000 psi), require the use of Ni-based alloys with high temperature performance. Currently, the U.S. Department of Energy Fossil Energy program together with Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI) and Energy Industries of Ohio (EIO) is pursuing a Component Test (Comets) project to address material- and manufacturing-related issues for A-USC applications. Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) is supporting this project in the areas of mechanical and microstructure characterization, weld evaluation, environmental effect studies, etc. In this work, we present results from these activities on two promising Ni-based alloys and their weldments for A-USC applications, i.e., Haynes 282 and Inconel 740H. Detailed results include microhardness, tensile, air and environmental creep, low cycle fatigue, creep-fatigue, environmental high cycle fatigue, and supporting microstructural characterization.

The goal of improving the efficiency of pulverized coal power plants has been pursued for decades. The need for greater efficiency and reduced environmental impact is pushing utilities to ultra supercritical conditions (USC), i.e. steam conditions of 760°C and 35 MPa. The long-term creep strength and environmental resistance requirements imposed by these conditions are clearly beyond the capacity of the currently used ferritic steels and other related alloys. Consequently, new materials based on austenitic stainless steels and nickel-base superalloys are being evaluated as candidate materials for these applications. In the present work, the nickel-base superalloys CCA617, Haynes 230 and Inconel 740, and an austenitic stainless steel Super З04H, were evaluated. The materials were aged for different lengths of time at temperatures relevant to USC applications and the corresponding microstructural changes were characterized by x-ray diffraction, optical, scanning and transmission electron microscopy, with particular attention being given to the structure, morphology and compositions of phases (including γ, γ’, carbides, ordered phases, etc.) and the nature, density and distribution of dislocations and other defects. The results are presented and discussed in light of accompanying changes in microhardness.

A new 12%Cr steel, VM12, has been developed with the combined strength and oxidation resistance characteristics desired for high-temperature applications. The steel increases chromium content by around 0.2% to improve oxidation properties while alloying with other elements such as cobalt, tungsten, and boron to meet a range of requirements, including extending fatigue life. The steel is designed to have the same creep strength as T/P92 but with better oxidation resistance due to the higher chromium content. It has about a 0.2% increase in mechanical properties compared to T/P92 steel. Results are presented for tubes and pipes cast with a variety of surface conditions. In addition, detailed results are provided on the effects of alloying elements on creep and oxidation resistance.

A recent engineering design study conducted by the Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI) has compared the cost and performance of an advanced ultra-supercritical (A-USC) pulverized coal (PC) power plant with main steam temperature of 700°C to that of conventional coal-fired power plant designs: sub-critical, supercritical, and current USC PC plants with main steam temperatures of 541°, 582°, and 605°C, respectively. The study revealed that for a US location in the absence of any cost being imposed for CO 2 emissions the A-USC design was a slightly more expensive choice for electricity production. However, when the marginal cost of the A-USC design is compared to the reduction in CO 2 emissions, it was shown that the cost of the avoided CO 2 emissions was less than $25 per metric ton of CO 2 . This is significantly lower than any technology currently being considered for CO 2 capture and storage (CCS). Additionally by lowering CO 2 /MWh, the A-USC plant also lowers the cost of CCS once integrated with the power plant. It is therefore concluded that A-USC technology should be considered as one of the primary options for minimizing the cost of reducing CO 2 emissions from future coal power plants.

Increasing the efficiency of the Rankine regenerative-reheat steam cycle to improve the economics of electric power generation and to achieve lower cost of electricity has been a long sought after goal. Advanced ultra-supercritical (A-USC) development for materials to reach 760C (1400F) is a goal of the U.S. Program on Materials Technology for Ultrasupercritical Coal-Fired Boilers sponsored by the United States (U.S.) Department of Energy and the Ohio Coal Development Office (OCDO). As part of the development of advanced ultra-supercritical power plants in this program and internally funded programs, a succession of design studies have been undertaken to determine the scope and quantity of materials required to meet 700 to 760C (1292 to 1400F) performance levels. At the beginning of the program in 2002, the current design convention was to use a “two pass” steam generator with a pendant and horizontal tube bank arrangement as the starting point for the economic analysis of the technology. The efficiency improvement achieved with 700C (1292F) plus operation over a 600C (1112F) power plant results in about a 12% reduction in fuel consumption and carbon dioxide emissions. The reduced flue gas weight per MW generated reduces clean up costs for the lower sulfur dioxide, nitrogen oxides and particulate emissions. The operation and start up of the 700C (1292F) plant will be similar in control methods and techniques to a 600C (1112F) plant. Due to arrangement features, the steam temperature control range and the once through minimum circulation flow will be slightly different. The expense of nickel alloy components will be a strong economic incentive for changes in how the steam generator is configured and arranged in the plant relative to the steam turbine. To offer a view into the new plant concepts this paper will discuss what would stay the same and what needs to change when moving up from a 600C (1112F) current state-of-the-art design to a plant design with a 700C (1292F) steam generator and turbine layout.

High temperature strength of a nickel-based superalloy, Alloy 740H, was investigated to evaluate its applicability to advanced ultrasupercritical (A-USC) power plants. A series of tensile, creep and fatigue tests were performed at 700°C, and the high temperature mechanical properties of Alloy 740H was compared with those of other candidate materials such as Alloy 617 and Alloy 263. Although the effect of the strain rate on the 0.2% proof stress was negligible, the ultimate tensile strength and the rupture elongation significantly decreased with decreasing strain rate, and the transgranular fracture at higher strain rate changed to intergranular fracture at lower strain rate. The time to creep rupture of Alloy 740H was longer than those of Alloy 617 and Alloy 263. The fatigue limit of Alloy 740H was about half of the ultimate tensile strength. Further, Alloy 740H showed greater fatigue strength than Alloy 617 and Alloy 263, especially at low strain range.

Alloy 718, widely used for its high-temperature performance in various applications, is being investigated for use in advanced power plants. Driven by the need for efficiency improvements, these plants demand higher temperatures and pressures, putting significant stress on critical components like boiler tubes and turbines. With existing steels and alloys struggling at such high temperatures, researchers are exploring alternatives. New generation plants target steam turbine inlet temperatures of 720°C and pressures of 350MPa, necessitating superalloys for high- and intermediate-pressure rotor sections. The Thermie Advanced project explored the potential of 718 for these applications. A trial rotor disk, forged using advanced processes, underwent a novel heat treatment to enhance microstructural stability and improve creep behavior. Ongoing creep tests exceeding 100,000 hours suggest a potential 50°C increase in the operational limit compared to standard 718. This 12-year research effort holds promise for utilizing 718 in forged components of advanced ultra-supercritical power plant steam turbines, potentially operating up to 700°C.

This paper outlines a comprehensive UK-based research project (2007-2010) focused on developing fireside corrosion models for heat exchangers in ultra-supercritical plants. The study evaluates both conventional materials like T22 and advanced materials such as Super 304H, examining their behavior under various test environments with metal skin temperatures ranging from 425°C to 680°C. The research aims to generate high-quality data on corrosion behavior for materials used in both furnace and convection sections, ultimately producing reliable corrosion prediction models for boiler tube materials operating under demanding conditions. The project addresses some limitations of existing models for these new service conditions and provides a brief review of the fuels and test environments used in the program. Although modeling is still limited, preliminary results have been presented, focusing on predicting fireside corrosion rates for furnace walls, superheaters, and reheaters under various service environments. These environments include those created by oxyfuel operation, coal-biomass co-firing, and more traditional coal firing.

New Monte Carlo models have recently been developed to predict microstructural evolution in steels and aluminum alloys during heat treatment and high-temperature service. These models can control precipitate type and size distribution, distinguishing between pure lattice and grain boundaries. Consequently, they can forecast the precipitate size distribution within grains and on grain boundaries as a function of time. This paper describes the model validation for ferritic Fe-9Cr P92 steels. The model provides new information over a range of time intervals adding up to the total plant lifetime in an ultra-supercritical plant. This information can be incorporated into continuum damage mechanics models for predicting creep rate and stress rupture life. The paper discusses how this technique is used as a materials development tool to forecast necessary compositional modifications for improving creep properties in ferritic steels.

India's current installed power generating capacity is about 225,000 MW, of which about 59% is coal based. It is projected that India would require an installed capacity of over 800,000 MW by 2032. Coal is likely to remain the predominant source of energy in India till the middle of the century. India is also committed to reducing the CO 2 emission intensity of its economy and has drawn up a National Action Plan for Climate Change, which, inter alia, lays emphasis on the deployment of clean coal technologies. With this backdrop, a National Mission for the Development of Advanced Ultra Supercritical Technology has been initiated. The Mission objectives include development of advanced high temperature materials, manufacturing technologies and design of equipment. A corrosion test loop in an existing plant is also proposed. Based on the technology developed, an 800 MW Demonstration A-USC plant will be established. Steam parameters of 310 kg/cm 2 , 710 °C / 720 °C have been selected. Work on selection of materials, manufacture of tubes, welding trials and design of components has been initiated. The paper gives details of India's A-USC program and the progress achieved.

Following the successful completion of a 14-year effort to develop and test materials which would allow advanced ultra-supercritical (A-USC) coal-fired power plants to be operated at steam temperatures up to 760°C, a United States-based consortium has started on a project to build an A-USC component test facility, (A-USC ComTest). Among the goals of the facility are to validate that components made from the advanced alloys can perform under A-USC conditions, to accelerate the development of a U.S.-based supply chain for the full complement of A-USC components, and to decrease the uncertainty for cost estimates of future commercial-scale A-USC power plants. The A-USC ComTest facility will include a gas fired superheater, thick-walled cycling header, steam piping, steam turbine (11 MW nominal size) and valves. Current plans call for the components to be subjected to A-USC operating conditions for at least 8,000 hours by September 2020. The U.S. consortium, principally funded by the U.S. Department of Energy and the Ohio Coal Development Office with co-funding from Babcock & Wilcox, General Electric and the Electric Power Research Institute, is currently working on the Front-End Engineering Design phase of the A-USC ComTest project. This paper will outline the motivation for the project, explain the project’s structure and schedule, and provide details on the design of the facility.

Type IV damage was found at several ultra-supercritical (USC) plants that used creep-strength-enhanced ferritic (CSEF) steels in Japan, and the assessment of the remaining life of the CSEF steels is important for electric power companies. However, there has been little research on the remaining life of material that has actually served at a plant. In this study, the damage and remaining life of a Gr.91 welded elbow pipe that served for 54,000 h at a USC plant were investigated. First, microscopic observation and hardness testing were conducted on specimen cut from the welded joint; the results indicated that the damage to the elbow was more severe in the fine-grain heat-affected zone near the inner surface. Furthermore, creep rupture tests were performed using specimens cut from the welded joint of the elbow, and from these results, the remaining life was evaluated using the time fraction rule as almost 110,000 h. Finite-element analysis was also conducted to assess the damage and remaining life, and the results were compared with the experimental results.

Following the successful completion of a 15-year effort to develop and test materials that would allow advanced ultra-supercritical (A-USC) coal-fired power plants to be operated at steam temperatures up to 760°C, a United States-based consortium has been working on a project (AUSC ComTest) to help achieve technical readiness to allow the construction of a commercial scale A-USC demonstration power plant. Among the goals of the ComTest project are to validate that components made from the advanced alloys can be designed and fabricated to perform under A-USC conditions, to accelerate the development of a U.S.-based supply chain for key A-USC components, and to decrease the uncertainty for cost estimates of future commercial-scale A-USC power plants. This project is intended to bring A-USC technology to the commercial scale demonstration level of readiness by completing the manufacturing R&D of A-USC components by fabricating commercial scale nickel-based alloy components and sub-assemblies that would be needed in a coal fired power plant of approximately 800 megawatts (MWe) generation capacity operating at a steam temperature of 760°C (1400°F) and steam pressure of at least 238 bar (3500 psia).The A-USC ComTest project scope includes fabrication of full scale superheater / reheater components and subassemblies (including tubes and headers), furnace membrane walls, steam turbine forged rotor, steam turbine nozzle carrier casting, and high temperature steam transfer piping. Materials of construction include Inconel 740H and Haynes 282 alloys for the high temperature sections. The project team will also conduct testing and seek to obtain ASME Code Stamp approval for nickel-based alloy pressure relief valve designs that would be used in A-USC power plants up to approximately 800 MWe size. The U.S. consortium, principally funded by the U.S. Department of Energy and the Ohio Coal Development Office under a prime contract with the Energy Industries of Ohio, with co-funding from the power industry participants, General Electric, and the Electric Power Research Institute, has completed the detailed engineering phase of the A-USC ComTest project, and is currently engaged in the procurement and fabrication phase of the work. This paper will outline the motivation for the effort, summarize work completed to date, and detail future plans for the remainder of the A-USC ComTest project.

Preface for the 2004 Advances in Materials Technology for Fossil Power Plants conference.

Ultra supercritical (USC) power plants offer the promise of higher efficiencies and lower emissions, which are goals of the U.S. Department of Energy’s Advanced Power Systems Initiatives. Most current coal power plants in the U.S. operate at a maximum steam temperature of 538°C. However, new supercritical plants worldwide are being brought into service with steam temperatures of up to 620°C. Current Advanced Power Systems goals include coal generation at 60% efficiency, which require steam temperatures of up to 760°C. This research examines the steamside oxidation of advanced alloys for use in USC systems, with emphasis placed on alloys for high- and intermediate-pressure turbine sections. Initial results of this research are presented.

Current state-of-the-art coal-fired supercritical steam power plants operate with high-pressure turbine inlet steam temperatures close to 600°C. The best of the recently developed and commercialized advanced 9-12Cr martensitic-ferritic steels may allow prolonged use at temperatures to about 620°C, but such steels are probably close to their inherent upper temperature limit. Further increase in the temperature capability of advanced steam turbines will certainly require the use of Ni-based superalloys and system redesign, as seen in the European programs that are pioneering advanced power plants capable of operating with 700°C steam. The U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) has recently undertaken a concerted effort to qualify ultra-supercritical boiler tubing and piping alloys for 720/760°C steam for increased efficiency and reduced emissions. It is, therefore, necessary to develop the corresponding USC steam turbine, also capable of reliable operation at such conditions. This paper summarizes a preliminary assessment made by the Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) and the National Energy Technology Laboratory (NETL) of materials needed for ultra-supercritical (USC) steam turbines, balancing both technical and business considerations. These efforts have addressed an expanded portfolio of alloys, that includes austenitic stainless steels and alloys, in addition to various Ni-based superalloys for critical turbine components. Preliminary input from utilities indicates that cost-effective improvements in performance and efficiency that do not sacrifice durability and reliability are prime considerations for any advanced steam turbine technology.

Significant development is being carried out worldwide for establishing advanced ultra supercritical power plant technology which aims enhancement of plant efficiency and reduction of emissions, through increased inlet steam temperature of 750°C and pressure of 350 bar. Nickel base superalloy, 50Ni-24Cr-20Co-0.6Mo-1Al-1.6Ti-2Nb alloy, is being considered as a promising material for superheater tubes and turbine rotors operating at ultra supercritical steam conditions. Thermal fluctuations impose low cycle fatigue loading in creep regime of this material and there is limited published fatigue and creep-fatigue characteristics data available. The scope of the present study includes behavior of the alloy under cyclic loading at operating temperature. Strain controlled low cycle fatigue tests, carried out within the strain range of 0.2%-1%, indicate substantial hardening at all temperatures. It becomes more evident with increasing strain amplitude which is attributed to the cumulative effects of increased dislocation density and immobilization of dislocation by γ′ precipitates. Deformation mechanism which influences fatigue life at 750°C as a function of strain rate is identified. Hold times up to 500 seconds are introduced at 750°C to evaluate the effect of creep fatigue interaction on fatigue crack growth, considered as one of the primary damage mode. The macroscopic performance is correlated with microscopic deformation characteristics.

A study is being conducted on turbine materials for use in ultra-supercritical (USC) steam power plants, with the objective of ensuring no material-related impediments regarding maximum temperature capabilities and the ability to manufacture turbine components. A review of the state-of-the-art and material needs for bolting and casing applications in USC steam turbines was performed to define and prioritize requirements for the next-generation USC turbines. For bolting, several potentially viable nickel-base superalloys were identified for service at 760°C, with the major issues being final material selection and characterization. Factors limiting inner casing material capabilities include casting size/shape, ability to inspect for discontinuities, stress rupture strength, and weldability for fabrication and repairs. Given the need for precipitation-strengthened nickel-base alloys for the inner casing at 760°C, the material needs are two-fold: selection/fabrication-related and characterization. The paper provides background on turbine components and reviews the findings for bolting and casing materials.