Gas turbine blades made from nickel-based superalloys, valued for their high temperature stability and creep resistance, undergo various forms of microstructural degradation during extended service at elevated temperatures that can ultimately lead to blade failure. To extend blade and turbine rotor life, Sulzer has developed evaluation and rejuvenation processes that include microstructural assessment and stress rupture testing of specimens from service-exposed blades. While stress rupture testing presents certain limitations and challenges in evaluating material condition, Sulzer has successfully rejuvenated hundreds of gas turbine blade sets across multiple superalloy types, including GTD 111, IN 738 LC, and U 500, demonstrating the effectiveness of heat treatment rejuvenation in improving microstructure and mechanical properties of service-degraded components.

A research program has been initiated to develop the first predictive methodology for corrosion fatigue life in steam turbine blades, addressing a critical gap in current understanding despite extensive research into corrosion pitting and fatigue failure. The study focuses initially on dual-certified 403/410 12% Cr stainless steel, utilizing a newly developed test facility capable of conducting high-cycle fatigue tests in simulated steam environments at 90°C with controlled corrosive conditions. This testing platform enables the investigation of various steady and cyclic stress conditions, establishing a foundation for future testing of other blade steels and the development of comprehensive blade life estimation techniques.

This study investigates the mechanisms of temper embrittlement in 410 martensitic stainless steel, a material widely used in steam turbine blades due to its excellent corrosion resistance and high strength achieved through quenching and tempering heat treatments. While the material’s hardness and impact toughness strongly depend on tempering temperatures, significant embrittlement occurs around 540°C, manifesting as decreased Charpy impact energy alongside increased strength and hardness. To understand this phenomenon at the nanometer scale, high-resolution transmission electron microscopy (TEM) analysis was performed, focusing on electron diffraction patterns along the <110>α-Fe and <113>α-Fe zone axes. The analysis revealed distinctive double electron diffraction spots at 1/3(211) and 2/3(211) positions, with lattice spacing of approximately 3.5 Å—triple the typical α-bcc lattice spacing (1.17 Å). These regions were identified as metastable “zones” resembling ω-phase structures, potentially responsible for the embrittlement. While this newly identified phase structure may not fully explain the complex mechanisms of temper embrittlement, it provides valuable insights for developing improved alloying and heat treatment methods to mitigate embrittlement in martensitic steels.

Research and development of 700°C A-USC steam turbine unit needs to be supported by materials with excellent overall performance. Waspaloy is a kind of γ′ phase precipitation hardening superalloy developed by the United States in the 1950s. In the 700°C R&D Plan of Shanghai Turbine Plant, it was selected as a candidate material for high temperature blades and bolts. The composition, microstructure, properties, blade die forging process and bolt rolling process of Waspaloy alloy were researched in this paper. Simultaneously, Shanghai Turbine Plant successfully manufactured Waspaloy alloy trial production for high temperature bolts and blades. The results show that Waspaloy not only has excellent processing performance, but also has good high temperature strength, long-term performance, stress relaxation resistance and long term aging performance stability at 700°C. It can fully meet the requirements of high-temperature blades and bolts of 700°C A-USC unit. It shows that the 700°C A-USC unit high temperature blades and bolts were successfully developed by Shanghai Turbine Plant.

Based on the research and development of Ni-based alloy of 700°C steam turbine bolts and blades worldwide, the process, microstructure, properties characteristics and strengthening mechanism of typical 700°C steam turbine bolts and blades materials Waspaloy are discussed in this study. The result shows that Waspaloy has higher elevated temperature yield strength, creep rupture strength, anti-stress relaxation property and good microstructure stability. The Waspaloy alloy could meet the design requirements of 700°C steam turbine bolts and blades.

Coatings are an essential part of the materials system to protect the turbine blades from oxidation and corrosive attack during service. Inter-diffusion of alloying elements between a turbine blade substrate and their coatings is a potential concern for coated turbine blades at ever increasing operating temperatures because this can cause the formation of undesirable Secondary Reaction Zones (SRZs), which may degrade the mechanical properties of coated Ni-based superalloys. Understanding the effects of each element on the SRZ formation is essential in order to understand both the mechanism and inter-diffusion behaviour between coatings and substrates. In this research, a number of simpler aluminized ternary Ni-Al-X (where X is Co, Cr, Re, Ru or Ta) alloys were investigated in order to elucidate the separate effects of each element on the microstructural evolution, especially at the coating/substrate interface. The aluminized ternary alloys developed distinctive diffusion zones, depending on the third alloy element, ‘X’. Specifically, it has been found that both Ni-Al-Re and Ni-Al-Ta alloys developed a continuous SRZ-like diffusion layer. This diffusion zone persisted in the Ni-Al-Re alloys after high temperature exposure, indicating that Re has a stronger effect on SRZ formation than Ta.

Gas turbine blades are operated in a high temperature and a high pressure. In order to cope with that harsh condition, the blades are made of Nickel based superalloys which show excellent performance in such environment. Manufacturers of the blades usually provide the standards for the blade inspection and replacement. According to their guide, the blades are replaced after 3 times of operations and 2 times of refurbishments. Howsoever, purchase the new blades is always costly and burdensome to the power plant owners hence, the assessment of the blade lifespan and the rejuvenation of the degraded blades are indeed crucial to them. In this study, the optimal rejuvenation conditions for gas turbine blades were derived and verified. In addition to that, the creep durability was evaluated based on the actual blade inspection interval. LCF tests have been carried out on the rejuvenated blade and the result was compared with the fatigue life of the new blades. In order to secure the safety of the rejuvenated blade during operation, a heat flow analysis was performed to simulate the operating conditions of the gas turbine during operation, and the main stress and strain areas were investigated through the analysis results. And then LCF and creep considering the actual operating conditions were evaluated. The calculated life of fatigue and creep life is compared to the hot gas path inspection interval. For the rejuvenated blades, the creep life and the LCF interval were reviewed based on the temperature, stress, and strain acquired by computational analysis. The creep life was calculated as 59,363 hours by LMP curve, and the LCF was calculated as 2,560 cycles by the Manson Coffin graph.

Increasing demand for reliable design of all kinds of structures requires materials properties evaluated under the conditions as close to real service conditions as possible. Presently resolved project dealing with development of new turbine blades geometry requires better understanding of the material behavior under service conditions. Service conditions of turbine blades are cyclic loading at high temperatures under superheated steam conditions and complex mechanical loading. There are not commercially available testing systems providing such functionality and thus the system allowing samples testing under considered conditions was developed. The system allows cyclic loading at temperatures up to 650°C under superheated steam conditions. Typical blade steel is investigated here and experimental approach considering complex mechanical loading as well as thermal and corrosion is shown here. The results of high cycle fatigue tests in superheated steam corrosive environment are shown here.

High gamma prime Ni-based superalloys comprising ≥3.5 % Al are difficult to weld due to high propensity of these materials to weld solidification, heat affected zone liquation, and stress-strain cracking. In this study the root cause analysis of cracking and overview on the developed weldable Ni-based superalloys for repair of turbine engine components manufactured from equiaxed (EA), directionally solidified (DS), and single crystal (SX) materials as well as for 3D AM is provided. It is shown that the problem with the solidification and HAZ liquation cracking of turbine engine components manufactured from EA and DS superalloys was successfully resolved by modification of welding materials with boron and silicon to provide a sufficient amount of eutectic at terminal solidification to promote self-healing of liquation cracks along the weld - base material interface. For crack repair of turbine engine components and 3D AM ductile LW4280, LW7901 and LCT materials were developed. It is shown that LW7901 and LCT welding materials comprising 30 - 32 wt.% Co produced sound welds by GTAW-MA on various SX and DS materials. Welds demonstrated high ductility, desirable combination of strength and oxidation properties for tip repair of turbine blades. Examples of tip repair of turbine blades are provided.

It is required to reduce the lifetime cost of turbine blades. To achieve the cost reduction, a refining and recycling method of scrapped turbine blades is proposed. For the establishment of the method, desulfurization mechanism of Ni-base superalloy by solid CaO was studied. 500 g of superalloy containing sulfur was heated in a vacuum induction furnace and kept at 1600 °C. A CaO rod was inserted into the molten alloy and held for 600 s. After the experiment, sulfur content in the alloy decreased from 200 ppm to 54 ppm. On the surface of the CaO rod after the experiment, only Ca, O, Al, and S were found by EPMA analysis. Especially, Al and S were distributed at the surface and grain boundaries of the rod. By powder XRD analysis, CaO, CaS and 3CaO･Al 2 O 3 were identified as constituent phases on the rod. The desulfurization mechanism of superalloy at 1600 °C is supposed to be three steps: (1) Al and S in the alloy react with CaO to generate CaS and Al 2 O 3 , respectively. (2) Al 2 O 3 melts with CaO as liquid slag. (3) CaS is captured by the slag, therefore, sulfur is removed from the alloy.

Solid particle erosion (SPE) and liquid droplet erosion (LDE) cause severe damage to turbine components and lead to premature failures, business loss and rapier costs to power plant owners and operators. Under a program funded by the Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI), nano­coatings are under development for application in steam and gas turbines to mitigate the adverse effects of PE and LPE on rotating blades and stationary vanes. Based on a thorough study of the available information, most promising coatings such as nano-structured titanium silicon carbo-nitride (TiSiCN), titanium nitride (TiN) and multilayered nano coatings were selected. TurboMet International (TurboMet) teamed with Southwest Research Institute (SwRI) with state-of-the-art nano-technology coating facilities with plasma enhanced magnetron sputtering (PEMS) method to apply these coatings on various substrates. Ti-6V-4Al, 12Cr, 17-4PH, and Custom 450 stainless steel substrates were selected based on the current alloys used in gas turbine compressors and steam turbine blades and vanes. Coatings with up to 30 micron thickness have been deposited on small test coupons. These are extremely hard coatings with good adhesion strength and optimum toughness. Tests conducted on coated coupons by solid particle erosion (SPE) and liquid droplet erosion (LDE) testing indicate that these coatings have excellent erosion resistance. The erosion resistance under both SPE and LDE test conditions showed the nano-structured coatings have high erosion resistance compared to other commercially produced erosion resistance coatings. Tension and high-cycle fatigue test results revealed that the hard nano-coatings do not have any adverse effects on these properties but may provide positive contribution.

Large scale components of the conventional 600°C class steam turbine were made of the ferritic steel, but the steam turbine plants with main steam temperatures of 700°C or above (A-USC) using the Ni-base superalloys are now being developed in order to further improve the thermal efficiency. The weight of the turbine rotor for the A-USC exceeds 10ton. A lot of high strength superalloys for aircraft engines or industrial gas turbines have been developed up to now. But it is difficult to manufacture the large-scale parts for the steam turbine plants using these conventional high strength superalloys because of their poor manufacturability. To improve high temperature strength without losing manufacturability of the large scale components for the A-USC steam turbine plants, we developed Ni-base superalloy USC800(Ni-23Co-18Cr-8W-4Al-0.1C [mass %]) which has temperature capability of 800°C with high manufacturability achieved by controlling microstructure stability and segregation property. The 700°C class A-USC materials are the mainstream of current development, and trial production of 10 ton-class forged parts has been reported. However, there have been no reports on the development and trial manufacturing of the A-USC materials with temperature capability of 800°C. In this report, results of trial manufacturing and its microstructure of the developed superalloy which has both temperature capability 800°C and good manufacturability are presented. The trial manufacturing of the large forging, boiler tubes and turbine blades using developed material were successfully achieved. According to short term creep tests of the large forging and the tube approximate 100,000h creep strength of developed material was estimated to be 270MPa at 700 °C and 100MPa at 800°C.

MoSiBTiC alloy is a promising material for advanced aerospace applications and next generation high pressure turbine blades in jet engines and gas turbines. It mainly consists of Mo solid solution, TiC and Mo 5 SiB 2 phases and has creep strength much stronger than Ni-base superalloys and better than SiC/SiC ceramic matrix composites. Furthermore, the fracture toughness of the alloy is much better (>15 MPa(m) 1/2 ) than Mo-Si-B ternary alloys (<10 MPa(m) 1/2 ) even if the volume fraction of Mo solid solution is less than 50 %. The improvement of fracture toughness would be caused not only by the continuity of Mo solid solution in solidification microstructure but also by TiC phase affecting as a fracture-resistant phase. In order to understand the microstructure evolution during solidification and the effect of TiC phase on the fracture toughness of the MoSiBTiC alloy, Mo-Ti-C ternary model alloys are dealt with in this study. Then, (1) liquidus surface projection and (2) isothermal section and the elastic moduli of TiC phase in equilibrium with Mo solid solution were focused on. The obtained liquidus surface projection suggests that the ternary transition peritectic reaction (L+ Mo 2 C->Mo+TiC) takes place in Mo-rich region. At 1800 °C, TiC phase in equilibrium with Mo phase contains at least 20.2 at% Mo and the Mo/TiC/Mo 2 C three phase region should exist around Mo-15Ti-10C.

Low thermal expansion precipitation strengthening Ni-base superalloy, Ni-20Cr-10Mo-1.2Al-1.6Ti alloy (USC141TM), was developed for 700°C class A-USC steam turbine material by Hitachi, Ltd and Hitachi Metals, Ltd. USC141 is usually solution treated and then aged to increase high temperature strength for turbine blades and bolts. As the estimated 105h creep rupture strength at 700°C is about 180MPa, USC141 could also be expected to apply for boiler tubes. On the other hand, this alloy seems to be only solution treated to apply for boiler tubes because tubes are usually jointed by welding and bended by cold working and thus tube alloys should have low hardness before welding and bending and should be used as solution treated. In this study, the creep properties of USC141 as solution treated was evaluated, and the results and microstructures after creep tests were compared with those as aged. As a result, USC141 as solution treated exhibited almost as same creep rupture properties as that as aged because precipitation at grain boundaries and in grains gradually increased at testing temperatures around 700°C. Furthermore seamless tubes of USC141 were produced and various properties including creep properties are now being evaluated.

Recently, a γ’ precipitation strengthened Ni-base superalloy, USC141, was developed for 700°C class A-USC boiler tubes as well as turbine blades. In boiler tube application, the creep rupture strength of USC141 was much higher than that of Alloy617, and the 105 hours’ creep rupture strength of USC141 was estimated to be about 180MPa at 700°C. This is because fine γ’ particles precipitate in austenite grains and some kinds of intermetallic compounds and carbides precipitate along austenite grain boundaries during creep tests. Good coal ash corrosion resistance is also required for tubes at around 700°C. It is known that coal ash corrosion resistance depends on the contents of Cr and Mo in Ni-base superalloys. Therefore the effect of Cr and Mo contents in USC141 on coal ash corrosion resistance, tensile properties, and creep rupture strengths were investigated. As a result, the modified USC141 containing not less than 23% Cr and not more than 7% Mo showed better hot corrosion resistance than the original USC141. This modified alloy also showed almost the same mechanical properties as the original one. Furthermore the trial production of the modified USC141 tubes is now in progress.

Additive manufacturing (AM) is a process where, as the name suggests, material is added during production, in contrast to techniques such as machining, where material is removed. With metals, AM processes involve localised melting of a powder or wire in specific locations to produce a part, layer by layer. AM techniques have recently been applied to the repair of gas turbine blades. These components are often produced from nickel-based superalloys, a group of materials which possess excellent mechanical properties at high temperatures. However, although the microstructural and mechanical property evolution during the high temperature exposure of conventionally produced superalloy materials is reasonably well understood, the effects of prolonged high temperature exposure on AM material are less well known. This research is concerned with the microstructures of components produced using AM techniques and an examination of the effect of subsequent high temperature exposures. In particular, the paper will focus on the differences between cast and SLM IN939 as a function of heat treatment and subsequent ageing, including differences in grain structure and precipitate size, distribution and morphology, quantified using advanced electron microscopy techniques.

The steam oxidation behaviour of boiler tubes and steam piping components is a limiting factor for improving the efficiency of the current power plants. Spallation of the oxide scales formed during service can cause serious damage to the turbine blades. Vallourec has implemented an innovative solution based on an aluminum diffusion coating applied on the inner surface of the T/P92 steel. The functionality of this coating is to protect the tubular components against spallation and increase the actual operating temperature of the metallic components. In the present study, the newly developed VALIORTM T/P92 product was tested at the EDF La Maxe power plant (France) under 167b and 545°C (steam temperature). After 3500h operation, the tubes were removed and characterized by Light Optical Metallography (LOM), Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM), with Energy Dispersive X-ray spectrometry (EDX) and X-Ray Diffraction (XRD). The results highlight the excellent oxidation resistance of VALIORTM T/P92 product by the formation of a protective aluminum oxide scale. In addition, no enhanced oxidation was observed on the areas close to the welds. These results are compared with the results obtained from laboratory steam oxidation testing performed on a 9%Cr T/P92 steel with and without VALIORTM coating exposed in Ar-50%H 2 O at 650°C.

For the safe life prediction of components under high cycle fatigue loading at high temperature, such as gas turbine blades and turbocharger components, the behavior of initial defects, which are physically short cracks below the long crack threshold ΔK is of crucial importance. The evolution of different crack closure mechanisms (such as plasticity, roughness and oxide induced crack closure) can lead to crack arrest by a reduction of the effective crack tip loading. To visualize the crack growth behavior of such cracks, cyclic crack resistance curves (cyclic R-curves) are used. The experimental determination of cyclic R-curves is challenging, especially under high temperature conditions due to a lack of optical accessibility. The formation of very short cracks in high strength materials makes it even more complicated to reliably determine these data. Within this study the crack growth behavior of physically short fatigue cracks in three different material states of the nickel alloy IN718 (wrought, cast and PBF-LB/M - processed) is experimentally determined at 650 °C. Based on a load increase procedure applied on Single Edge Notched (SEN) specimens with a compression pre-cracking procedure in advance, crack propagation of physically short cracks is measured with alternating current potential drop systems in air and under vacuum conditions. These examinations are carried out for three different load ratios (R = -1, 0 and 0.5) to investigate the amount of certain crack closure mechanisms active under different loading conditions. Moreover, the formation of a plastic wake along the crack flanks is determined by a finite element simulation. The results determined in air and under vacuum conditions are used to describe the impact of oxide induced crack closure on the behavior of physically short cracks. This allows the evaluation of the behavior of both near-surface and internal defects that are not accessible to the atmosphere.

Enhancement of the steam conditions is one of the most effective measures to achieve the goal of higher thermal efficiency. 700°C class A-USC (Advanced Ultra Super Critical Steam Conditions) power plant is one of the remarkable technologies to achieve the goal and reduce CO 2 emissions from fossil fuel power plants. Toshiba has been working on the A-USC development project with subsidy from METI (Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry) and NEDO (New Energy and Industrial Technology Development Organization). In this project, A-USC power plants with steam parameters of 35MPa 700/720/720°C were considered. To date, various materials have been developed and tested to verify their characteristics for use in A-USC power plants. And some of these materials are being investigated as to their suitability for use in long term. Together with members of the project, we carried out the boiler component test using a commercially-operating boiler. We manufactured a small-scale turbine casing made of nickel-based alloy, and supplied it for the test. In addition, we manufactured a turbine rotor for turbine rotation tests, and carried out the test at 700°C and rotating speed of 3,600rpm conditions. In this paper, we show the results of the A-USC steam turbine development obtained by the project.

In the context of research of lighter and/or stronger high temperature materials in order to improve aeroengines, the present work shows an example of a powder metallurgy (PM) manufacturing route for TiAl alloys that could be used for low pressure turbine (LPT) blades processing. In this frame, two different alloys, Ti-47Al-1Fe-1Zr-1Mo-0.2Si (at. %) FZM and Ti- 43.5A1-4Nb-1Mo-0.1B (at.%) TNM-B1, were gas-atomized into powders, extruded, heat-treated and mechanically tested.