In both direct- and indirect-fired supercritical CO 2 (sCO 2 ) cycles, there is considerable interest in increasing the size and efficiency of such systems, perhaps by increasing the peak temperature to >700°C. However, relatively little experimental data are available under these conditions with pressures of 200-300 bar. Furthermore, impurities such as O 2 and H 2 O in the CO 2 may greatly alter the compatibility of structural alloys in these environments. While an experimental rig is being constructed that can measure and control the impurity levels in sCO 2 at 200-300 bar, initial 1 bar experiments at 700°-800°C for 500 h have been conducted in high-purity and industrial grade CO 2 , CO 2 +0.15O 2 and CO 2 +10%H 2 O and compared to exposures in dry air and 200 bar sCO 2 . These results, focusing on Fe- and Ni-base structural alloys and commercial chromia- and alumina-forming alloys, indicate that modifications in the environment did not strongly affect the reaction products at 700°-800°C.

Direct-fired supercritical CO 2 (sCO 2 ) cycles are expected to result in sCO 2 with higher impurity levels compared to indirect-fired cycles. Prior work at ambient pressure showed minimal effects of O 2 and H 2 O additions, however, a new experimental rig has been built to have flowing controlled impurity levels at supercritical pressures at ≤800°C. Based on industry input, the first experiment was conducted at 750°C/300 bar in CO 2 +1%O 2 -0.25%H 2 O using 500-h cycles for up to 5,000 h. Compared to research grade sCO 2 , the results indicate faster reaction rates for Fe-based alloys like 310HN and smaller increases for Ni-based alloys like alloys 617B and 282. It is difficult to quantify the 310HN rate increase because of scale spallation. Characterization of the 5,000 h specimens indicated a thicker reaction product formed, which has not been observed in previous impurity studies at ambient pressure. These results suggest that more studies of impurity effects are needed at supercritical pressures including steels at lower temperatures.

Supercritical CO 2 (sCO 2 ) is of interest as a working fluid for several concepts including the direct- fired Allam cycle as a low-emission fossil energy power cycle. Over the past 10 years, laboratory exposures at 300 bar sCO 2 have found reasonably good compatibility for Ni-based alloys at <800°C, including an assessment of the sCO 2 impact on room temperature mechanical properties after 750°C exposures. However, initial screening tests at 1 and 20 bar CO 2 at 900°-1100°C showed poor compatibility for Ni-based alloys. In an open cycle, the introduction of 1%O 2 and 0.1- 0.25%H 2 O impurities at 300 bar increased the reaction rates ≥2X at 750°C. At lower temperatures, steels are susceptible to C ingress and embrittlement. Creep-strength enhanced ferritic steels may be limited to <550°C and conventional stainless steels to <600°C. Two strategies to increase those temperatures are higher Ni and Cr alloying additions and Al- or Cr-rich coatings. Alloy 709 (Fe- 20Cr-25Ni) shows some promising results at 650°C in sCO 2 but reaction rates were accelerated with the addition of O 2 and H 2 O impurities. Pack aluminized and chromized Gr.91 (Fe-9Cr-1Mo) and type 316H stainless steel show some promise at 600°-650°C but further coating optimization is needed.

Long-term performance of high temperature alloys is critically linked to the oxidation behavior in power generation applications in wet air and steam. As power generation systems move towards higher efficiency operation, nextgeneration fossil, nuclear and concentrating solar power plants are considering supercritical CO 2 cycle above 700°C. Wrought solid solution strengthened and precipitations strengthened alloys are leading candidates for both steam and Supercritical CO 2 power cycles. This study evaluates the cyclic oxidation behavior of HAYNES 230, 282, and 625 alloys in wet air, flowing laboratory air, steam and in 1 and 300 bar Supercritical CO 2 at ~750°C for duration of 1000 -10,000h. Test samples were thermally cycled for various times at temperature followed by cooling to room temperature. Alloy performances were assessed by analyzing the weight change behavior and extent of attack. The results clearly demonstrated the effects of alloy composition and environment on the long-term cyclic oxidation resistance. The extents of attack varied from alloy to alloy but none of the alloys underwent catastrophic corrosion and no significant internal carburization was observed in supercritical CO 2 . The performance of these alloys indicates that these materials are compatible not only in oxidizing environments, but also in Supercritical CO 2 environments for extended service operation.

The effect of gas impurities on corrosion behavior of candidate Fe- and Ni-base alloys (SS 316LN, Alloy 800HT, Alloy 600) in high temperature CO 2 environment was investigated in consideration of actual S-CO 2 cycle applications. Preliminary testing in research and industrial grade S-CO 2 at 600 °C (20 MPa) for 1000 h showed that oxidation rates were significantly reduced in industrial-grade S-CO 2 environment. Meanwhile, controlled tests with individual impurity additions such as CH 4 , CO, and O 2 in research-grade CO 2 were performed. The results indicated that CH 4 and CO additions did not seem to significantly affect oxidation rates. On the other hand, O 2 addition resulted in lower weight gains for all alloys, suggesting that O 2 may be primarily affecting corrosion behavior.

Structural alloy corrosion is a major concern for the design and operation of supercritical carbon dioxide (sCO 2 ) power cycles. Looking towards the future of sCO 2 system development, the ability to measure real-time alloy corrosion would be invaluable to informing operation and maintenance of these systems. Sandia has recently explored methods available for in-situ alloy corrosion monitoring. Electrical resistance (ER) was chosen for initial tests due the operational simplicity and commercial availability. A series of long duration (>1000 hours) experiments have recently been completed at a range of temperatures (400-700°C) using ER probes made from four important structural alloys (C1010 Carbon Steel, 410ss, 304L, 316L) being considered for sCO 2 systems. Results from these tests are presented, including correlations between the probe measured corrosion rate to that for witness coupons of the same alloys.

Following the successful completion of a 14-year effort to develop and test materials which would allow advanced ultra-supercritical (A-USC) coal-fired power plants to be operated at steam temperatures up to 760°C, a United States-based consortium has started on a project to build an A-USC component test facility, (A-USC ComTest). Among the goals of the facility are to validate that components made from the advanced alloys can perform under A-USC conditions, to accelerate the development of a U.S.-based supply chain for the full complement of A-USC components, and to decrease the uncertainty for cost estimates of future commercial-scale A-USC power plants. The A-USC ComTest facility will include a gas fired superheater, thick-walled cycling header, steam piping, steam turbine (11 MW nominal size) and valves. Current plans call for the components to be subjected to A-USC operating conditions for at least 8,000 hours by September 2020. The U.S. consortium, principally funded by the U.S. Department of Energy and the Ohio Coal Development Office with co-funding from Babcock & Wilcox, General Electric and the Electric Power Research Institute, is currently working on the Front-End Engineering Design phase of the A-USC ComTest project. This paper will outline the motivation for the project, explain the project’s structure and schedule, and provide details on the design of the facility.

Following the successful completion of a 15-year effort to develop and test materials that would allow advanced ultra-supercritical (A-USC) coal-fired power plants to be operated at steam temperatures up to 760°C, a United States-based consortium has been working on a project (AUSC ComTest) to help achieve technical readiness to allow the construction of a commercial scale A-USC demonstration power plant. Among the goals of the ComTest project are to validate that components made from the advanced alloys can be designed and fabricated to perform under A-USC conditions, to accelerate the development of a U.S.-based supply chain for key A-USC components, and to decrease the uncertainty for cost estimates of future commercial-scale A-USC power plants. This project is intended to bring A-USC technology to the commercial scale demonstration level of readiness by completing the manufacturing R&D of A-USC components by fabricating commercial scale nickel-based alloy components and sub-assemblies that would be needed in a coal fired power plant of approximately 800 megawatts (MWe) generation capacity operating at a steam temperature of 760°C (1400°F) and steam pressure of at least 238 bar (3500 psia).The A-USC ComTest project scope includes fabrication of full scale superheater / reheater components and subassemblies (including tubes and headers), furnace membrane walls, steam turbine forged rotor, steam turbine nozzle carrier casting, and high temperature steam transfer piping. Materials of construction include Inconel 740H and Haynes 282 alloys for the high temperature sections. The project team will also conduct testing and seek to obtain ASME Code Stamp approval for nickel-based alloy pressure relief valve designs that would be used in A-USC power plants up to approximately 800 MWe size. The U.S. consortium, principally funded by the U.S. Department of Energy and the Ohio Coal Development Office under a prime contract with the Energy Industries of Ohio, with co-funding from the power industry participants, General Electric, and the Electric Power Research Institute, has completed the detailed engineering phase of the A-USC ComTest project, and is currently engaged in the procurement and fabrication phase of the work. This paper will outline the motivation for the effort, summarize work completed to date, and detail future plans for the remainder of the A-USC ComTest project.

Advanced power systems that operate at temperatures higher than about 650°C will require nickel-base alloys in critical areas for pressure containment. Age-hardened alloys offer an additional advantage of reduced volume of material compared with lower strength solid solution-strengthened alloys if thinner tube wall can be specified. To date, the only age-hardened alloy that has been approved for service in the time dependent temperature regime in the ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code is INCONEL alloy 740H. Extensive evaluation of seamless tube, pipe, and forged fittings in welded construction, including implant test loops and pilot plants, has shown the alloy to be fit for service in the 650-800°C (1202-1472°F) temperature range. Since, nickel-base alloys are much more expensive than steel, manufacturing methods that reduce the cost of material for advanced power plants are of great interest. One process that has been extensively used for stainless steels and solution-strengthened nickel-base alloys is continuous seam welding. This process has rarely been applied to age-hardened alloys and never for use as tube in the creep-limited temperature regime. This paper presents the initial results of a study to develop alloy 740H welded tube, pipe and fittings and to generate data to support establishment of ASME code maximum stress allowables.

The Advanced Materials and Manufacturing Technologies (AMMT) program is aiming at the accelerated incorporation of new materials and manufacturing technologies into nuclear-related systems. Complex Ni-based components fabricated by laser powder bed fusion (LPBF) could enable operating temperatures at T > 700°C in aggressive environments such as molten salts or liquid metals. However, available mechanical properties data relevant to material qualification remains limited, in particular for Ni-based alloys routinely fabricated by LPBF such as IN718 (Ni- 19Cr-18Fe-5Nb-3Mo) and Haynes 282 (Ni-20Cr-10Co-8.5Mo-2.1Ti-1.5Al). Creep testing was conducted on LPBF 718 at 600°C and 650°C and on LPBF 282 at 750°C. finding that the creep strength of the two alloys was close to that of wrought counterparts. with lower ductility at rupture. Heat treatments were tailored to the LPBF-specific microstructure to achieve grain recrystallization and form strengthening γ' precipitates for LPBF 282 and γ' and γ" precipitates for LPBF 718. In-situ data generated during printing and ex-situ X-ray computed tomography (XCT) scans were used to correlate the creep properties of LPBF 282 to the material flaw distribution. In- situ data revealed that spatter particles are the potential causes for flaws formation in LPBF 282. with significant variation between rods based on their location on the build plate. XCT scans revealed the formation of a larger number of creep flaws after testing in the specimens with a higher initial flaw density. which led to a lower ductility for the specimen.

This paper addresses the limitations of P92 steel used in ultra-supercritical power plants, particularly ferrite formation in thick components and its impact on short- and long-term properties. A guideline for determining ferritic content in P92 steel is presented. Furthermore, a novel 12% Cr boiler steel grade, VM12-SHC, is introduced. This new material offers good creep properties and oxidation resistance, overcoming the limitations of P92 steel. Finally, the development of matching filler metals for welding P92 and VM12-SHC steels is presented, ensuring optimal weld compatibility and performance in power plant applications.