Steel castings of creep-resistant steels are critical components in the high and intermediate pressure turbine sections of fossil fuel-fired power plants. As plant efficiencies improve and emission standards tighten, steam parameters become more stringent, necessitating constant enhancement of material creep resistance. Steel foundries alone cannot conduct necessary material development at an appropriate scale, so all power plant component suppliers cooperate to define optimal chemical compositions, perform test melts, creep tests, microstructure investigations, and test pilot components, such as through the COST program developing new 9-12%Cr cast steel grades. This paper illustrates a steel foundry's role in COST, describing the transfer of these new cast steel grades from research into commercial production of heavy cast components, outlining incurred problems, process development cycles, comparisons with low-alloy steels, welding tests, base material/weld investigations, heat treatment optimization, and casting of pilot components/weldability test plates to verify castability of larger parts and make necessary adjustments. Parallel to ongoing COST creep tests, the steel grades were introduced into commercial large component production, involving solutions to process-related issues, with over 180 components successfully manufactured to date, while further COST program developments present ongoing challenges.

Advanced martensitic 9% chromium steels have been identified as the most favored group of materials for high temperature applications in thermal power plants. To extend the temperature range of martensitic steels up to 650°C large effort was put on the development of new alloy concepts. The so-called MARBN concept (Martensitic steel with defined Boron/Nitrogen relation) provides increased creep rupture strength due to higher solid solution strengthening and improved microstructural stability. The major improvement is the reduction of type IV cracking in welded joints, which shifts the focus to the creep rupture strength of the weld metal. This paper illustrates the process experience of the steel foundry for production of heavy cast components in latest state of the art 9-12%Cr-MoCoVNbNB-alloyed cast steel grades and the newest state of development and prototype components in MARBN cast steel grades. Metallurgy, solidification, heat treatment and welding are main items to be considered for development of new, complex steel grades for foundry processing with the help of empiric processing in test programs and thermo-physical simulation. As welding is an essential processing step in the production of heavy steel cast components a good out-of-position weldability is required. Moreover a stress-relieve heat-treatment takes place subsequently after welding for several hours. This contribution also deals with the development of matching welding consumables for the production of heavy cast components and discusses the challenges of defining appropriate welding and heat treatment parameters to meet the requirements of sufficient strength and toughness at ambient temperature. Additionally, first results of creep rupture tests are presented.

The necessity to reduce carbon dioxide emissions of new fossil plant, while increasing net efficiency has lead to the development of not only new steels for potential plant operation of 650°C, but also cast nickel alloys for potential plant operation of up to 700°C and maybe 750°C. This paper discusses the production of prototype MarBN steel castings for potential plant operation up to 650°C, and gamma prime strengthened nickel alloys for advanced super critical plant (A-USC) operation up to 750°C. MarBN steel is a modified 9% Cr steel with chemical concentration of Cobalt and tungsten higher than that of CB2 (GX-13CrMoCoVNbNB9) typically, 2% to 3 Co, 3%W, with controlled B and N additions. The paper will discuss the work undertaken on prototype MarBN steel castings produced in UK funded research projects, and summarise the results achieved. Additionally, within European projects a castable nickel based super alloy has successfully been developed. This innovative alloy is suitable for 700°C+ operation and offers a solution to many of the issues associated with casting precipitation hardened nickel alloys.

A global movement is pushing for improved efficiency in power plants to reduce fossil fuel consumption and CO 2 emissions. While raising operating temperatures and pressures can enhance thermal efficiency, it necessitates materials with exceptional high-temperature performance. Currently, steels used in power plants operating up to 600°C achieve efficiencies of 38-40%. Advanced Ultra Supercritical (A-USC) designs aim for a significant leap, targeting steam temperatures of 700°C and pressures of 35 MPa with a lifespan exceeding 100,000 hours. Ni-based superalloys are leading candidates for these extreme conditions due to their superior strength and creep resistance. Haynes 282, a gamma prime (γ′) precipitation-strengthened alloy, is a promising candidate for A-USC turbine engines, exhibiting excellent creep properties and thermal stability. This research investigates the microstructural evolution in large, sand-cast components of Haynes 282. Microstructure, referring to the arrangement of grains and phases within the material, significantly impacts its properties. The research examines the alloy in its as-cast condition and after various pre-service heat treatments, aiming to fully identify and quantify the microstructural changes. These findings are then compared with predictions from thermodynamic equilibrium calculations using a dedicated Ni alloy database. The research reveals that variations in heat treatment conditions can significantly affect the microstructure development in Haynes 282, potentially impacting its mechanical properties.

The drive for reduced carbon dioxide emissions and improved efficiency in coal fire power plant has led to much work being carried out around the world with regards to material development to enable 700+°C steam temperature operation. At these elevated temperatures and pressures steels just don’t have enough strength, and typically have a temperature limit of around 620°C (possibly up to 650°C in the near future) in the HP environment. Therefore, material development has focused on nickel alloys. European programs such as AD700, COMTES, European 50+ and more recently, NextGen Power and Macplus, have investigated the use of nickel alloys in the steam turbine. Large castings have an important role within the steam turbine, because valves bodies and turbine casings are nearly always produced from a cast component. The geometry of these components is often complex, and therefore, the advantage of using castings for such items is that near net shapes can be produced with minimal machining. This is important, as nickel alloys are expensive, and machining is difficult, so castings offer an attractive cost benefit. Cast shapes can be more efficiently designed with regards to stress management. For example, contouring of fillet regions can help to reduce stress concentrations leads to reduced plant maintenance and casting complex shapes reduces the number of onsite fabrication welds to inspect during outage regimes.

The voestalpine foundry group, operating at locations in Linz and Traisen, Austria, specializes in heavy steel casting components ranging from 1 to 200 tons for power generation, oil and gas, chemical processing, and offshore applications. Their manufacturing expertise encompasses high-alloyed martensitic 9-12% Cr-steels and nickel-based Alloy 625, particularly for ultra-supercritical (USC) and advanced USC power generation systems operating at temperatures from 600°C to over 700°C. The production of these complex, thick-walled components relies on advanced thermodynamic calculation and simulation for all thermal processes, from material development through final casting. The foundries’ comprehensive capabilities include specialized melting, molding, heat treatment, non-destructive testing, and fabrication welding, with particular emphasis on joining dissimilar cast, forged, and rolled materials. Looking toward future innovations, the group is exploring additive manufacturing for mold production and robotic welding systems to enhance shaping and surface finishing capabilities.

The A-USC technology is still under development due to limited number of materials complying with the requirements of high creep strength and high performance in highly aggressive corrosion environments. Development of power plant in much higher temperatures than A-USC is currently impossible due to the materials limitation. Currently, nickel-based superalloys besides advanced austenitic steels are the viable candidates for some of the A-USC components in the boiler, turbine, and piping systems due to higher strength and improved corrosion resistance than standard ferritic or austenitic stainless steels. The paper, presents the study performed at 800 °C for 3000 hours on 3 advanced austenitic steels; 309S, 310S and HR3C with higher than 20 Cr wt% content and 4 Ni-based alloys including: two solid-solution strengthened alloys (Haynes 230), 617 alloy and two (γ’) gamma - prime strengthened materials (263 alloy and Haynes 282). The high temperature oxidation tests were performed in water to steam close loop system, the samples were investigated analytically prior and after exposures using Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) coupled with Energy Dispersive Spectrometry (EDS), and X-Ray Diffractometer (XRD). Mass change data have been examined every 250 hours.

Flux cored wires are worldwide used in power generation industry due to their technical and economic advantages. For welding P91 and P92 flux cored wires with a rutile slag system are available for several years. Results of long-term investigations up to 30.000 h show that specimens of all weld metal meet the requirements of the base material. Following the recent demand of reduced Mn+Ni content the chemical composition of all weld metal has been modified. For P91 a matching flux cored wire with Mn+Ni<1wt% and for P92 with Mn+Ni<1.2wt% is now available. In this paper the mechanical properties of all weld metal and welded joints are being presented. Latest developments in cast materials have shown that the so-called CB2 (GX13CrMoCoVNbNB 10-1-1) enables steam temperatures up to 620°C (1148°F). Therefore a matching flux cored wire with low Ni-content has been developed. Results of welding procedure qualification and first experience of manufacturing industrial components show the successful implementation of this new material grade and welding consumable.

A United States-based consortium has successfully completed the Advanced Ultra-Supercritical Component Test (A-USC ComTest) project, building upon a 15-year materials development effort for coal-fired power plants operating at steam temperatures up to 760°C. The $27 million project, primarily funded by the U.S. Department of Energy and Ohio Coal Development Office between 2015 and 2023, focused on validating the manufacture of commercial-scale components for an 800 megawatt power plant operating at 760°C and 238 bar steam conditions. The project scope encompassed fabrication of full-scale components including superheater/reheater assemblies, furnace membrane walls, steam turbine components, and high-temperature transfer piping, utilizing nickel-based alloys such as Inconel 740H and Haynes 282 for high-temperature sections. Additionally, the team conducted testing to secure ASME Code Stamp approval for nickel-based alloy pressure relief valves. This comprehensive effort successfully established technical readiness for commercial-scale A-USC demonstration plants while developing a U.S.-based supply chain and providing more accurate cost estimates for future installations.

This study investigates the impact of adding small amounts of rare earth (RE) elements on the properties and microstructures of SA335P91 steel welds. The RE elements were incorporated into the weld metal using a coating process. The researchers then proposed an optimal RE formula aimed at achieving improved properties and microstructures. To evaluate the effectiveness of this approach, various tests were conducted on both welds with and without RE additions. These tests included tensile testing (both at room and high temperatures), impact testing, metallographic analysis to examine the microstructure, determination of phase transformation points, scanning electron microscopy, and X-ray diffraction. The results revealed that the addition of RE elements has the potential to enhance the properties and modify the microstructure of SA335P91 welds.

Prior to utilizing new advanced materials in coal power plants, a large number of experimental testing is required. Test procedures are needed in specialized high temperature laboratories with state of the art facilities and precise, accurate analytical equipment capable of performing tests at a variety of temperatures and environments. In this study, the results of a unique technique involving salt spray testing at high temperatures are presented. The Haynes 282 gamma – prime (γ’) strengthened alloy fabricated by means of three different manufacturing processes: HAYNES 282 WROUGHT alloy, Haynes 282-SINT alloy, and finally Haynes 282-CAST alloy have been tested. The materials have been exposed to a salt spray corrosion atmosphere using 1% NaCl - 1% Na 2 SO 4 . Post exposure investigations have included SEM, EDS and XRD examinations. The test using salt spray of 1% NaCl - 1% Na 2 SO 4 water solution at 550 °C for 500 hours indicted no influence on the corrosion products formation, where Cr 2 O 3 has been developed in all three alloys, whereas NiO has been found only in Haynes 282-CAST material. On the other hand, it has been found that the fabrication process of HAYNES 282 alloy strongly influences the corrosion products formation under the high temperature exposures.

Microstructure in the gage sections of ruptured GX12CrMoWVNbN10-1-1 cast steel specimens was examined after creep tests under applied stresses ranging from 120 to 160 MPa at T=893 K. The microstructure after tempering consisted of laths with an average thickness of 332 nm. The tempered martensite lath structure was characterized by M 23 C 6 -type carbide particles with an average size of about 105 nm, and MX carbonitrides with an average size of about 45 nm. Precipitation of Laves phase occurred during creep test. The structural changes in the gauge section of the samples were characterized by the evolution of relatively large subgrains with remarkably lowered density of interior dislocations within former martensite laths. MX carbonitrides and M 23 C 6 -type carbide particles increase in size slightly under long-term creep. Microstructural degradation mechanisms during creep in GX12CrMoWVNbN10-1-1 cast steel are discussed.

Creep strength enhanced ferritic steels like T/P 91 and T/P 92 are widely used for the fabrication of pressure vessel components in the petro-chemical and thermal power industry. Today, a new generation of 9-12% Cr CSEF steels like MARBN, Save12AD, G115 and Super VM12 are entering into the market. All CSEF steels require an accurate post-weld heat treatment after welding. This paper discusses the impact of chemical composition on Ac1 as well as the transformation behavior during post-weld heat treatment in a temperature range below and above Ac1. The Ac1 temperature of weld metals with variations in chemical composition has been determined and thermodynamic calculations has been carried out. Simulations of heat treatment cycles with variations in temperature have been carried out in a quenching dilatometer. The dilatation curves have been analyzed in order to detect any phase transformation during heating or holding at post weld heat treatment. Creep rupture tests have been carried out on P91 and Super VM12 type weld metals in order to investigate the effect of sub- and intercritical post weld heat treatment on creep rupture strength.

Despite the significant progress achieved in power generation technologies in the past two decades, finding effective solutions to further reduce emissions of harmful gases from thermal power plant still remains the major challenge for the power generation industry as well as alloy material developers. In the European material programmes COST 522 and COST 536, based on the existing 9-12%Cr creep resisting steels, an advanced 9%Cr-Mo martensitic alloy, C(F)B2 (GX13CrMoCoVNbNB9-2-1) alloy has been developed. By modification through alloying of boron and cobalt and together with other micro-adjustment of the composition, C(F)B2 alloys has showed very encouraging properties. The current paper summaries the development and evaluation of the matching filler metals for C(F)B2 grade. The design of the filler metal composition is discussed and comparison is made with the parent materials in respect to the alloy additions and microstructure. The mechanical properties of the weld metals at ambient temperature are examined. Creep properties of both undiluted weld metals and cross-weld joints are examined through stress rupture test and the data are evaluated and compared with those of the base alloy and other existing 9%Cr-Mo creep resisting steels.

The mechanical behavior of a cast form of an advanced austenitic stainless steel, CF8C-Plus, is compared with that of its wrought equivalent in terms of both tensile and creep-rupture properties and estimated allowable stress values for pressurized service at temperatures up to about 850°C. A traditional Larson-Miller parametric model is used to analyze the creep-rupture data and to predict long-term lifetimes for comparison of the two alloy types. The cast CF8C-Plus exhibited lower yield and tensile strengths, but higher creep strength compared to its wrought counterpart. Two welding methods, shielded-metal-arc welding (SMAW) and gas-metal-arc welding, met the weld qualification acceptance criteria in ASME BPVC Section IX for the cast CF8C-Plus. However, for the wrought CF8C-Plus, while SMAW and gas-tungsten-arc welding passed the tensile acceptance criteria, they failed the side bend tests due to lack of fusion or weld metal discontinuities.

This study investigates a novel approach to addressing the persistent Type IV cracking issue in Grade 91 steel weldments, which has remained problematic despite decades of service history and various mitigation attempts through chemical composition and procedural modifications. Rather than further attempting to prevent heat-affected zone (HAZ) softening, we propose eliminating the vulnerable base metal entirely by replacing critical sections with additively manufactured (AM) weld metal deposits using ASME SFA “B91” consumables. The approach employs weld metal designed for stress-relieved conditions rather than traditional normalizing and tempering treatments. Our findings demonstrate that the reheat cycles during AM buildup do not produce the substantial softening characteristic of Type IV zones, thereby reducing the risk of premature creep failure. The study presents comprehensive properties of the AM-built weld metal after post-weld heat treatment (PWHT), examines factors influencing deposit quality and performance, and explores the practical benefits for procurement and field construction, supported by in-service data and application cases.