Grade 91 steel has been widely utilized in power plants over the last 20 years. Its specification worldwide has dramatically increased since the acceptance of Code Case 1943 for this material in 1983. Recent evaluation of a combination of ex-service Grade 91 steel components and virgin material has provided a unique opportunity to independently assess the performance of a combination of base metal and weldments. This approach has been grounded in the fundamental objective of linking metallurgical risk factors in Grade 91 steel to the cross-weld creep performance. Establishing critical risk factors in 9Cr steels is regarded as a key consideration in the integration of a meaningful life management strategy for these complex steels. The potential metallurgical risk factors in Grade 91 steel have been fundamentally divided into factors which affect strength, ductility or both. In this study, two heats of ex-service Grade 91 steel which exhibit dramatic differences in strength and ductility have been evaluated in the ex-service condition and re-heat treated to establish a relevant set of strength:ductility variables. This set of variables includes [strength:ductility]: low:low, medium:low, low:high and medium:high. The influence of these strength:ductility variables were investigated for feature type cross-weld creep tests to better evaluate the influence of the initial base material condition on cross-weld creep performance.

Early supercritical units such as American Electric Power (AEP) Philo U6, the world’s first supercritical power plant, and Eddystone U1 successfully operated at ultrasupercritical (USC) levels. However due to the unavailability of metals that could tolerate these extreme temperatures, operation at these levels could not be sustained and units were operated for many years at reduced steam (supercritical) conditions. Today, recently developed creep strength enhanced ferritic (CSEF) steels, advanced austenitic stainless steels, and nickel based alloys are used in the components of the steam generator, turbine and piping systems that are exposed to high temperature steam. These materials can perform under these prolonged high temperature operating conditions, rendering USC no longer a goal, but a practical design basis. This paper identifies the engineering challenges associated with designing, constructing and operating the first USC unit in the United States, AEP’s John W. Turk, Jr. Power Plant (AEP Turk), including fabrication and installation requirements of CSEF alloys, fabrication and operating requirements for stainless steels, and life management of high temperature components

23Cr-45Ni-7W alloy (HR6W) is a material being considered for use in the high temperature parts of A-USC boilers in Japan. In order to establish an assessment method of creep damage for welded components made using HR6W, two types of internal pressure creep tests were conducted. One is for straight tubes including the circumferential weld and the other is for welded branch connections. The test results for the circumferential welds ensured that the creep rupture location within the area of the base metal, as well as the time of rupture, can be assessed by mean diameter hoop stress. On the other hand, the creep rupture area was observed in the weld metal of the branch connections, although the creep strength of Inconel filler metal 617 was higher than that of HR6W. FE analyses were conducted using individual creep strain rates of the base metal, the heat affected zone and the weld metal to clarify this difference in the failures of these two specimens. Significant stress was only produced in the weld metal as opposed to the base metal, due to the difference in creep strain rates between the welded branch connections and creep crack were initiated in the weld metal. The differences between the two failure types were assessed using the ductility exhaustion method.

By utilizing computational thermodynamics in a Design of Experiments approach, it was possible to design and manufacture nickel-base superalloys that are strengthened by the eta phase (Ni3Ti), and that contain no gamma prime (Ni3Al,Ti). The compositions are similar to NIMONIC 263, and should be cost-effective, and have more stable microstructures. By varying the aging temperature, the precipitates took on either cellular or Widmanstätten morphologies. The Widmanstätten-based microstructure is thermally stable at high temperatures, and was found to have superior ductility, so development efforts were focused on that microstructure. High temperature tensile test and creep test results indicated that the performance of the new alloys was competitive with NIMONIC 263. SEM and TEM microscopy were utilized to determine the deformation mechanisms during creep.

High chromium HiperFer (High performance ferritic) materials present a promising concept for the development of high temperature creep and corrosion resistant steels. The institute for Microstructure and Properties of Materials (IEK-2) at Forschungszentrum Jülich GmbH, Germany develops high strength, Laves phase forming, fully ferritic steels which feature excellent resistance to steam oxidation and better creep life than state of the art 9-12 Cr steels. Mechanical strength properties of these steels depend not only on chemical composition, but can be adapted to various applications by specialized thermo(mechanical) treatment. The paper will outline the sensitivity of tensile, creep, stress relaxation and impact properties on processing and heat treatment. Furthermore an outlook on future development potentials will be derived.

There is a constant need for improved knowledge of the influence of non-standard processing on the expected performance of creep strength enhanced ferritic (CSEF) materials as the total installed tonnage of these materials is rapidly increasing across the power generation industry. Cr-Mo-V steel grades micro-alloyed with niobium and titanium designed for pressurized equipment operating in the supercritical steam range proved to be very sensitive to relative minor variations in the principal heat treatment parameters time and temperature, when compared to the traditional Cr-Mo-V grades. A key component for successful welds is optimised post weld heat treatment (PWHT). Under certain conditions premature failures of welds can occur when incorrect weld and heat treatment performance result in a reduction of specified mechanical properties and high temperature creep performance, it is therefore of significant importance to have a good understanding of actual material properties for effective operation and plant life studies. This study investigated the effect and impact variations of post weld heat treatment time and temperature on mechanical properties of tungsten inert gas (TIG) and manual metal arc (MMA) welds on Grade 91 pipes from a set of reference samples. This is in preparation of establishing a benchmark set of tests to determine the integrity and expected long-term performance of butt-welds from limited site sample volumes, providing a non-intrusive methodology to identify welds suspected to have received non-standard PWHT cycles on Grade 91 pipework systems.

Fossil fuels continue to be the primary source of energy in the U.S and worldwide. In order to improve the efficiency of fossil power plants, advanced structural materials need to be developed and deployed to meet the need of high temperature creep resistance and corrosion resistance. Examples include creep strength enhanced ferritic (CSEF) steels, austenitic stainless steels, nickel-based superalloys, and oxide dispersion strengthened alloys. Welding is extensively used in construction of fossil power plants. The performance of the weld region can be critical to the safe and economical operation of fossil power plants. Degradations in performance such as reduced creep strength and premature failure in the weld region (e.g. Type IV failure in ferritic steels) are examples of longstanding welding and weldability problems for boiler and other components. In the past, extensive studies have been carried out to characterize the different microstructures in different regions of a weld, and to a certain extent, to establish the correlations between the microstructure and the creep strength. However, the metallurgical or microstructural induced local stress/strain variations have been seldom quantified. In addition, it has been long recognized that, due to the sharp microstructure and property gradients in the weld and HAZ, the standard creep testing procedure for the base metal can produce erroneous results when used for weld testing.

Modified 9Cr-1Mo alloy steel has been developed over the last few decades and has since gained wide acceptance in the boiler industry for the production of a variety of pressure-critical components, including tubing, piping and headers. The properties of creep-strength enhanced ferritic steels such as grade 91 are critically dependent on manufacturing parameters such as steelmaking, hot deformation, heat treatment and welding. Since the applications for which this material is used impose strict requirements in terms of resistance, corrosion, and creep behavior, poor process control can severely compromise the service behavior. This work discusses the impact of total deformation during the rolling process, and heat treatment parameters on time-independent and time-dependent properties for grade 91. For this study, two heats with similar chemical composition were produced with different reduction ratios: to which, several normalizing and tempering combinations were applied. For each combination, the microstructure was characterized, including evaluation of segregation by metallographic examination, and analysis of secondary phase precipitates by means of X-ray powder diffraction. Mechanical testing and creep testing were performed. A comparison of results is presented, and recommendations on the optimal process parameters are provided to ensure reliable performance of grade 91 material.

More efficient, sustainable, flexible and cost-effective energy technologies are strongly needed to fulfil the new challenges of the German “Energiewende”. For a reduction of consumed primary resources higher efficiency steam cycles with increased operating parameters, pressure and temperature, are mandatory. Hence, advanced materials are needed. The present study focuses on stainless, high strength, ferritic (non-martensitic) steel grades, regarding thermal treatment effects on particle evolution. The heat treatment includes variations, e.g. a two phase pre heat treatment. Effects of the treatment were analysed and connected to creep performance. Experiments at differently heat treated materials show promising improvement of creep performance. These results can be linked to the stability and evolution of strengthening Laves phase particles.

In wrought nickel-base alloys used at elevated temperatures for extended periods of time, it is commonly observed that unwanted phases may nucleate and grow. One such phase is the eta phase, based on Ni 3 Ti, which is a plate-shaped precipitate that nucleates at the grain boundaries and grows at the expense of the strengthening gamma prime phase. In order to study the effects of eta phase on creep performance, Alloy 263 was modified to contain 3 different microstructures: standard (contains gamma prime); aged (contains gamma prime and eta); and modified (contains only eta and no gamma prime). These microstructures were then creep tested in the range of 973-1123 K (700-850°C). An extensive test matrix revealed that the eta-only modified alloy had creep rupture strengths within 10% of the standard alloy even though this alloy had no strengthening gamma prime precipitates. It also exhibited superior creep ductility. A preliminary test matrix on the aged material containing eta and gamma prime prior to the creep tests revealed that the performance of this microstructure was generally between that of the standard alloy (best) and the eta-only alloy (worst). The aged material exhibited far superior creep ductility. These results suggest that the presence of the eta phase may not be deleterious to creep ductility, and in fact, may enhance it.

The long-term performance of superheater super 304h tube during the normal service of an ultra-supercritical 1000mw thermal power unit was tracked and analyzed, and the metallographic structure and performance of the original tube sample and tubes after 23,400h, 56,000h, 64,000 h, 70,000 h and 80,000 h service were tested. The results show that the tensile strength, yield strength and post-break elongation meet the requirements of ASME SA213 S30432 after long-term service, but the impact toughness decreases significantly. The metallographic organization is composed of the original complete austenite structure and gradually changes to the austenite + twin + second phase precipitates. With the extension of time, the number of second phases of coarseness in the crystal and the crystal boundary increases, and the degree of chain distribution increases. The precipitation phase on the grain boundary is dominated by M 23 C 6 , and there are several mx phases dominated by NbC and densely distributed copper phases in the crystal. The service environment produces a high magnetic equivalent and magnetic induction of the material, the reason is that there are strips of martensite on both sides of the grain boundary, and the number of martensite increases with the length of service.

Long-term performance of high temperature alloys is critically linked to the oxidation behavior in power generation applications in wet air and steam. As power generation systems move towards higher efficiency operation, nextgeneration fossil, nuclear and concentrating solar power plants are considering supercritical CO 2 cycle above 700°C. Wrought solid solution strengthened and precipitations strengthened alloys are leading candidates for both steam and Supercritical CO 2 power cycles. This study evaluates the cyclic oxidation behavior of HAYNES 230, 282, and 625 alloys in wet air, flowing laboratory air, steam and in 1 and 300 bar Supercritical CO 2 at ~750°C for duration of 1000 -10,000h. Test samples were thermally cycled for various times at temperature followed by cooling to room temperature. Alloy performances were assessed by analyzing the weight change behavior and extent of attack. The results clearly demonstrated the effects of alloy composition and environment on the long-term cyclic oxidation resistance. The extents of attack varied from alloy to alloy but none of the alloys underwent catastrophic corrosion and no significant internal carburization was observed in supercritical CO 2 . The performance of these alloys indicates that these materials are compatible not only in oxidizing environments, but also in Supercritical CO 2 environments for extended service operation.

A new nickel-base superalloy GH750 has been developed as boiler tube of advanced ultrasupercritical (A-USC) power plants at temperatures about and above 750°C in China. This paper researched the weld solidification of GH750 filler metal, microstructure development and property of GH750 welded joint by gas tungsten arc weld. Liquid fraction and liquid composition variation under non-equilibrium state were calculated by thermo-dynamic calculation. The weld microstructure and the composition in the dendrite core and interdendritic region were analyzed by SEM(EDX) in detail. The investigated results show that there is an obvious segregation of precipitation-strengthening elements during the weld solidification. Titanium and Niobium are the major segregation elements and segregates in the interdendritic region. It was found that the changing tendency of the elements’ segregation distribution during the solidification of GH750 deposit metal is agree with the thermodynamic calculation results. Till to 3,000hrs’ long exposure at 750°C and 800°C, in comparison with the region of dendrite core of solidification microstructure, not only the coarsening and the accumulation of γʹ particles are remarkable in the interdendritic region, but also the small quantity of the blocky and needle like η phases from. The preliminary experimental results indicate that the weakening effect of creep-rupture property of the welded joint is not serious compared with GH750 itself.

Inconel alloy 740/740H (ASME Code Case 2702) is an age-hardenable nickel-based alloy designed for advanced ultrasupercritical (A-USC) steam boiler components (superheaters, reheaters, piping, etc.). In this work, creep testing, beyond 40,000 hours was conducted a series of alloy 740 heats of varying product form, chemistry, and grain size. Long-term creep-rupture strength was found to be weakly dependent on grain size. Analysis of the time-to-rupture data was conducted to ensure long-term strength projections and development of ASME stress allowables. Testing was also conducted on welded joints in alloy 740 with different filler metal and heat-treatment combinations. This analysis shows the current weld strength reduction factor of 30% (Weld Strength Factor of 0.70) mandated by ASME Code Case 2702 is appropriate for 740 filler metal but other options exist to improve strength. Based on these results, it was found that alloy 740 has the highest strength and temperature capability of all the potential A-USC alloys available today.

This paper summarizes recent efforts to improve creep performance in Grade 91 (Mod. 9Cr-1Mo, ASTM A387) steel weldments via non-standard heat treatments prior to welding. Such heat treatments offer a potential solution for minimizing Type IV failures in creep strength enhanced ferritic (CSEF) steels. A lower temperature tempering (LTT, 650°C) of the 9Cr steels prior to gas tungsten arc welding (GTAW) resulted in improved creep-rupture life at 650°C compared to the samples tempered at a standard condition (HTT, 760°C) before welding. From detailed characterization of precipitation kinetics in the heat affected zone, it was hypothesized that M 23 C 6 carbides in the fine-grain heat-affected zone (FGHAZ) in the LTT sample were fully dissolved, resulting in re-precipitation of strengthening carbides during post weld heat treatment (PWHT). This was not the case in the HTT sample since M 23 C 6 in the FGHAZ was only partially dissolved prior to welding, which caused coarsening of existing M 23 C 6 after PWHT and premature creep failure in the FGHAZ. However, it was also found that the LTT raised the ductile-brittle transition temperature above room temperature (RT). Two different thermo-mechanical treatments (TMTs); two-step tempering and aus-forging/aus-aging, of the modified 9Cr-1Mo steels were attempted, in order to control the balance between creep properties and RT ductility, through control of precipitation kinetics of the M 23 C 6 carbides and/or MX carbo-nitrides. The hardness map of the TMT samples after GTAW and PWHT were evaluated.

9-12%Cr martensitic-ferritic steels continue to be developed for target temperatures of 650°C. This paper reviews the performance of two experimental European steels against the performance of the better known grade 92 alloy. It comments on the problem of type IV cracking and the effect of welding variables on cross-weld creep performance. Preliminary results from an on-going creep test programme are presented in context, and the findings compared with published data.

Oxyfuel combustion efforts to burn fossil fuels with oxygen, for easier post-combustion CO 2 capture, include schemes to use flue gas to drive turbines for power generation. The environment examined here is 10% CO 2 and 0.2% O 2 , with the balance being steam, with temperatures ranging from 630 to 821 °C. The relatively high C and O 2 activities of this environment, as compared to pure steam, may lead to changes in oxidation behavior and mechanical properties. Oxidation coupons of Ni- and Co-base superalloys, in both bare metal and TBC coated conditions, were exposed to this environment for up to 1000 hours. The results of these exposures, in terms of mass gain and scale morphology, are presented.

Ferritic 9-12 wt.% chromium steels are commonly used for thick-walled high-temperature components in thermal power plants, but they face two major limitations in high-temperature service. Firstly, a reduction in creep strength occurs after approximately 10,000 hours at service temperatures around 600°C, due to the dissolution of finely dispersed V-rich nitrides and the precipitation of coarse particles of the modified Z-phase, [(Cr,V,Nb)N]. Secondly, welded joints of nearly all ferritic steel grades are prone to premature creep failures in the fine-grained heat-affected zone, known as Type IV cracking, which results from a strength loss of up to 50% compared to the base material. This study describes the development of a 9Cr3W3CoVNb steel with added boron and controlled nitrogen content. Preliminary creep testing results up to 24,000 hours at 650°C show a significant improvement in creep strength compared to established ferritic 9Cr grades like P91 and P92, attributed to a reduced driving force for the precipitation of modified Z-phase particles. Crosswelds of the new 9Cr3W3CoVNbBN steel also demonstrate improved creep behavior at 650°C, with creep rupture strength comparable to the mean base material creep strength of the best commercially available grade P92.

Diffusion aluminide coatings have been evaluated as a strategy for improving the oxidation resistance of austenitic and ferritic-martensitic (FM) steels, particularly in the presence of steam or water vapor. The objective was to evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of these coatings and quantify their performance and lifetime. Long-term diffusion and oxidation experiments were conducted to study the behavior of various model diffusion coatings and produce a better data set for lifetime predictions. The key findings are that (1) thin coatings (<50μm) with relatively low Al contents appear to be more effective because they avoid high thermal expansion intermetallic phases and have less strain energy to nucleate a crack; and (2) the low Al reservoir in a thin coating and the loss of Al due to interdiffusion are not problematic because the low service temperatures of FM steels (<600°C) and, for austenitic steels at higher temperatures, the phase boundary between the ferritic coating-austenitic substrate inhibits Al interdiffusion. Unresolved issues center on the effect of the coating on the mechanical properties of the substrate including the reaction of N in the alloy with Al.

High-performance Ferritic (HiperFer) steels represent a promising materials innovation for next-generation thermal energy conversion systems, particularly in cyclically operating applications like concentrating solar thermal plants and heat storage power plants (Carnot batteries), where current market adoption is hindered by the lack of cost-effective, high-performance materials. HiperFer steels demonstrate superior fatigue resistance, creep strength, and corrosion resistance compared to conventional ferritic-martensitic 9-12 Cr steels and some austenitic stainless steels, making them potentially transformative for future energy technologies. This paper examines the microstructural mechanisms underlying HiperFer’s enhanced fatigue resistance in both short and long crack propagation, while also presenting current findings on salt corrosion properties and exploring potential alloying improvements for fusion reactor applications, highlighting the broad technical relevance of these innovative materials.