This paper presents three recent example cases of cracking in Grade 91 steel welds in longer-term service in high temperature steam piping systems: two girth butt welds and one trunnion attachment weld. All the cases were in larger diameter hot reheat piping, with the service exposure of the welds ranging from approximately 85,000 to 150,000 hours. Cracking in all cases occurred by creep damage (cavitation and microcracking) in the partially transformed heat-affected zone (PTZ, aka Type IV zone) in the base metal adjacent to the welds. The location and morphology of the cracking are presented for each case along with operating conditions and potential contributors to the cracking, such as system loading, base metal chemical composition, and base metal microstructure.

Creep strength of Grade 91 steels has been reviewed and allowable stress of the steels has been revised several times. Allowable stress regulated in ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code of the steels with thickness of 3 inches and above was reduced in 1993, based on the re-evaluation with long-term creep rupture data collected from around the world. After steam leakage from long seam weld of hot reheat pipe made from Grade 122 steel in 2004, creep rupture strength of the creep strength enhanced ferritic (CSEF) steels has been reviewed by means of region splitting method in consideration of 50% of 0.2% offset yield stress (half yield) at the temperature, in the committee sponsored by the Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry (METI) of Japanese Government. Allowable stresses in the Japanese technical standard of Grade 91 steels have been reduced in 2007 according to the above review. In 2010, additional long-term creep rupture data of the CSEF steels has been collected and the re-evaluation of creep rupture strength of the steels has been conducted by the committee supported by the Federation of Electric Power Companies of Japan, and reduction of allowable stress has been repeated in 2014. Regardless of the previous revision, additional reduction of the allowable stress of Grade 91 steels has been proposed by the review conducted in 2015 by the same committee as 2010. Further reduction of creep rupture strength of Grade 91 steels has been caused mainly by the additional creep rupture data of the low strength materials. A remaining of segregation of alloying elements has been revealed as one of the causes of lowered creep rupture strength. Improvement in creep strength may be expected by reducing segregation, since diffusional phenomena at the elevated temperatures is promoted by concentration gradient due to segregation which increases driving force of diffusion. It has been expected, consequently, that the creep strength and allowable stress of Grade 91 steels can be increased by proper process of fabrication to obtain a homogenized material free from undue segregation.

Japanese USC-PC units successfully operate with steam temperatures of 610°C (1130°F). IHI is developing the next generation of USC-PC boilers, targeting 620°C (1150°F) for improved efficiency. Investigations are underway for even higher 700°C (1290°F) steam temperatures. IHI collaborates with turbine manufacturers to create reliable and efficient boiler-turbine packages for both new and existing power plants.

This paper reports the results of a collaborative investigation of an ex-service grade 91 bend carried out by the UK generating companies Centrica, SSE, Engie and RWE. As part of the handover exercise for Centrica’s Langage power station in 2009 a number of routine checks were carried out on the main steam and hot reheat grade 91 steam pipework. In some cases low hardness readings were found with subsequent metallurgical replication showing the presence of an aberrant non martensitic microstructure. This led to a more extensive inspection programme on the steam lines and the discovery of other areas of suspect material. A review of the operating capability of the plant, including detailed pipework stress analysis and a pipework peaking assessment, along with the assumption that lower strength grade 91 material was present, led to the steam lines being down rated and returning to service under these revised conditions. At the first C inspection in December 2012, after the HRSG and associated pipework had operated for 18720 hours, a bend with a soft weld, along with a section of the straight pipe on either side, was removed from service. An investigation was undertaken to establish how long this component would have survived, had it been left in service, and to consider the implications for the future operation of the plant.

The creep strength of the base metals and welded joints of ASME Grade 91 type steel under actual service conditions was investigated using long-term used materials in this study. Creep tests were conducted on the materials used for hot reheat or main steam piping at power plants. The remaining creep life of each material under actual service conditions was evaluated using the Larson-Miller parameter for the test result. Then, the creep life of each material under the service condition was estimated as a summation of the service time at the plants and the remaining creep life. The estimation results were useful for examining the validity of the life evaluation formula in the long-term region because it is extremely difficult to obtain creep rupture data under such conditions owing to the long test duration. The estimated creep lives were compared with creep life evaluation curves, which were regulated for Grade 91 type steel in Japan. Regarding the base metals, the estimation results suggest that Grade 91 pipe-type steel tends to exhibit a shorter life than the 99% confidence lower limit of the evaluation curve of the material. This finding indicated that the life evaluation formula for the Grade 91 type steel base metals should be reviewed. On the other hand, the estimation results suggest that the welded joints of Grade 91 type steel generally exhibit a longer life than the 99% confidence lower limit of the evaluation curve of the material, indicating that there is no need to review the life evaluation formula for the Grade 91 type steel welded joints.

The susceptibilities of hot cracking and reheat cracking of A-USC candidate Ni-based alloys were evaluated relatively by Trans-Varestraint testing and Slow Strain Rate Tensile (SSRT) testing. In addition, semi-quantitative evaluation of the stress relaxation cracking susceptibility of Alloy 617 was conducted, because stress relaxation cracking in the heat affected zone (HAZ) has actually been reported for repair welds in Alloy 617 steam piping in European A-USC field-testing. Solidification cracking susceptibilities of Alloy 617 were the highest; followed by HR35, Alloy 740 and Alloy 141, which were all high; and then by HR6W and Alloy 263, which were relatively low. In addition, liquation cracking was observed in the HAZ of Alloy 617. The reheat cracking susceptibilities of Alloy 617, Alloy 263, Alloy 740 and Alloy 141 were somewhat higher than those of HR6W and HR35 which have good creep ductility due to the absence of γ’ phase precipitates. A method to evaluate stress relaxation cracking susceptibility was developed by applying a three-point bending test using a specimen with a V-notch and finite element analysis (FEA), and it was shown that stress relaxation cracking of aged Alloy 617 can be experimentally replicated. It was proposed that a larger magnitude of creep strain occurs via stress relaxation during the three-point bending test due to a higher yield strength caused by γ’ phase strengthening, and that low ductility due to grain boundary carbides promoted stress relaxation cracking. The critical creep strain curve of cracking can be created by means of the relationship between the initial strain and the creep strain during the three-point bending tests, which were calculated by FEA. Therefore, the critical conditions to cause cracking could be estimated from the stress relaxation cracking boundary from of the relationship between the initial strain and the creep strain during the three-point bending test.

Early supercritical units such as American Electric Power (AEP) Philo U6, the world’s first supercritical power plant, and Eddystone U1 successfully operated at ultrasupercritical (USC) levels. However due to the unavailability of metals that could tolerate these extreme temperatures, operation at these levels could not be sustained and units were operated for many years at reduced steam (supercritical) conditions. Today, recently developed creep strength enhanced ferritic (CSEF) steels, advanced austenitic stainless steels, and nickel based alloys are used in the components of the steam generator, turbine and piping systems that are exposed to high temperature steam. These materials can perform under these prolonged high temperature operating conditions, rendering USC no longer a goal, but a practical design basis. This paper identifies the engineering challenges associated with designing, constructing and operating the first USC unit in the United States, AEP’s John W. Turk, Jr. Power Plant (AEP Turk), including fabrication and installation requirements of CSEF alloys, fabrication and operating requirements for stainless steels, and life management of high temperature components

This paper reports the results of a collaborative small scale creep testing exercise carried out by the UK generating companies Centrica, SSE, Engie and RWE as part of an investigation of an ex-service grade 91 bend.

The United States Department of Energy (U.S. DOE) Office of Fossil Energy and the Ohio Coal Development Office (OCDO) have been the primary supporters of a U.S. effort to develop the materials technology necessary to build and operate an advanced-ultrasupercritical (A-USC) steam boiler and turbine with steam temperatures up to 760°C (1400°F). The program is made-up of two consortia representing the U.S. boiler and steam turbine manufacturers (Alstom, Babcock & Wilcox, Foster Wheeler, Riley Power, and GE Energy) and national laboratories (Oak Ridge National Laboratory and the National Energy Technology Laboratory) led by the Energy Industries of Ohio with the Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI) serving as the program technical lead. Over 10 years, the program has conducted extensive laboratory testing, shop fabrication studies, field corrosion tests, and design studies. Based on the successful development and deployment of materials as part of this program, the Coal Utilization Research Council (CURC) and EPRI roadmap has identified the need for further development of A-USC technology as the cornerstone of a host of fossil energy systems and CO 2 reduction strategies. This paper will present some of the key consortium successes and ongoing materials research in light of the next steps being developed to realize A-USC technology in the U.S. Key results include ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code acceptance of Inconel 740/740H (CC2702), the operation of the world’s first 760°C (1400°F) steam corrosion test loop, and significant strides in turbine casting and forging activities. An example of how utilization of materials designed for 760°C (1400°F) can have advantages at 700°C (1300°F) will also be highlighted.

In order to improve thermal efficiency of fossil-fired power plants through increasing steam temperature and pressure high strength martensitic 9-12%Cr steels have extensively been used, and some power plants have experienced creep failure in high temperature welds after several years operations. The creep failure and degradation in welds of longitudinally seam-welded Cr- Mo steel pipes and Cr-Mo steel tubes of dissimilar metal welded joint after long-term service are also well known. The creep degradation in welds initiates as creep cavity formation under the multi-axial stress conditions. For the safety use of high temperature welds in power plant components, the complete understanding of the creep degradation and establishment of creep life assessment for the welds is essential. In this paper creep degradation and initiation mechanism in welds of Cr-Mo steels and high strength martensitic 9-12%Cr steels are reviewed and compared. And also since the non-destructive creep life assessment techniques for the Type IV creep degradation and failure in high strength martensitic 9-12%Cr steel welds are not yet practically established and applied, a candidate way based on the hardness creep life model developed by the authors would be demonstrated as well as the investigation results on the creep cavity formation behavior in the welds. Additionally from the aspect of safety issues on welds design an experimental approach to consider the weld joint influence factors (WJIF) would also be presented based on the creep rupture data of the large size cross-weld specimens and component welds.

In order to reduce CO 2 emissions and improve power generation efficiency, a development project involving an advanced USC (A-USC) plant has been carried out in Japan since 2008. Nibased alloys are candidate materials for boiler components with high temperature steam conditions, which are much stronger than conventional heat resistant steel. However, Ni-based alloys have never been applied with respect to the high pressure parts and thick walled components of USC coal-fired power plants. In this study, therefore, fabrication and characteristic properties, such as weldability, the weld joint and bent part properties, and weld cracking susceptibilities of Ni-based alloys such as HR6W, HR35 and two types of Alloy617 (High B and Low B) pipes were evaluated. Additionally, two types of HR6W header mock-ups and a HR6W tube element mock-up were fabricated. With the exception of Alloy617 (High B), the fabrication trials of Ni-based alloy pipes were conducted successfully, and the long-term creep strength of weldments and bends of Ni-based alloy pipes were found to be nearly equivalent to those of base metal. In the case of Alloy617 (High B), hot cracking was observed.

A United States-based consortium has successfully completed the Advanced Ultra-Supercritical Component Test (A-USC ComTest) project, building upon a 15-year materials development effort for coal-fired power plants operating at steam temperatures up to 760°C. The $27 million project, primarily funded by the U.S. Department of Energy and Ohio Coal Development Office between 2015 and 2023, focused on validating the manufacture of commercial-scale components for an 800 megawatt power plant operating at 760°C and 238 bar steam conditions. The project scope encompassed fabrication of full-scale components including superheater/reheater assemblies, furnace membrane walls, steam turbine components, and high-temperature transfer piping, utilizing nickel-based alloys such as Inconel 740H and Haynes 282 for high-temperature sections. Additionally, the team conducted testing to secure ASME Code Stamp approval for nickel-based alloy pressure relief valves. This comprehensive effort successfully established technical readiness for commercial-scale A-USC demonstration plants while developing a U.S.-based supply chain and providing more accurate cost estimates for future installations.

The steam generation systems (SGS) of concentrated solar power (CSP) plants employ multiple heat exchangers arranged in series to convert thermal energy collected from the sun via a heat transfer fluid (HTF) to produce superheated steam in the Rankine cycle. Common CSP plant designs are based either on parabolic trough or central tower technology. The major Rankine cycle components consist of preheaters, evaporators, steam drums, superheaters, steam turbines, and water/air-cooled condensers, all connected through steel piping. For CSP plants capable of reheating the steam for improved efficiency, reheaters are also included in the Rankine cycle. In central tower design with directly heated water as the HTF, the receiver can also be considered part of the Rankine cycle. Operating experiences of CSP plants indicate that plant reliability is significantly impacted by failures in various components of the Rankine cycle. Many damage mechanisms have been identified, which include corrosion, thermal fatigue, creep, and stress corrosion cracking, among others. Much of the damage can be attributed to poor water/steam chemistry and inadequate temperature control. While damage in the Rankine cycle components is common, there is generally lack of comprehensive guidelines created specifically for the operation of these CSP components. Therefore, to improve CSP plant reliability and profitability, it is necessary to better understand the various damage mechanisms experienced by linking them to specific operating conditions, followed by developing a “theory and practice” guideline document for the CSP operators, so that failures in the Rankine cycle components can be minimized. In a major research project sponsored by the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE), effort is being undertaken by EPRI to develop such a guideline document exclusively for the CSP industry. This paper provides an overview of the ongoing DOE project along with a few examples of component failures experienced in the Rankine cycle.

INCONEL alloy 740H has been specified for tube and pipe for the boiler and heat exchanger sections of AUSC and sCO 2 pilot plants currently designed or under construction. These systems also require fittings and complex formed components such as flanges, saddles, elbows, tees, wyes, reducers, valve parts, return bends, thin-wall cylinders and tube sheets. The initial evaluation of alloy 740H properties, leading to ASME Code Case 2702, was done on relatively small cross-section tube and plate. The production of fittings involves the use of a wide variety of hot or cold forming operations. These components may have complex geometric shapes and varying wall thickness. The utility industry supply chain for fittings is largely unfamiliar with the processing of age-hardened nickel-base alloys. Special Metals has begun to address this capability gap by conducting a series of trials in collaboration with selected fittings manufacturers. This paper describes recent experiences in first article manufacture of several components. The resulting microstructure and properties are compared to the published data for tubular products. It is concluded that it will be possible to manufacture most fittings with properties meeting ASME Code minima using commercial manufacturing equipment and methods providing process procedures appropriate for this class of alloy are followed. INCONEL and 740H are registered trademarks of Special Metals Corporation.

In recent years continuous and extensive research and development activities have been being done worldwide on 700°C A-USC (Advanced Ultra Super Critical) power plants to achieve higher efficiency and reduce the CO 2 emission. Increasing steam temperature and pressure of such A-USC boilers under consideration require the adoption of Ni based alloys. In the Japanese national project launched in 2008, Ni based alloy HR6W (45Ni-23Cr-7W-Ti, ASME Code Case 2684) is one of the candidate materials for boiler tube and pipe as well as Alloy617, Alloy263 and Alloy740H. The most important issues in A-USC boiler fabrication are the establishment of proper welding process for thick wall components of these alloys and verification of the long term reliability of their weldments. In our previous study, the weldability of HR6W was investigated and the welding process for Ni based thick wall pipe was established with the narrow gap HST (Hot wire Switching TIG) welding procedure originally developed by Babcock-Hitachi K.K. In this paper, creep rupture strengths of HR6W weldment were verified by the long term test up to 60,000 hours for tube and 40,000 hours for pipe. In Japanese national project, narrow gap HST welding process was also applied to the welding test for the other Ni based candidate pipe materials. Furthermore, as the practical A-USC boiler manufacturing trials, header mockup test was conducted and qualified for HR6W.

This paper briefly introduces the state-of-the-art of the research and development of candidate heat resistant materials used for the manufacturing of 700°C advanced ultra-super-critical (AUSC) fossil fuel power plants (PP) in China, especially, focus on the impressive progress in the past three years. The detailed advancements (technical exploration and industrial investigation) of candidate materials spectra for the boiler system of A-USC PP will be presented in the current paper, including novel ferritic heat resistant steels, advanced austenitic heat resistant steels, Fe- Ni-based alloys and Ni-based alloys, which serve and cover the steam temperature scope from 600°C to 720°C. Some newly available data associated with above materials will be released.

The global electric power production is largely dependent on the operation of fossil-fired generation units. Many coal-fired units are exceeding 300,000 hours, which is beyond the expected design life. This has caused a continuous need to inspect steam touched components operating at high temperature and pressure. State-of-the-art coal and combined cycle gas units are specifying ever-greater amounts of the Creep Strength Enhanced Ferritic (CSEF) steels such as Grade 91 or Grade 92. The martensitic 9%Cr CSEF steels were developed to provide greater strength than traditional low alloy power plant steels, such as Grades 11, 12 and 22. The enhanced strength allows for a reduction in overall wall thickness in new or replacement components. Extensive research in both service failures and laboratory testing has shown that time-dependent creep damage can develop differently in Grade 91 steel when compared to low alloy steels. Furthermore, the creep strength in Grade 91 can vary by more than a factor of 10 between different heats. This wide variation of creep strength has led to extensive research in understanding the damage mechanisms and progression of damage in this steel. In this study, large cross weld samples were fabricated from thick wall piping in Grade 91 steel using two different heats of material. One weld was fabricated in a ‘damage tolerant’ heat and another weld was fabricated in a ‘damage intolerant’ heat of material. The samples were subjected to a post-weld heat treatment (PWHT) at a temperature of 745°C (1375°F) for 1.50 hours. Hardness maps were collected on the cross-welds in the as-welded and PWHT condition for both weldments. Cross-weld creep test conditions were selected to develop accelerated damage representative of in-service behavior. The test samples were interrupted at multiple stages and nondestructively evaluated (NDE) with advanced phased-array ultrasonic techniques. Samples were developed to variable levels of damage (50% to 100% life fraction) in both weldments. Metallographic sections were extracted at specific locations to validate the NDE findings using light emitting diode, laser and scanning electron microscopy. This research is being used to help validate the level of damage that can be reliably detected using conventional and advanced NDE techniques.

India's current installed power generating capacity is about 225,000 MW, of which about 59% is coal based. It is projected that India would require an installed capacity of over 800,000 MW by 2032. Coal is likely to remain the predominant source of energy in India till the middle of the century. India is also committed to reducing the CO 2 emission intensity of its economy and has drawn up a National Action Plan for Climate Change, which, inter alia, lays emphasis on the deployment of clean coal technologies. With this backdrop, a National Mission for the Development of Advanced Ultra Supercritical Technology has been initiated. The Mission objectives include development of advanced high temperature materials, manufacturing technologies and design of equipment. A corrosion test loop in an existing plant is also proposed. Based on the technology developed, an 800 MW Demonstration A-USC plant will be established. Steam parameters of 310 kg/cm 2 , 710 °C / 720 °C have been selected. Work on selection of materials, manufacture of tubes, welding trials and design of components has been initiated. The paper gives details of India's A-USC program and the progress achieved.

A Japanese national project has been undertaken since Aug. 2008 with the objective of developing an advanced ultra-supercritical power plant (A-USC) with a steam temperature of 700°C. Fe-Ni and Ni-based alloys, namely HR6W, HR35, Alloy617, Alloy740, Alloy263 and Alloy141, were taken as candidate materials for piping and superheater/reheater tubes in an A-USC boiler. Weldments of these alloys were manufactured by GTAW, after which long term creep rupture tests were conducted at 700°C, 750°C and 800°C. Weldments of HR6W, HR35 and Alloy617 showed similar creep strength as compared with these base metals. Weldments of Alloy740 tended to fail in the HAZ, and it is considered that voids and cracks preferentially formed in the small precipitation zone along the grain boundary in the HAZ. The creep strength of Alloy263 in weldments exhibited the highest level among all the alloys, although HAZ failure occurred in the low stress test condition. A weld strength reduction factor will be needed to avoid HAZ failure in Alloy740 and Alloy263. Also, to prevent premature failure in weld metal, optimization of the chemical composition of weld filler materials will be required.

Increasing the steam temperature of a coal-fired pulverized coal (PC) power plant increases its efficiency, which decreases the amount of coal required per MW of electrical output and therefore decreases the emissions from the plant, including CO 2 . However, increasing the steam temperature requires that the materials for the boiler pressure parts and steam turbine be upgraded to high-nickel alloys that are more expensive than alloys typically used in existing PC units. This paper explores the economics of A-USC units operating between 595°C and 760°C (1100°F to 1400°F) with no CO 2 removal and with partial capture of CO 2 at an emission limit of 454 kg CO 2 /MW-hr (1000 lb CO 2 /MW-hr) on a gross power basis. The goal of the paper is to understand if the improved efficiency of A-USC would reduce the cost of electricity compared to conventional ultra-supercritical units, and estimate the economically “optimal” steam temperature with and without CO 2 removal.