A compositional modification has been proposed to validate an alloy design which potentially eliminates the requirement of post-weld heat treatment (PWHT) while preserving the advantage of mechanical properties in a reduced activation bainitic ferritic steel based on Fe-3Cr-3W-0.2V- 0.1Ta-Mn-Si-C, in weight percent, developed at Oak Ridge National Laboratory in 2007. The alloy design includes reducing the hardness in the as-welded condition for improving toughness, while increasing the hardenability for preserving the high-temperature mechanical performance such as creep-rupture resistance in the original steel. To achieve such a design, a composition range with a reduced C content combining with an increased Mn content has been proposed and investigated. Newly proposed “modified” steel successfully achieved an improved impact toughness in the as- welded condition, while the creep-rupture performance across the weldments without PWHT demonstrated ~50% improvement of the creep strength compared to that of the original steel weldment after PWHT. The obtained results strongly support the validity of the proposed alloy design.

This study examines the corrosion resistance of additively manufactured 316L stainless steel (SS) for nuclear applications across three environments: pressurized water reactor primary water (PWR PW), hot concentrated nitric acid, and seawater. Wire-feed laser additive manufacturing (WLAM) specimens showed oxidation behavior similar to wrought 316L SS in PWR PW, though stress corrosion cracking (SCC) susceptibility varied with heat treatment. In nitric acid testing, laser powder bed fusion (L-PBF) specimens demonstrated superior corrosion resistance compared to conventional SS, primarily due to improved intergranular corrosion resistance resulting from cleaner feedstock powder and rapid solidification rates that minimized grain boundary segregation. Laser metal deposition (LMD) repair studies in seawater environments successfully produced dense, crack-free repairs with good metallurgical bonding that matched the substrate’s mechanical properties while maintaining corrosion resistance. These results emphasize the importance of corrosion testing for additively manufactured components and understanding how their unique microstructures affect performance.

This paper presents the CEN WS064 Prospective Group 2, a project involving different European stakeholders from more than 20 organizations with the objective to identify the needs and propose code developments research for the nuclear design and construction code RCC-MRx for innovative reactors with more onerous operational conditions: i) reactor components are generally exposed to higher temperatures; ii) have innovative and more corrosive coolants such as liquid lead or molten salt; iii) materials and components are generally exposed to higher radiation levels than light-water reactors. The main outputs of the CEN WS064 are code evolution proposals and proposals for pre-normative research in support of code evolution. The code evolution is driven by further improving safety and cost reduction. Nuclear Design Codes are robust engineering tools but should incorporate new technologies and research. The paper describes the adopted methodology and the rationale for identifying code evolution needs. Code evolution and research proposals will be discussed. Examples of proposals that will be discussed include: Guideline for design of material/components with innovative coolants, extension of design life to 60 years; qualification of new materials and components with advanced manufacturing. A general requirement is that code evolution and associated material and component qualification and codification need to be significantly accelerated for which new approaches such as AI tools will play an important role.

Local vacuum electron beam welding is an advanced manufacturing technology which has been investigated at Sheffield Forgemasters to develop as part of a cost-effective, reliable, agile, and robust manufacturing route for the next generation of civil nuclear reactors in the UK. A dedicated electron beam welding facility at Sheffield Forgemasters has been installed. This includes an x-ray enclosure, 100kW diode electron gun, 100T turntable, and weld parameter development vacuum chamber. A small modular reactor demonstrator vessel has successfully been manufactured with a wall thickness of 180 mm, including indication-free slope-in, steady- state and slope-out welding parameters. Electroslag strip cladding has also been investigated to demonstrate its viability in reactor pressure vessel manufacture. The electro-slag strip cladding method has been shown to produce high quality 60 mm strips on a 2600 mm inner diameter ring.

As many nuclear power plants are in the license renewal operating period and some are entering subsequent license renewal, there is increased probability that repairs will be needed on components that have been exposed to significant neutron fluence. The neutron-driven transmutation of nickel and tramp boron in austenitic materials commonly used in reactor internals can lead to the generation of trapped helium and the associated risk of helium-induced cracking (HeIC) during weld repairs. In the weld heat affected zone, where temperatures are insufficient to allow the helium to diffuse out of the material, the helium can remain trapped. Upon cooling, the residual stresses, combined with weakened grain boundaries due to helium coalescence, can lead to cracking. The current ASME limit for helium content for Code repairs is 0.1 appm. Prior work has demonstrated a strong inverse correlation between helium content and permissible weld heat input for avoidance of HelC. The helium concentration in the material to be repaired is thus a critical input to the development of weld repair processes to be applied to these materials. The reliable measurement of helium in irradiated materials at concentrations relevant for the evaluation of HeIC risk is a specialized process. It is important to demonstrate that the capability is available and can be practically leveraged to support emergent repairs. This paper presents on the execution and results of a multi-laboratory test program aimed at demonstrating the industry capability of acquiring accurate, repeatable, and timely measurements of relatively low concentrations of helium (< ~20 appm) within austenitic materials commonly used in reactor internals. Participating laboratories were supplied with equivalent specimens extracted from boron-doped coupons that were irradiated to drive the boron-to-helium transmutation reaction. The results and lessons learned from the program are expected to support the development of industry guidance for the acquisition of similar measurements supporting nuclear component repairs.

As part of a Department of Energy (DOE) funded program assessing advanced manufacturing techniques for Small Modular Reactor (SMR) applications, the Nuclear Advanced Manufacturing Research Centre (AMRC) and the Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI) have been developing Electron Beam Welding (EBW) parameters and procedures based upon SA508 Grade 3 Class 1 base material. The transition shell, a complex component connecting the lower assembly to the upper assembly is a shell that flares up with varying thicknesses across its section. The component due to its geometry could be built by near net shape powder metallurgy hot isostatic pressing instead of conventional forging techniques. The demonstrator transition shell here is built from several sub-forging as a training exercise. The complex geometry and joint configuration were selected to assess the EBW as a suitable technique. This paper presents results from the steady state welding in the 60-110 mm material thickness range, showing that weld properties meet specification requirements. Weld quality was assured by Time-of-Flight Diffraction (ToFD). The transition shell was completed by welding a flange to the assembly. The presented transition shell assembly represents 6 welded sections all fabricated in below 100 min total welding time.

The Advanced Materials and Manufacturing Technologies (AMMT) program is aiming at the accelerated incorporation of new materials and manufacturing technologies into nuclear-related systems. Complex Ni-based components fabricated by laser powder bed fusion (LPBF) could enable operating temperatures at T > 700°C in aggressive environments such as molten salts or liquid metals. However, available mechanical properties data relevant to material qualification remains limited, in particular for Ni-based alloys routinely fabricated by LPBF such as IN718 (Ni- 19Cr-18Fe-5Nb-3Mo) and Haynes 282 (Ni-20Cr-10Co-8.5Mo-2.1Ti-1.5Al). Creep testing was conducted on LPBF 718 at 600°C and 650°C and on LPBF 282 at 750°C. finding that the creep strength of the two alloys was close to that of wrought counterparts. with lower ductility at rupture. Heat treatments were tailored to the LPBF-specific microstructure to achieve grain recrystallization and form strengthening γ' precipitates for LPBF 282 and γ' and γ" precipitates for LPBF 718. In-situ data generated during printing and ex-situ X-ray computed tomography (XCT) scans were used to correlate the creep properties of LPBF 282 to the material flaw distribution. In- situ data revealed that spatter particles are the potential causes for flaws formation in LPBF 282. with significant variation between rods based on their location on the build plate. XCT scans revealed the formation of a larger number of creep flaws after testing in the specimens with a higher initial flaw density. which led to a lower ductility for the specimen.

Carbon migration in narrow-gap welding joints of dissimilar steels has been studied using bead-on-plate specimens to determine the factors that influence the formation of a soft ferrite structure in the carbon-depleted zone. Carbon migration was found to occur during tempering, with a ferrite structure formed at the intersection of multiple layers due to severe carbon migration. This was attributed to a steep gradient in Cr content caused by the low fusion penetration at the intersection. Experimental results and the relationship between fusion penetration and weld bead alignment confirmed that low fusion penetration is the main cause of ferrite-structured carbon depleted zones.

To operate future fusion power plants economically, the fusion community needs structural materials that can last longer and operate at higher temperatures than current materials, as well as better heat-dissipating components and a reliable supply chain for them. Additive manufacturing (AM) of existing reduced activation ferritic/martensitic steels (RAFMS) has the potential to solve these problems, which is why we developed a laser powder bed fusion (LPBF) process for Eurofer97 steel, demonstrating excellent mechanical properties (~30% improved yield strength, ~6300% improved creep rupture life, similar toughness and ductility compared to wrought Eurofer97) and low process scatter (relative standard error for yield, tensile strength and elongation on build plate <1%). The main remaining challenge is the consistent sourcing of quality Eurofer97 powder, but we have shown that this can already be done if the limits on impurity elements are slightly relaxed. Our work lays the groundwork for the manufacture of complex fusion components that can dissipate heat better and have a higher operating temperature thanks to the improved material properties. It also helps plug the current RAFMS supply chain gap, enabling easier component prototyping and small-scale manufacture that can smoothly scale in volume in the future.

A thorough understanding of interactions between graphite and fluoride fuel salts is crucial, as graphite is a promising candidate for the moderator of molten salt reactors. This study investigates the infiltration of fluoride fuel salts into graphite and the fluorination of graphite by these salts under various pressures and temperatures. A high-pressure salt infiltration test apparatus was developed to examine the infiltration of NaF-KF-UF 4 and NaF-BeF 2 -UF 4 -ZrF 4 fuel salts into two types of graphite at high temperatures. For tests using NaF-BeF 2 -UF 4 -ZrF 4 , two different temperatures were selected to assess the impact of temperature on threshold pressure. The study observed salt infiltration into graphite at pressures exceeding its threshold pressure, and the threshold pressure for infiltration was lower at the higher temperature. In addition, the formation of carbon fluorides on the surface of post-test graphite specimens was identified.

The incore instrumentation system of a pressurized water reactor (PWR) facilitates neutron flux mapping and temperature measurements at specific core locations. A guide conduit, extending from the seal table to the lower reactor pressure vessel head, guides and protects each incore guide thimble between the table and the lower reactor vessel head. Each flux thimble houses a detector and drive cable. Once filled with reactor coolant, the conduit becomes an extension of the reactor coolant pressure boundary. This paper reports the examination results of cracking detected in a TP304 stainless steel guide conduit adjacent to a fillet weld at the upper surface of a TP304 seal table. The cracking resulted in reactor coolant leakage that was detected by the presence of boric acid deposits on the exterior of the conduit and table. Failure analysis including dimensional measurements, chemical analysis, stereomicroscopy, metallography, and scanning electron microscopy showed that extensive cracking of the conduit and seal table material occurred due to stress corrosion cracking (SCC). Assessment showed that chlorine-containing deposits were present on the exterior of the conduit and on the surfaces of the seal table and were due to the design and operation of HVAC systems at the coastal plant. Stainless steels are susceptible to SCC in environments with elevated temperatures, chloride contents, and increased tensile stress – particularly in non-post weld heat treated (PWHT) weld regions and the heat affected zone (HAZ). This was the apparent primary cause of the failure. However, chloride-induced SCC of such materials typically results in transgranular crack propagation, whereas the observed cracks were indicative of intergranular stress corrosion cracking (IGSCC). Microstructural analysis showed that the observed cracks initiated in sensitized areas of material adjacent to the weld. Sensitization of the material caused chromium depletion from adjacent areas and increased susceptibility of the depleted areas to IGSCC. In this case, the most probable source of sensitization was related to welding and the long-term growth of grain boundary carbides nucleated during welding. This was considered a contributing cause to the failure.

Laser additive manufacturing (AM) is being considered by the nuclear industry to manufacture net- shape components for advanced reactors and micro reactors. Part-to-part and vendor-to-vendor variations in part quality, microstructure, and mechanical properties are common for additively manufactured components, attributing to the different processing conditions. This work demonstrates the use of microstructurally graded specimen as a high throughput means to establish the relationship between process-microstructure-creep properties. Through graded specimen manufacturing, multiple microstructures, correlated to the processing conditions, can be produced in a single specimen. The effects of a solution annealing heat treatment on the microstructure and creep properties of AM 316H are investigated in this work. Using digital image correlation (DIC), the creep strain can be calculated in these graded regions, allowing for multiple microstructures to be probed in a single creep test. The solution annealing heat treatment was not sufficient in recrystallization of the large, elongated grains in the AM material; however, it was sufficient in removing the cellular structure commonly found in AM processed alloys creating a network of subgrains in their place. The resulting changes in microstructure and mechanical properties are presented. The heat treatment was found to generally increase the minimum creep rate, reduce the minimum creep rate, and reduce the ductility. Significant amounts of grain boundary carbides and cavitation were observed.

High-performance Ferritic (HiperFer) steels represent a promising materials innovation for next-generation thermal energy conversion systems, particularly in cyclically operating applications like concentrating solar thermal plants and heat storage power plants (Carnot batteries), where current market adoption is hindered by the lack of cost-effective, high-performance materials. HiperFer steels demonstrate superior fatigue resistance, creep strength, and corrosion resistance compared to conventional ferritic-martensitic 9-12 Cr steels and some austenitic stainless steels, making them potentially transformative for future energy technologies. This paper examines the microstructural mechanisms underlying HiperFer’s enhanced fatigue resistance in both short and long crack propagation, while also presenting current findings on salt corrosion properties and exploring potential alloying improvements for fusion reactor applications, highlighting the broad technical relevance of these innovative materials.

The next generation of materials and assemblies designed to address challenges in power generation, such as molten salt or supercritical carbon dioxide thermal transfer systems, corrosion, creep/fatigue, and higher temperature operation, will likely be highly optimized for their specific performance requirements. This optimization often involves strict control over microstructure, including homogeneity, grain size, texture, and grain boundary phases, as well as precise alloy chemistry and homogeneity. These stringent requirements aim to meet the new demands for bulk mechanical performance and durability. Some advanced materials, like oxide-dispersion strengthened or high-entropy alloys, necessitate specialized synthesis, fabrication, or welding/joining processes. Traditional methods that involve melting and solidifying can compromise the optimized microstructure of these materials, making non-melting synthesis and fabrication methods preferable to preserve their advanced characteristics. This paper presents examples where solid-phase, high-shear processing has produced materials and semi-finished products with superior performance compared to those made using conventional methods. While traditional processing often relies on thermodynamics-driven processes, such as creating precipitate phases through prolonged heat treatment, high-shear processing offers kinetics-driven, non-equilibrium alternatives that can yield high-performance microstructures. Additionally, examples are provided that demonstrate the potential for more cost-effective manufacturing routes due to fewer steps or lower energy requirements. This paper highlights advances in high-shear extrusion processing, including friction extrusion and shear-assisted processing and extrusion, as well as developments in solid-phase welding techniques like friction stir welding for next-generation power plant materials.

This study explores the expanded applications of Alloy J513, a high-performance material traditionally used in cast engine valvetrain components, for powder metallurgy and surface cladding applications. While already recognized for its superior heat and wear resistance at a lower cost compared to cobalt-based hardfacing materials, J513 demonstrates additional advantages in powder metallurgy applications due to its ability to achieve desired powder characteristics through atomization without requiring post-atomization annealing. Through experimental investigation based on fundamental metallurgical principles and cladding engineering processes, the presented research demonstrates J513’s exceptional weldability and favorable weldment structure compared to conventional cobalt-based alloys. The study establishes crucial relationships between weldment behavior and unit energy input, providing valuable insights for advanced cladding techniques while highlighting J513’s potential as a sustainable alternative to traditional nickel- and cobalt-based alloys in various manufacturing processes, including surface overlay and additive manufacturing.

Modified 9Cr-1Mo steel was manufactured via laser powder bed fusion (LPBF) using gas atomized powders under various building conditions. Dense samples were obtained at an energy density of 111-125 J/mm 3 . As-built samples were subjected to a normalization and tempering heat treatments. The microstructure of the as-built sample exhibits a duplex structure, comprising coarse columnar δ-ferrite grains and fine martensite grains. In addition, a small amount of retained austenite phase was observed at the interface between δ-ferrite and martensite. The formation of δ-ferrite is attributed to the extremely rapid solidification that occurs during the LPBF process, while martensite is obtained through the phase transformation because of the thermal cycles experienced during the process. The area fraction of δ-ferrite and martensite can be controlled by adjusting the LPBF parameters. Typical as-built microstructure morphology characterized by the columnar δ- ferrite was eliminated after the heat treatments, resulting in a tempered martensitic microstructure that is identical with that obtained through the conventional process. However, an increase in prior austenite grain size was observed when the area fraction of δ-ferrite in the as-built condition was high, due to faster phase transformation kinetics of martensite than that of δ-ferrite during the normalization. This suggests that the prior austenite grain size can be controlled by optimizing the area fraction of δ-ferrite and martensite in the as-built microstructure.

Additive manufacturing is a groundbreaking manufacturing method that enables nearly lossless processing of high-value materials and produces complex components with a level of flexibility that traditional methods cannot achieve. Wire arc additive manufacturing (WAAM), utilizing a conventional welding process such as gas metal arc welding, is one of the most efficient additive manufacturing technologies. The WAAM process is fully automated and guided by CAD/CAM systems on robotic or CNC welding platforms. This paper explores the fundamental concepts and metallurgical characteristics of WAAM. It focuses primarily on the mechanical properties of printed sample structures made from P91, X20, and alloys 625 and 718 wire feedstock. The study particularly addresses the anisotropy of mechanical properties through both short-term and long-term testing, comparing these results to materials processed using conventional methods.

There is an increased interest in miniature testing to determine material properties. The small punch test is one miniaturized test method that has received much interest and is now being applied to support the design and life assessment of components. This paper presents the results of a test program for a small punch creep test at 650°C of 316L stainless steel produced from additive manufacturing. A major finding is that the deflection rate curve versus time may have multiple minima as opposed to forged 316L with only one minimum. This is believed to be due to microcracking and has direct consequences on the determination of the creep properties that that are based on a single minimum value in the CEN Small Punch Standard. In the paper, aged and nonaged materials are compared, and small punch creep results are also compared with standard uniaxial creep tests. The multiple minima feature means that the approach to determine equivalent stress and strain rate from the minimum deflection rate needs to be modified. Some approaches for this are discussed in the paper. Under the assumption that the multiple minima represent cracking, it opens up opportunities to quantify reduced creep ductility by the small punch test.

Supercritical carbon dioxide cooling during machining has been identified as an effective measure to mitigate the risk of stress corrosion cracking in materials utilized in the primary circuit of light water reactors, particularly in pressure vessel structural steels. This study aims to compare two different cooling methods, the novel supercritical carbon dioxide and conventional high pressure soluble oil, employed during both milling and turning processes for SA508 Grade 3 Class 2 and AISI 316L steels. As the surface conditions of materials are critical to fatigue properties, such as crack initiation and endurance life, the fatigue performance of both cooling methods for each process were then evaluated and the impact on properties determined. To compare the potential benefits of supercritical carbon dioxide cooling against conventional soluble oil cooled machining, fatigue specimens were machined using industry relevant CNC machine tools. Surface finish and machining methods were standardized to produce two different specimen types, possessing dog- bone (milled) and cylindrical (turned) geometries. Force-controlled constant amplitude axial fatigue testing at various stress amplitudes was undertaken on both specimen types in an air environment and at room temperature using a stress ratio of 0.1. The fatigue performance of the supercritical carbon dioxide cooled specimens revealed substantially greater endurance lives for both SA508 and 316L materials, when compared with specimens machined using high pressure soluble oil cooling.

This study evaluates the elevated temperature mechanical performance of 316H stainless steel produced using directed energy deposition (DED) additive manufacturing (AM) from three separate collaborative research programs focused on understanding how AM variables affect creep performance. By combining these studies, a critical assessment of variables was possible including the DED AM method (laser powder and gas metal arc wire), laser power, sample orientation relative to build orientation, chemical composition, and post-processing heat treatment. Detailed microstructure characterization was used to supplement creep and chemistry results to provide insights into potential mechanistic differences in behavior. The study found that sample orientation was a critical variable in determining lower-bound creep behavior, but that in general the lowest creep strength orientation and the lowest creep ductility orientation were not the same. Heat treatment was also an important variable with as-printed materials showing for specific test conditions improved performance and that underlying substructures formed due to inhomogeneous chemical distributions were not completely removed when using standard wrought solution annealing heat-treatments. The chemistry of the final deposited parts differed from the starting stock and may be an important consideration for long-term performance which is not fully appreciated. Overall, the study found that while all the DED materials tested fell within an expected wrought scatter band of performance, the actual creep performance could vary by an order of magnitude due to the many factors described.