Inconel Filler Metal 72 (FM 72) and Incoclad 671/800H co-extruded tubing have been successfully used for over 20 years to protect boiler tubing from high-temperature degradation. A newer alloy, FM 72M, offers superior weldability and the lowest corrosion rate in simulated low NOx environments. Both FM 72 and 72M show promise in addressing challenges like circumferential cracking and corrosion fatigue in waterwall tubing overlays. Additionally, 72M’s superior wear resistance makes it ideal for replacing erosion shields in superheater and reheater tubing. Beyond improved protection, these alloys exhibit increased hardness and thermal conductivity over time, leading to reduced temperature difference across the tube wall and consequently, enhanced boiler efficiency and lower maintenance costs. This paper discusses the historical selection of optimal alloys for waterwall and upper boiler tubing overlays, analyzes past failure mechanisms, and highlights the key properties of successful choices like FM 72 and 72M.

The Chinese power industry has experienced rapid development in the past decade. The newly built 600+°C ultra-super-critical (UCS) fossil fire power plants and pressed water reactor nuclear power plants in China are the world’s most advanced level technically and effectively. The available capacity of 600+°C UCS fossil fire power plant in China is more than 200 GW by the end of 2015, which has greatly contributed to the energy-saving and emission-reduction for China and the whole world. In China, the 610°C and 620°C advanced USC (A-USC) fossil fire power plants had been combined into the grid, 630°C A-USC fossil fire power plant is about to start to build, the feasibility of 650°C A-USC fossil fire power plant is under evaluation, 700°C AUSC fossil fire power plant has been included in the national energy development plan and the first Chinese 700°C A-USC testing rig had been put into operation in December 2015. The advanced heat resistant materials are the bottlenecking to develop A-USC fossil fire power plant worldwide. In this paper, the research and development of candidate heat resistant steels and alloys selected and/or used for 600+°C A-UCS fossil fire power plant in China is emphasized, including newly innovated G115 martensitic steel used for 630°C steam temperature, C-HRA-2 fully solid-solution strengthening nickel alloy used for 650°C steam temperature, C-HRA-3 solid-solution strengthening nickel alloy used for 680°C steam temperature, 984G iron-nickel alloy used for 680°C steam temperature, C-HRA-1 precipitation hardening nickel alloy and C700R1 solid-solution strengthening nickel alloy used for 700+°C steam temperature.

Along with rapid development of thermal power industry in mainland China, problems in metal materials of fossil power units also change quickly. Through efforts, problems such as bursting due to steam side oxide scale exfoliation and blocking of boiler tubes, and finned tube weld cracking of low alloy steel water wall have been solved basically or greatly alleviated. However, with rapid promotion of capacity and parameters of fossil power units, some problems still occur occasionally or have not been properly solved, such as weld cracks of larger-dimension thick-wall components, and water wall high temperature corrosion after low-nitrogen combustion retrofitting.

G115 is a novel ferritic heat resistant steel developed by CISRI in the past decade. It is an impressive candidate material to make tubes, pipes, and forgings for advanced ultra super critical (A-USC) fossil fired power plants used for the temperature scope from 600°C to 650°C. The successful development of G115 extends the upper application temperature limitation of martensitic steel from 600°C to about 650°C. This breakthrough is imperative for the design and construction of 610°C to 650°C A-USC fossil fired power plants, from the viewpoint of the material availability and economics of coal fired power plant designs. This paper introduces the development history and progress of G115 steel. The strengthening mechanism of the novel martensitic steel is briefly discussed, and the optimized chemical composition and mechanical properties of G115 steel are described. The details of industrial trials of G115 tube and pipe at BaoSteel in the past years are reviewed, with the emphasis on the microstructure evolution during aging and creep testing. These tests clearly show that the microstructure of G115 steel is very stable up to the temperature of 650°C. Correspondingly, the comprehensive mechanical properties of G115 steel are very good. The creep rupture time is longer than 17000 hours at the stress of 120MPa and at the temperature of 650°C and 25000+ hours at the stress of 100MPa and at the temperature of 650°C, which is about 1.5 times higher than that of P92 steel. At the same time, the oxidation resistance of G115 steel is a little bit better than that of P92 steel. If G115 steel is selected to replace P92 pipes at the temperature scope from 600°C to 650°C, the total weight of the pipe can be reduced by more than 50% and the wall thickness of the pipe can be reduced up to about 55%. In addition, the upper application temperature limitation of G115 steel is about 30°C higher than that of P92 steel. Thus, G115 steel is a strong candidate material for the manufacturing of 600+°C advanced ultra-super-critical (A-USC) fossil fuel power plants in China and elsewhere.

Austenitic stainless steels have been used for boiler tubes in power plants. Since austenitic stainless steels are superior to ferritic steels in high temperature strength and steam oxidation resistance, austenitic stainless steel tubes are used in high temperature parts in boilers. Dissimilar welded joints of austenitic steel and ferritic steel are found in the transition regions between high and low temperature parts. In dissimilar welded parts, there is a large difference in the coefficient of thermal expansion between austenitic and ferritic steel, and thus, thermal stress and strain will occur when the temperature changes. Therefore, the dissimilar welded parts require high durability against the repetition of the thermal stresses. SUPER304H (18Cr-9Ni-3Cu-Nb-N) is an austenitic stainless steel that recently has been used for boiler tubes in power plants. In this study, thermal fatigue properties of a dissimilar welded part of SUPER304H were investigated by conducting thermal fatigue tests and finite element analyses. The test sample was a dissimilar welded tube of SUPER304H and T91 (9Cr-1Mo-V-Nb), which is a typical ferritic heat resistant boiler steel.

This paper presents an overview of China’s electric power development and the National 700°C Ultra-Supercritical (USC) Coal-Fired Power Generation Technology Innovation Consortium. Besides, the R&D plan and latest progress of China 700°C USC coal-fired power generation technology is also introduced in this paper.

Sanicro 25 material is approved for use in pressure vessels and boilers according ASME code case 2752, 2753 and VdTUV blatt 555. It shows higher creep rupture strength than any other austenitic stainless steels available today. It is a material for superheater and reheaters, enabling higher steam parameters of up to about 650 °C steam (ie about max 700 °C metal) without the need for expensive nickel based alloys. The aim of the present study is the investigation of the steam oxidation resistance of the Sanicro 25. The long term test was conducted in the temperature range 600 -750 °C up to 20 000 hours. The morphology of the oxide scale and the microstructure of the bulk material were investigated. In addition, the effect of surface finish and pressure on the steam oxidation were also studied.

The United States Department of Energy (U.S. DOE) Office of Fossil Energy and the Ohio Coal Development Office (OCDO) have been the primary supporters of a U.S. effort to develop the materials technology necessary to build and operate an advanced-ultrasupercritical (A-USC) steam boiler and turbine with steam temperatures up to 760°C (1400°F). The program is made-up of two consortia representing the U.S. boiler and steam turbine manufacturers (Alstom, Babcock & Wilcox, Foster Wheeler, Riley Power, and GE Energy) and national laboratories (Oak Ridge National Laboratory and the National Energy Technology Laboratory) led by the Energy Industries of Ohio with the Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI) serving as the program technical lead. Over 10 years, the program has conducted extensive laboratory testing, shop fabrication studies, field corrosion tests, and design studies. Based on the successful development and deployment of materials as part of this program, the Coal Utilization Research Council (CURC) and EPRI roadmap has identified the need for further development of A-USC technology as the cornerstone of a host of fossil energy systems and CO 2 reduction strategies. This paper will present some of the key consortium successes and ongoing materials research in light of the next steps being developed to realize A-USC technology in the U.S. Key results include ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code acceptance of Inconel 740/740H (CC2702), the operation of the world’s first 760°C (1400°F) steam corrosion test loop, and significant strides in turbine casting and forging activities. An example of how utilization of materials designed for 760°C (1400°F) can have advantages at 700°C (1300°F) will also be highlighted.

A new nickel-based superalloy, designated as GH750, was developed to meet the requirements of high temperature creep strength and corrosion resistance for superheater/reheater tube application of A-USC power plants at temperatures above 750°C. This paper introduces the design of chemical composition, the process performance of tube fabrication, microstructure and the properties of alloy GH750, including thermodynamic calculation, room temperature and high temperature tensile properties, stress rupture strength and thermal stability. The manufacturing performance of alloy GH750 is excellent and it is easy to forge, hot extrusion and cold rolling. The results of the property evaluation show that alloy GH750 exhibits high tensile strength and tensile ductility at room and high temperatures. The 760°C/100,000h creep rupture strength of this alloy is larger than 100MPa clearly. Microstructure observation indicates that the precipitates of GH750 consist of the precipitation strengthening phase γ’, carbides MC and M 23 C 6 and no harmful and brittle TCP phases were found in the specimens of GH750 after long term exposure at 700~850°C. It can be expected for this new nickel-based superalloy GH750 to be used as the candidate boiler tube materials of A-USC power plants in the future.

SMST is producing Ni alloy Boiler tubes since more than 10 years with application in several test loops and R&D programs. This paper will give an overview about the experience with the common grades A617 as well as C263 plus some additional information on the new developed austenitic material “Power Austenite MoW”.

Following the successful completion of a 14-year effort to develop and test materials which would allow advanced ultra-supercritical (A-USC) coal-fired power plants to be operated at steam temperatures up to 760°C, a United States-based consortium has started on a project to build an A-USC component test facility, (A-USC ComTest). Among the goals of the facility are to validate that components made from the advanced alloys can perform under A-USC conditions, to accelerate the development of a U.S.-based supply chain for the full complement of A-USC components, and to decrease the uncertainty for cost estimates of future commercial-scale A-USC power plants. The A-USC ComTest facility will include a gas fired superheater, thick-walled cycling header, steam piping, steam turbine (11 MW nominal size) and valves. Current plans call for the components to be subjected to A-USC operating conditions for at least 8,000 hours by September 2020. The U.S. consortium, principally funded by the U.S. Department of Energy and the Ohio Coal Development Office with co-funding from Babcock & Wilcox, General Electric and the Electric Power Research Institute, is currently working on the Front-End Engineering Design phase of the A-USC ComTest project. This paper will outline the motivation for the project, explain the project’s structure and schedule, and provide details on the design of the facility.

For raising thermal efficiency and decreasing CO 2 emission, China had constructed the first 600°C ultra-supercritical(USC) fossil power plant in 2006. Now more than a hundred 600°C, 1000MW USC electric power units have been put in service. Recently, China has also developed 620°C USC power units and some of them have been put in service already. Meanwhile, more than fifty 620°C USC boilers will be produced by various China boiler companies. The austenitic steels TP347H, Super304H and HR3C are routinely used for 600°C USC boilers. Among these steels, a big amount of Super304H has been used for boiler superheater/reheater components application. However, Super304H is characterized by good stress-rupture strength but poor corrosion/oxidation resistance. On the other side, HR3C is characterized by very good corrosion/oxidation resistance but lower stress-rupture strength than Super304H. Now, the China 620°C USC project needs a new austenitic heat resisting steel with high stress-rupture strength and good corrosion/oxidation resistance to fulfill the superheater/reheater tube components application requirement. A new austenitic heat resisting steel SP2215 is based on 22Cr-15Ni with certain amount of Cu and also Nb and N for multiphase precipitation (MX, Cu-rich phase, NbCrN) strengthening in Fe-Cr-Ni austenitic matrix and M 23 C 6 carbide precipitation at grain boundaries. This SP2215 new austenitic steel is characterized by high stress-rupture strength (650°C, 105h>130MPa) and good corrosion/oxidation resistance. SP2215 austenitic steel has been commercially produced in tube product form. This SP2215 new austenitic heat-resisting steel is recommended to be used as superheater/reheater components for 620°C USC boiler application.

Energy requirements and environmental concerns have promoted a development in higher-efficiency coal fired power technologies. Advanced ultra-super critical power plant with an efficiency of higher than 50% is the target in the near future. The materials to be used due to the tougher environments become therefore critical issues. This paper provides a review on a newly developed advanced high strength heat resistant austenitic stainless steel, Sandvik Sanicro 25, for this purpose. The material shows good resistance to steam oxidation and flue gas corrosion, and has higher creep rupture strength than any other austenitic stainless steels available today, and has recently obtained two AMSE code cases. This makes it an interesting option in higher pressures/temperature applications. In this paper, the material development, structure stability, creep strength, steam oxidation and hot corrosion behaviors, fabricability and weldability of this alloy have been discussed. The conclusion is that the Sanicro 25 is a potential candidate for superheaters and reheaters in higher-efficiency coal fired boilers i.e. for applications seeing up to 700°C material temperature.

Inconel alloy 740H is designated for boiler sueprheater/reheater tubes and main steam/header pipes application of advanced ultra-supercritical (A-USC) power plant at operating temperatures above 750°C. Microstructure evolution and precipitates stability in the samples of alloy 740H after creep-rupture test at 750°C, 800°C and 850°C were characterized in this paper by scanning electron microscopy, transmission electron microscopy and chemical phase analysis in details. The phase compositions of alloy 740H were also calculated by thermodynamic calculation. The research results indicate that the microstructure of this alloy keeps good thermal stability during creep-rupture test at 750°C, 800°C and 850°C. The precipitates are MC, M 23 C 6 and γ′ during creep-rupture test. The temperature of creep test has an important effect on the growth rate of γ′ phase. No harmful and brittle σ phase was found and also no γ′ to η transformation happened during creep. Thermodynamic calculations reveal almost all the major phases and their stable temperatures, fractions and compositions in the alloy. The calculated results of phase compositions are consistent with the results of chemical phase analysis. In brief, except of coarsening of γ′, Inconel alloy 740H maintains the very good structure stability at temperatures between 750°C and 850°C.

The EU NextGenPower-project aims at demonstrating Ni-alloys and coatings for application in high-efficiency power plants. Fireside corrosion lab and plants trials show that A263 and A617 perform similar while A740H outperforms them. Lab tests showed promising results for NiCr, Diamalloy3006 and SHS9172 coatings. Probe trials in six plants are ongoing. A617, A740H and A263 performed equally in steamside oxidation lab test ≤750°C while A617 and A740H outperformed A263 at 800°C; high pressure tests are planned. Slow strain rate testing confirmed relaxation cracking of A263. A creep-fatigue interaction test program for A263 includes LCF tests. Negative creep of A263 is researched with gleeble tests. A263 Ø80 - 500mm trial rotors are forged with optimized composition. Studies for designing and optimizing the forging process were done. Segregation free Ø300 and 1,000mm rotors have been forged. A263 – A263 and A293 – COST F rotor welding show promising results (A263 in precipitation hardened condition). Cast step blocks of A282, A263 and A740H showed volumetric cracking after heat treatment. New ‘as cast’ blocks of optimized composition are without cracks. A 750°C steam cycle has been designed with integrated CO 2 capture at 45% efficiency (LHV). Superheater life at ≤750°C and co-firing is modeled.

Development of the advanced USC (A-USC) boiler technology has been promoted in recent years, which targets 700°C steam condition. HR6W (Ni-23Cr-7W-Ti-Nb-25Fe) and HR35 (Ni-30Cr-6W-Ti-15Fe) have been developed for A-USC boiler tubes and pipes. The former alloy is mainly strengthened by Fe 2 W type Laves phase. The latter one employs precipitation strengthening of α-Cr phase in addition to Laves phase. Characteristic alloy design of both alloys, which does not use precipitation strengthening of γ′ phase (Ni 3 Al), leads to superior ductility and resistance to stress-relaxation cracking. Stability of creep strength and microstructure has been confirmed by long-term creep rupture tests. The 100,000h average creep rupture strength of HR6W is 85MPa at 700C. That of HR35 is 126MPa at 700°C which is comparable with conventional Alloy617. Tubes of both alloys have been evaluated by the component test in Japanese national A-USC project with γ′ hardened Alloy617 and Alloy263. Detailed creep strength, deformation behavior and microstructural evolution of these alloys are described from the viewpoint of the difference in strengthening mechanisms. Capability of these alloys for A-USC boiler materials has been demonstrated by the component test in the commercial coal fired boiler as the part of the A-USC project.

Increasing the steam temperature of a coal-fired pulverized coal (PC) power plant increases its efficiency, which decreases the amount of coal required per MW of electrical output and therefore decreases the emissions from the plant, including CO 2 . However, increasing the steam temperature requires that the materials for the boiler pressure parts and steam turbine be upgraded to high-nickel alloys that are more expensive than alloys typically used in existing PC units. This paper explores the economics of A-USC units operating between 595°C and 760°C (1100°F to 1400°F) with no CO 2 removal and with partial capture of CO 2 at an emission limit of 454 kg CO 2 /MW-hr (1000 lb CO 2 /MW-hr) on a gross power basis. The goal of the paper is to understand if the improved efficiency of A-USC would reduce the cost of electricity compared to conventional ultra-supercritical units, and estimate the economically “optimal” steam temperature with and without CO 2 removal.

In recent years continuous and extensive research and development activities have been being done worldwide on 700°C A-USC (Advanced Ultra Super Critical) power plants to achieve higher efficiency and reduce the CO 2 emission. Increasing steam temperature and pressure of such A-USC boilers under consideration require the adoption of Ni based alloys. In the Japanese national project launched in 2008, Ni based alloy HR6W (45Ni-23Cr-7W-Ti, ASME Code Case 2684) is one of the candidate materials for boiler tube and pipe as well as Alloy617, Alloy263 and Alloy740H. The most important issues in A-USC boiler fabrication are the establishment of proper welding process for thick wall components of these alloys and verification of the long term reliability of their weldments. In our previous study, the weldability of HR6W was investigated and the welding process for Ni based thick wall pipe was established with the narrow gap HST (Hot wire Switching TIG) welding procedure originally developed by Babcock-Hitachi K.K. In this paper, creep rupture strengths of HR6W weldment were verified by the long term test up to 60,000 hours for tube and 40,000 hours for pipe. In Japanese national project, narrow gap HST welding process was also applied to the welding test for the other Ni based candidate pipe materials. Furthermore, as the practical A-USC boiler manufacturing trials, header mockup test was conducted and qualified for HR6W.

Addressing the growing concern of supercritical and ultra-supercritical boilers as potential safety hazards in power plants, a new Boiler Risk Management and Life Prediction System (BRMLPS) has been developed. This system leverages risk-based inspection and assessment techniques alongside life prediction and management methods. The BRMLPS focuses on evaluating and ranking the risk associated with critical boiler components, such as heating surfaces, headers, and drums. This risk assessment allows for the development of targeted and efficient inspection plans and repair strategies, ultimately aiming to minimize accident rates, reduce potential losses, and optimize safety investments. By implementing this system, power plants can achieve maintenance optimization, balancing safety and economic considerations for their specialized equipment.

Recently, boiler waterwall tube damage such as fireside corrosion and circumferential cracking in low NOx environments has become a serious issue in Japan, despite the typical use of relatively lower sulfur content coal is typically being used than in US. Thermal spray coating has been the most popular method for tube protection in Japan, and thermal spray coated tubes have been used for this purpose. However, extensive damage to thermal spray coating tubes from cracking and exfoliation has been recently experienced. It has been reported that the thermal fluctuations occurring due to operational changes create alternating stress, leading to cracking and exfoliation of the thermal sprayed thin coating. Corrosion-resistant weld overlays, such as Type 309 stainless steel (in sub-critical boilers) and Alloy 622 (in sub-critical and super-critical boilers), are commonly used to protect boiler tubes from corrosion in low NOx coal fired boilers in U.S. In order to develop a fundamental understanding of the high temperature corrosive behavior of Alloy 622 weld overlay, gaseous corrosion testing and certain mechanical tests for consideration of long-term aging were undertaken. After four years of service in the low NOx combustion environment of a coal fired supercritical boiler, field tests on Alloy 622 weld overlay panels are in continuation. This paper describes the field test behavior of Alloy 622 weld overlay panels installed in a Japanese supercritical boiler, the laboratory results of weight loss corrosion testing, and the results of cyclic bend tests with overlay welded tubes related to aging.