This paper explores the low cycle fatigue (LCF) and creep-fatigue properties of a hot-forged, normalized, and tempered 9Cr-1Mo ferritic steel. This steel offers good performance in high-temperature applications (up to 873K) in power plants and reactors. The steel was forged into 70 mm diameter rods and then heat-treated with normalizing (1313K for 1 hour, air cooling) and tempering (1033K for 1 hour, air cooling). LCF tests were conducted at 300-873K with varying strain amplitudes and strain rates to understand the influence of both factors. Additionally, some specimens were aged at different temperatures for 10,000 hours before testing. Finally, creep-fatigue interaction tests were performed at 823K and 873K using tensile hold times ranging from 1 to 30 minutes.

The EU NextGenPower-project aims at demonstrating Ni-alloys and coatings for application in high-efficiency power plants. Fireside corrosion lab and plants trials show that A263 and A617 perform similar while A740H outperforms them. Lab tests showed promising results for NiCr, Diamalloy3006 and SHS9172 coatings. Probe trials in six plants are ongoing. A617, A740H and A263 performed equally in steamside oxidation lab test ≤750°C while A617 and A740H outperformed A263 at 800°C; high pressure tests are planned. Slow strain rate testing confirmed relaxation cracking of A263. A creep-fatigue interaction test program for A263 includes LCF tests. Negative creep of A263 is researched with gleeble tests. A263 Ø80 - 500mm trial rotors are forged with optimized composition. Studies for designing and optimizing the forging process were done. Segregation free Ø300 and 1,000mm rotors have been forged. A263 – A263 and A293 – COST F rotor welding show promising results (A263 in precipitation hardened condition). Cast step blocks of A282, A263 and A740H showed volumetric cracking after heat treatment. New ‘as cast’ blocks of optimized composition are without cracks. A 750°C steam cycle has been designed with integrated CO 2 capture at 45% efficiency (LHV). Superheater life at ≤750°C and co-firing is modeled.

Creep-fatigue tests strain-controlled with different strain amplitudes and different hold times at 725 were done on nickel-based alloy 617 as a typical candidate material for turbine rotor of advanced ultra-supercritical power plant. Stress relaxes during the hold time when the strain remains at the tensile peak. The analysis of the stress relaxation during different strain hold times shows that the ratio of the relaxation stress and the maximum stresses has strong correlation with strain amplitude and hold time. The failure life also has a certain dependence on the relaxation stress ratio. The failure life decreases and the relaxation stress ratio increases as the strain amplitude increases. The failure life decreases and the relaxation stress ratio increases as the hold time increases. Therefore the stress relaxation ratio was used as an intermediate variable to obtain the corresponding relationship model by establishing the relationship between the relaxation stress ratio and the strain and the relationship between the relaxation stress ratio and the failure life. This model can be used to predict the creep-fatigue interaction life more simply and directly.

A significant research and development effort is underway to support the qualification of Alloy 709 as a Class A construction material in the American Society of Mechanical Engineers (ASME) Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code, Section III, Division 5, High Temperature Reactors. This initiative includes a comprehensive Alloy 709 code qualification plan aimed at generating extensive material testing data crucial for compiling the code case data package. The data package is essential in establishing material-specific design parameters for Alloy 709 to be used as Section III, Division 5 Class A construction material for fast reactors, molten salt reactors and gas-cooled reactors. An ASME Section III, Division 5 material code case requires the evaluation of mechanical properties from a minimum of three commercial heats, covering anticipated compositional ranges. A key part of the data package involves fatigue and creep-fatigue testing at elevated temperatures, needed for developing the fatigue design curves and the damage envelope of the creep-fatigue interaction diagram (D-diagram). This paper summarizes the strain-controlled fatigue testing on three commercial heats of Alloy 709 at 760 and 816°C with strain ranges between 0.25% and 3%. The fatigue failure data are used to generate a preliminary fatigue design curve. Additionally, the creep-fatigue testing results at 816°C with tensile hold times of 10, 30, and 60 minutes are presented in support of developing the D-diagram for Alloy 709.

A comprehensive EPRI initiative launched in 2006 has addressed the critical need to better understand creep-fatigue interactions in power plants experiencing cyclic operation. This international collaboration of industry experts has focused on evaluating current test methods, analyzing crack initiation and growth methodologies, examining life prediction approaches for various applications, identifying deficiencies in creep-fatigue damage assessment, and determining future research requirements. This paper presents key findings from the project, with particular attention to the performance of creep-strengthened ferritic steels, specifically Grade 91 and 92 steels, providing essential insights for power plants facing increasingly demanding operational conditions.

The creep-fatigue properties of steam turbine materials such as the 1%CrMoV steel traditionally adopted for steam inlet temperatures up to ~565°C, the newer advanced 9-11%Cr steels for applications up to ~600°C, and the nickel based Alloy 617 for potential use to >700°C are reviewed, in particular with reference to their cyclic/hold test crack initiation endurances. The results of cyclic/hold creep-fatigue tests are commonly employed to establish the damage summation diagrams used to form the basis of a number of creep-fatigue assessment procedures, and it is demonstrated that care should be exercised in the way such diagrams are interpreted to compare the creep-fatigue resistances of different alloy types. The form of such damage diagrams is dependent, not only on the analytical procedures used to define the respective fatigue and creep damage fractions, but also on both the deformation and damage interaction mechanisms displayed by the material.

Procedures for assessing components subjected to cyclic loading at high temperatures require material property data that characterize creep-fatigue deformation behavior and resistance to cracking. While several standards and codes define test procedures for acquiring low cycle fatigue (LCF) and creep properties, no formal guidelines exist for determining creep-fatigue data. This paper reviews the results of a global survey conducted by EPRI to support the development of a new draft testing procedure intended for submission to ASTM and, ultimately, ISO standards committees. The survey included a review of relevant national and international standards, as well as responses to a questionnaire distributed to high-temperature testing specialists in Europe, North America, and Japan. Additionally, standards related to the calibration of load, extension, and temperature measurement devices were examined. The questionnaire responses provided insights into test specimen geometry, testing equipment, control and measurement of load, extension, and temperature, and data acquisition practices. This paper outlines the background and considerations for the proposed guidance in the new standard.

The creep-fatigue properties of modified 9Cr-1Mo (grade 91) steel have been investigated for the purpose of design in cyclic service. In this paper test results from creep-fatigue (CF) and low cycle fatigue (LCF) on grade 91 steel are reported. The tests performed on the high precision pneumatic loading system (HIPS) are in the temperature range of 550-600ºC, total strain range of 0.7-0.9% and with hold periods in both tension and compression. Curves of cyclic softening and stress relaxation are presented. The CF test results and results obtained from literature are also analysed using methods described in the assessment and design codes of RCC-MRx, R5 and ASME NH as well as by the recently developed Φ-model. It is shown that the number of cycles to failure for CF data can be accurately predicted by the simple Φ-model. The practicality in using the life fraction rule for presenting the combined damage is discussed and recommendations for alternative approaches are made.

Significant development is being carried out worldwide for establishing advanced ultra supercritical power plant technology which aims enhancement of plant efficiency and reduction of emissions, through increased inlet steam temperature of 750°C and pressure of 350 bar. Nickel base superalloy, 50Ni-24Cr-20Co-0.6Mo-1Al-1.6Ti-2Nb alloy, is being considered as a promising material for superheater tubes and turbine rotors operating at ultra supercritical steam conditions. Thermal fluctuations impose low cycle fatigue loading in creep regime of this material and there is limited published fatigue and creep-fatigue characteristics data available. The scope of the present study includes behavior of the alloy under cyclic loading at operating temperature. Strain controlled low cycle fatigue tests, carried out within the strain range of 0.2%-1%, indicate substantial hardening at all temperatures. It becomes more evident with increasing strain amplitude which is attributed to the cumulative effects of increased dislocation density and immobilization of dislocation by γ′ precipitates. Deformation mechanism which influences fatigue life at 750°C as a function of strain rate is identified. Hold times up to 500 seconds are introduced at 750°C to evaluate the effect of creep fatigue interaction on fatigue crack growth, considered as one of the primary damage mode. The macroscopic performance is correlated with microscopic deformation characteristics.

Enhanced life assessment methods contribute to the long-term operation of high-temperature components by reducing technical risks and increasing economic benefits. This study investigates creep-fatigue behavior under multi-stage loading, including cold start, warm start, and hot start cycles, as seen in medium-loaded power plants. During hold times, creep and stress relaxation accelerate crack initiation. Creep-fatigue life can be estimated using a modified damage accumulation rule that incorporates the fatigue fraction rule for fatigue damage and the life fraction rule for creep damage while accounting for mean stress effects, internal stress, and creep-fatigue interaction. In addition to generating advanced creep, fatigue, and creep-fatigue data, scatter band analyses are necessary to establish design curves and lower-bound properties. To improve life prediction methods, further advancements in deformation and lifetime modeling are essential. Verification requires complex experiments under variable creep conditions and multi-stage creep-fatigue interactions. A key challenge remains the development of methods to translate uniaxial material properties to multiaxial loading scenarios. Additionally, this study introduces a constitutive material model, implemented as a user subroutine for finite element applications, to simulate start-up and shut-down phases of components. Material parameter identification has been achieved using neural networks.

Creep rupture strength is the principal material property prioritized in designing power generation plants against the steady-state stress due to internal pressure. Increasingly plants must cycle so there is a possibility of life reduction due to creep-fatigue interaction. Grade 92 steel is one of the creep strength enhanced ferritic (CSEF) steels which has superior creep strength compared to other CSEFs. It is expected to be widely used in coal-fired ultra-super critical plants as well as in LNG-fired combined cycle plants. However, at present there is insufficient information regarding the creep-fatigue behavior of this material. A joint study has been conducted to understand the behavior of this steel under creep-fatigue condition and see how accurate the failure life can be estimated. Three kinds of base materials as well as two kinds of welded joints have been tested under strain-controlled cyclic loading with or without hold times as well as under constant load creep condition. Continued decrease in the number of cycles to failure was observed with the extension of hold time in all the base metals and cross-weld specimens. It was found that the modified ductility exhaustion approach based on inelastic strain, as well as its extension employing the inelastic strain energy density, made reasonably accurate predictions of failure lives under a wide range of test conditions. Temperature- and rate-dependencies of fracture limits in terms of inelastic strain and energy density were able to be uniquely expressed using simple thermal activation energy parameters.

There are main drivers for the design and assessment of steam turbine components of today such as demands for improved materials, higher plant cycling operation, and reduced life-cycle costs. New materials have been developed over the last decades resulting in advanced martensitic 9-10CrMoV steels already applied in different types of turbines successfully. Heavy cyclic loading getting more importance than in the past results in utilization of the fatigue capabilities at high and low temperatures which might lead to crack initiation and subsequent crack propagation. Fracture mechanics methods and evaluation concepts have demonstrated their applicability to assess the integrity of components with defects or crack-like outage findings. Based on realistic modelling of the failure mechanism, accurate prediction of crack sizes at failure state can be improved defining the appropriate damage criteria. Ductility is a main aspect for robust design but its value definition can depend on component type, design rules, real loading conditions, service experience, and material characteristics. The question which direct material parameter is able to serve as limit value in design and how it can be determined has to be solved. Examples of advanced analysis methods for creep crack growth and fatigue interaction involving the crack initiation time show that the reserves of new martensitic 9-10Cr steels in high temperature application can be well quantified. The creep rupture elongation A u and the loading conditions in the crack far field are main factors. If the A u value is sufficient high also after long-time service, the material remains robust against cracks. Investigations into the influence of stress gradients on life time under fatigue and creep fatigue conditions show that e.g. for 10CrMoWV rotor steel crack growth involvement offers further reserves. The consideration of constraint effect in fracture mechanics applied to suitable materials allows for further potentials to utilize margin resulting from classical design. The new gained knowledge enables a more precise determination of component life time via an adapted material exploitation and close interaction with advanced design rules.

Martensitic steel P91 with higher creep strength was first introduced as thick section components in power plants some 18 years ago. However, more recently a number of failures have been experienced in both thick and thin section components and this has given rise to re-appraisal of this steel. Thick section components are generally known to have failed due to Type IV cracking. Furthermore, due to the restructuring of the electricity industry worldwide many of the existing steam plant are now required to operate in cycling mode and this requires the use of materials with high resistance to thermal fatigue . Here high strength P91 is assumed to offer an additional benefit in that the reduced section thickness increases pipework flexibility and reduces the level of through wall temperature gradients in thick section components. Because of this envisaged benefit a number of operators/owners of the existing plant, especially in the UK, have been substituting these new higher strength steels for the older materials, especially when a plant is moved from base load to cyclic operation. There has also been a perceived advantage of higher steam side oxidation resistance of superheater tubes made from high Cr steels. For the Heat Recovery Steam Generators (HRSGs) used in Combined Cycle Gas Turbines (CCGTs) there is a requirement to produce compact size units and thus high strength steels are used to make smaller size components. This paper discusses these issues and compares the envisaged benefits with the actual plant experience and more recent R&D findings. In view of these incidents of cracking and failures it is important to develop life assessment tools for components made from P91 steel. ETD has been working on this through a ‘multi-client project' and this aspect will be discussed in this paper.

Ni-base superalloys used for hot section hardware of gas turbine systems experience thermomechanical fatigue (TMF), creep, and environmental degradation. The blades and vanes of industrial gas turbines (IGTs) are made from superalloys that are either directionally-solidified (DS) or cast as single crystals (SX). Consequently, designing and evaluating these alloys is complex since life depends on the crystallographic orientation in addition to the complexities related to the thermomechanical cycling and the extent of hold times at elevated temperature. Comparisons between the more complex TMF tests and simpler isothermal low cycle fatigue (LCF) tests with hold times as cyclic test methods for qualifying alternative repair, rejuvenation, and heat-treatment procedures are discussed. Using the extensive set of DS and SX data gathered from the open literature, a probabilistic physics-guided neural network is developed and trained to estimate life considering the influence of crystallographic orientation, temperature, and several other cycling and loading parameters.

Grade 92 steel, a creep strength-enhanced ferritic (CSEF) steel, is used in supercritical steam fossil power plants for boilers and piping systems. While its creep strength is crucial, understanding the interaction between creep and fatigue damage is also vital for assessing component integrity under cyclic loading. Despite existing studies on its creep-fatigue behavior, additional data under creep-dominant conditions relevant to plant evaluations are needed. Girth welds, critical to piping system integrity, are particularly important in this context. EPRI and CRIEPI initiated a project to develop a comprehensive database on the creep-fatigue behavior of Grade 92 steel's base metal and welded joints and to establish a suitable life estimation procedure. Key findings include: (i) a thick pipe with submerged arc welding (SAW) was manufactured for testing; (ii) base metal and cross-weld specimens showed similar behavior under short-term creep and cyclic loading; (iii) these specimens had lower creep strengths than average literature values for this steel class in the short time regime, with differences decreasing as stress decreased; and (iv) the fatigue and creep-fatigue behavior of these specimens were similar to those of Grade 91 and 122 steels, with common characteristics in creep-fatigue failure prediction models across the three CSEF steels.

This study presents a characterization of the microstructural evolutions taking place in a 9%Cr martensitic cast steel subjected to fatigue and creep-fatigue loading. Basis for this study of investigation is an extensive testing program performed on a sample heat of this type of steel by conducting a series of service-like high temperature creep-fatigue tests. The major goal here was to systematically vary specific effects in order to isolate and describe relevant damage contributing mechanisms. Furthermore, some of the tests have been interrupted at several percentages of damage to investigate not only the final microstructure but also their evolution. After performing those tests, the samples were examined using transmission electron microscopy (TEM) to characterize and quantify the microstructural evolutions. The size distribution of subgrains and the dislocation density were determined by using thin metal foils in TEM. A recovery process consisting of the coarsening of the subgrains and a decrease of the dislocation density was observed in different form. This coarsening is heterogeneous and depends on the applied temperature, strain amplitude and hold time. These microstructural observations are consistent with the very fast deterioration of creep properties due to cyclic loading.

Creep-fatigue lives of nickel-based Alloy 617 and Alloy 740H were investigated to evaluate their applicability to advanced ultrasupercritical (A-USC) power plants. Strain controlled push-pull creep-fatigue tests were performed using solid bar specimen under triangular and trapezoidal waveforms at 700°C. The number of cycles to failure was experimentally obtained for both alloys and the applicability of three representative life prediction methods was studied.

To improve efficiency and flexibility and reduce CO 2 emissions, advanced ultra super critical (AUSC) power plants are under development, worldwide. Material development and its selection are critical to the success of these efforts. In several research and development programs / projects the selection of materials is based on stress rupture, oxidation and corrosion tests. Without doubt, these criteria are important. To improve the operational flexibility of modern power plants the fatigue properties are of increased importance. Furthermore, for a safe operation and integrity issues the knowledge about the crack behavior is essential. Crack initiation and crack growth may be caused by natural flaws or cracks induced by component operation. In order to develop new materials, properties like tensile strength and creep strength are an important part of qualification and subsequent approval by notified bodies. Consequently short term properties as well as time-temperature dependent properties are generated and taken into considerations. In the case of high strength γ'-strengthening nickel-base alloys investigating the creep crack behavior is also strongly recommended. This article shows results of currently investigated nickel-based alloys for newly developed headers, pipes and other high temperature boiler applications and their critical creep crack propagation behavior.

This paper examines elevated-temperature materials behavior through two perspectives: that of component designers/stress analysts and developers of elevated-temperature design criteria. It explores challenges in design and structural integrity evaluation, focusing on how elevated temperature design criteria originally developed for nuclear components can be adapted for non-nuclear power and petrochemical applications, particularly those under cyclic loading conditions. A central challenge lies in extrapolating from limited specimen data—gathered under specific time periods, loading conditions, and geometries—to predict behavior in complex structures subjected to variable short-term and long-term loading patterns. The paper concludes by proposing a pathway for developing elevated-temperature design criteria specifically for power and petrochemical plant components operating cyclically in the creep regime.

This paper presents the creep and creep-fatigue crack growth behaviors of 30Cr1Mo1V turbine rotor steel which had been in service for 16 years. Two typical sections of the rotor, i.e. high and low temperature sections, are examined at 538°C, with crack initiation and propagation monitored by D.C. potential drop method in a compact tension (CT) specimen. The material of the high temperature section has the lower resistance to creep and creep-fatigue crack growths than the low temperature section. The creep crack initiation (CCI) time decreases with the increase of initial stress intensity factor. The creep-fatigue crack growth (CFCG) is dominated by the cycle-dependent fatigue process when the hold time at the maximum load is shorter, but it becomes dominated by the time-dependent creep process when the hold time becomes longer. The high temperature section shows a larger influence of time-dependent creep behavior on CFCG than the low temperature section.