This paper presents the creep and creep-fatigue crack growth behaviors of 30Cr1Mo1V turbine rotor steel which had been in service for 16 years. Two typical sections of the rotor, i.e. high and low temperature sections, are examined at 538°C, with crack initiation and propagation monitored by D.C. potential drop method in a compact tension (CT) specimen. The material of the high temperature section has the lower resistance to creep and creep-fatigue crack growths than the low temperature section. The creep crack initiation (CCI) time decreases with the increase of initial stress intensity factor. The creep-fatigue crack growth (CFCG) is dominated by the cycle-dependent fatigue process when the hold time at the maximum load is shorter, but it becomes dominated by the time-dependent creep process when the hold time becomes longer. The high temperature section shows a larger influence of time-dependent creep behavior on CFCG than the low temperature section.

Creep-fatigue crack formation (endurance) and crack growth rate data are necessary inputs for assessing the structural integrity and for estimating the design life of high temperature components in power generation and aircraft engine industries. Ensuring consistency in the reported test data, as well as an understanding of the inherent scatter and its source in the data, are both necessary for assuring quality and limitations of the analyses that rely on the data. In 2008, the American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM) under the umbrella of its subcommittees E08.05 on Cyclic Deformation and Crack Formation and E08.06 on Crack Growth, and the sponsorship of Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI) through its international experts’ working group on creep-fatigue embarked on the task of developing separate standard test methods for creep-fatigue crack formation and creep-fatigue crack growth. The first standard entitled, “E-2714-09: Standard Test Method for Creep-fatigue Testing” was developed in 2009 and was followed up with a round-robin consisting of 13 laboratories around the world for testing the newly developed standard. This paper discusses the results of this round-robin concluded in 2012 using the widely used P91 steel that led to the formulation of the Precision and Bias statement contained in the version of the ASTM standard E2714 that was successfully balloted in the year 2013.

In today’s market place power generation plants throughout the world have been trying to reduce their operating costs by extending the service life of their critical machines such as steam turbines and gas turbines beyond the design life criteria. The key ingredient in plant life extension is remaining life assessment technology. This paper will outline remaining life procedures which will incorporate the defect tolerant design concepts applied to the various damage mechanisms such as creep, fatigue, creep-fatigue and stress corrosion cracking. Also other embrittlement mechanisms will also be discussed and how they will influence the life or operation of the component. Application of weld repairs to critical components such as rotors and steam chest casings will be highlighted and how defect tolerant design concept is applied for the repair procedure and the acceptance standard of the nondestructive testing applied. Also highlighted will be various destructive tests such as stress relaxation tests (SRT) which measures creep strength and constant displacement rate test (CDRT) which evaluates fracture resistance or notch ductility. Also shown will be actual life extension examples applied to steam turbine components and weld repairs. Utilization of computer software to calculate fatigue and creep fatigue crack growth will also be presented

There are main drivers for the design and assessment of steam turbine components of today such as demands for improved materials, higher plant cycling operation, and reduced life-cycle costs. New materials have been developed over the last decades resulting in advanced martensitic 9-10CrMoV steels already applied in different types of turbines successfully. Heavy cyclic loading getting more importance than in the past results in utilization of the fatigue capabilities at high and low temperatures which might lead to crack initiation and subsequent crack propagation. Fracture mechanics methods and evaluation concepts have demonstrated their applicability to assess the integrity of components with defects or crack-like outage findings. Based on realistic modelling of the failure mechanism, accurate prediction of crack sizes at failure state can be improved defining the appropriate damage criteria. Ductility is a main aspect for robust design but its value definition can depend on component type, design rules, real loading conditions, service experience, and material characteristics. The question which direct material parameter is able to serve as limit value in design and how it can be determined has to be solved. Examples of advanced analysis methods for creep crack growth and fatigue interaction involving the crack initiation time show that the reserves of new martensitic 9-10Cr steels in high temperature application can be well quantified. The creep rupture elongation A u and the loading conditions in the crack far field are main factors. If the A u value is sufficient high also after long-time service, the material remains robust against cracks. Investigations into the influence of stress gradients on life time under fatigue and creep fatigue conditions show that e.g. for 10CrMoWV rotor steel crack growth involvement offers further reserves. The consideration of constraint effect in fracture mechanics applied to suitable materials allows for further potentials to utilize margin resulting from classical design. The new gained knowledge enables a more precise determination of component life time via an adapted material exploitation and close interaction with advanced design rules.

To improve efficiency and flexibility and reduce CO 2 emissions, advanced ultra super critical (AUSC) power plants are under development, worldwide. Material development and its selection are critical to the success of these efforts. In several research and development programs / projects the selection of materials is based on stress rupture, oxidation and corrosion tests. Without doubt, these criteria are important. To improve the operational flexibility of modern power plants the fatigue properties are of increased importance. Furthermore, for a safe operation and integrity issues the knowledge about the crack behavior is essential. Crack initiation and crack growth may be caused by natural flaws or cracks induced by component operation. In order to develop new materials, properties like tensile strength and creep strength are an important part of qualification and subsequent approval by notified bodies. Consequently short term properties as well as time-temperature dependent properties are generated and taken into considerations. In the case of high strength γ'-strengthening nickel-base alloys investigating the creep crack behavior is also strongly recommended. This article shows results of currently investigated nickel-based alloys for newly developed headers, pipes and other high temperature boiler applications and their critical creep crack propagation behavior.

The use of the bainitic creep strength enhanced ferritic steel T/P23 has increased over the last decade in a wide range of applications including headers, superheater and reheater tubing and in waterwall tubing. Many issues have been reported in weldments of this material, such as hydrogen induced cracking, reheat cracking and stress corrosion cracking. In order to help characterize high temperature cracking phenomena, including reheat cracking, a limited number of laboratory creep crack growth tests are being conducted as part of an ongoing project. Tests were run on as-welded sections with the test specimen crack-tip located in select zones of the weldment. Test temperatures are intended to bookend the range of applications from a waterwall condition of ~482°C (900°F) to the superheat/reheat condition of 565°C (1050°F). This paper describes the results of some early testing at 482°C (900°F). The tests provided useful insight into the cracking susceptibility of the material at this temperature with respect to not only time-dependent cracking, but also fatigue crack growth and fracture toughness. The paper includes details of the test method and results, as well as findings from post-test metallographic examinations of the tested specimens.

In several material qualification programs tubes and thick-walled components mainly from Alloy 617 and Alloy 263 were investigated. Results as low cycle fatigue and long term creep behavior of base materials and welds are presented. Numerical models to describe the material behavior have been developed and verified by multiaxial tests. In order to ensure the feasibility of A-USC plants two test loops have been installed in GKM Mannheim – one for tube materials and a new one for thick-walled piping and components. The latter consists of a part with static loading and a part subjected to thermal cycles and is in operation since November 2012. First results of measurements and numerical calculations for a pipe bend (static loading) as well as pipes and a header (thermal cycles) are presented.

Single crystal Ni-base superalloys are subjected to tension hold at high temperature in addition to cyclic loading during the operation of gas turbines. Various studies have investigated creep-fatigue crack propagation in superalloys under trapezoidal loadings and evaluated the life time based on parameters such as creep J-integral. However, it is still unclear how damage field and stress-strain condition change at the crack tip during hold time, and how it affects on fatigue crack propagation. In this study, the influence of the tension hold and accompanying creep at crack tip on subsequent fatigue crack propagation behavior was evaluated by introducing single tension holds into pure cyclic loadings. The series of the experiments revealed that because of the tension hold, material degradation and stress relaxation occurred simultaneously ahead of crack tip. In the region where material was degraded, the resistance against crack propagation was reduced, while in the region where stress was relaxed, the crack driving force was lowered.

This study aims to examine the effects of grain boundary oxidation and creep on crack initiation and fracture behaviors in cold worked surface layer, under static tensile stresses in air. To determine these effects in relation to percent cold work and hardness scale, cold-rolled plates with a reduction ratios between 10% and 50% were prepared. Uniaxial constant load (UCL) tests were conducted at elevated temperature in air using smooth round bar specimen. UCL tests with a load of 0.9σy (926MPa) at 550°C show that rupture time for all cold- rolled materials were shorter than that of as-received material. From cross-sectional observation after UCL testing, surface crack at grain boundary and voids were observed in as-received material, whereas creep cracks were also observed in cold-rolled materials. This implied that crack initiation was assisted by cold working. Comparing test results with a load reduced to 0.8σy (823MPa), difference of rupture time was expected as a factor of 5 for as-received material, and measured as 2-3 for cold-rolled materials. It was suggested that cold worked layer was more sensitive to creep than base metal.

Significant development is being carried out worldwide for establishing advanced ultra supercritical power plant technology which aims enhancement of plant efficiency and reduction of emissions, through increased inlet steam temperature of 750°C and pressure of 350 bar. Nickel base superalloy, 50Ni-24Cr-20Co-0.6Mo-1Al-1.6Ti-2Nb alloy, is being considered as a promising material for superheater tubes and turbine rotors operating at ultra supercritical steam conditions. Thermal fluctuations impose low cycle fatigue loading in creep regime of this material and there is limited published fatigue and creep-fatigue characteristics data available. The scope of the present study includes behavior of the alloy under cyclic loading at operating temperature. Strain controlled low cycle fatigue tests, carried out within the strain range of 0.2%-1%, indicate substantial hardening at all temperatures. It becomes more evident with increasing strain amplitude which is attributed to the cumulative effects of increased dislocation density and immobilization of dislocation by γ′ precipitates. Deformation mechanism which influences fatigue life at 750°C as a function of strain rate is identified. Hold times up to 500 seconds are introduced at 750°C to evaluate the effect of creep fatigue interaction on fatigue crack growth, considered as one of the primary damage mode. The macroscopic performance is correlated with microscopic deformation characteristics.

This paper reports on a study that investigated how low cycle fatigue (LCF) and fatigue crack propagation (FCG) properties of P92, P122, and P23 steels vary between 600°C and 700°C depending on the location relative to a cross weld. Microstructure analysis was also performed on fractured specimens. Due to its higher yield strength, P122 exhibited the best continuous LCF life. However, creep-fatigue interaction (CFI) in the weld heat-affected zone (HAZ) of P122 and P23 steels significantly reduced their lifespans compared to continuous LCF tests. This reduction is attributed to the effect of weld thermal cycles on fine precipitates. FCG tests revealed that the base metal consistently outperformed the HAZ in all tested steels and temperatures. P92 and P122 showed similar FCG rates except for P92's behavior at 600°C, which resembled P23. In both steels, the HAZ exhibited faster FCG rates at 600°C and 700°C compared to the base metal, particularly at lower stress intensity factor ranges (ΔK). Within the HAZ, the region 1 mm from the fusion line displayed the slowest FCG rates, followed by the base metal, while the fusion line and the region 2 mm from it showed the fastest. Fracture surfaces near the fusion line displayed cleavage-like features, while the region 1 mm away exhibited features associated with higher crack growth resistance.

Cast nickel-based superalloys used as structural materials for gas turbine parts need to withstand high temperatures and dynamic mechanical loads. When in contact with ambient air, the formation of protective oxide scales causes a depletion of γ’-precipitates in the surface-near region and leaves a weakened microstructure. This environmentally based degradation of the material might be accelerated under cyclic thermal exposure. In this paper, the cyclic oxidation behavior of two cast nickel-based superalloys and one single crystalline variant are investigated: C1023, CM-247 LC and M-247 SX. Exposure tests were carried out under both isothermal and cyclic conditions in air at 850 °C, 950 °C and 1050 °C for times up to 120 h to investigate the impact of thermal cycling. The differences in oxidation mechanisms are analyzed phenomenologically via light and electron microscopy and brought in correlation with the oxidation kinetics, determined based on net mass change and depletion zone growth. An assessment of the impact of precipitation loss on local mechanical strength is attempted via nano-indentation method. The found relations can be transferred onto an acceleration of crack growth under creep-fatigue and thermo-mechanical fatigue conditions.

Future, flexible thermal energy conversion systems require new, demand-optimized high-performance materials. In order to provide a basis for the targeted development of fatigue-resistant, cost-effective steel grades, the microstructural damage to materials and the failure of conventional and novel steels were investigated in thermo-mechanical fatigue and fatigue crack propagation experiments. Based on the results, improved, ferritic “HiperFer” (High performance Ferrite) steels were designed, produced and characterized. A brief description of the current state of development is given.

Detailed knowledge of the creep and creep crack behavior is essential for a safe operation of thick-walled components in thermal power plants. High mechanical loads and temperatures of more than 700 °C often require the application of nickel-based alloys, e.g. alloy C-263. Unfortunately, manufacturing and non-destructive evaluation (NDE) of thick-walled components (> 50 mm) made of nickel-based alloys are quite challenging. Tolerable critical flaw sizes, experimentally validated for long service durations, play an important role in the quality assurance of such components. It is commonly accepted that manufacturing parameters, e.g. heat treatment procedures, have a significant influence on creep ductility and time-dependent crack behavior. By means of adjusting the process parameters, the ductility and the creep life of notched specimen can be significantly improved in the case of alloy C-263. Essential root cause is the decoration of grain boundaries with carbides which drastically influences creep crack initiation and growth. This results in significant differences for allowable critical flaw sizes and thus, the potential use of the candidate material. On a first generation of alloy C-263 “G1”, a dense population of carbides on the grain boundaries was found, which resulted in an inadmissible creep crack behavior. The resulting critical flaw sizes were only a few tenths of a millimeter. On a second generation “G2”, the grain boundary occupation was positively influenced, so that a satisfactory creep crack behavior could be found. The critical flaw sizes are in the order of one millimeter or more. A critical or impermissible material behavior under creep conditions can be demonstrated by testing smooth and notched round specimens. For example, the first generation “G1” notched round specimens fails earlier than the smooth round specimens, indicating notch sensitivity. On the second generation “G2”, however, a notch insensitivity was found. The critical defect sizes can be determined by a method that takes into account a simultaneous examination of the crack tip situation and the ligament situation.

This study presents a characterization of the microstructural evolutions taking place in a 9%Cr martensitic cast steel subjected to fatigue and creep-fatigue loading. Basis for this study of investigation is an extensive testing program performed on a sample heat of this type of steel by conducting a series of service-like high temperature creep-fatigue tests. The major goal here was to systematically vary specific effects in order to isolate and describe relevant damage contributing mechanisms. Furthermore, some of the tests have been interrupted at several percentages of damage to investigate not only the final microstructure but also their evolution. After performing those tests, the samples were examined using transmission electron microscopy (TEM) to characterize and quantify the microstructural evolutions. The size distribution of subgrains and the dislocation density were determined by using thin metal foils in TEM. A recovery process consisting of the coarsening of the subgrains and a decrease of the dislocation density was observed in different form. This coarsening is heterogeneous and depends on the applied temperature, strain amplitude and hold time. These microstructural observations are consistent with the very fast deterioration of creep properties due to cyclic loading.

In the test loop HWT II (High Temperature Materials Test Loop) installed in the fossil power plant Grosskraftwerk (GKM) Mannheim in Germany, thick-walled components made of nickel base alloys were operated up to temperature of 725 °C. The operation mode chosen (creep-fatigue) was to simulate a large number of start-ups and shutdowns with high gradients as expected for future high efficient and flexible power plants and to investigate the damage due to thermal fatigue of the used nickel base alloys. In this paper the damage evolution of a header made of the nickel base alloys Alloy 617 B and Alloy C263, which was a part of HWT II test rig, were investigated using nondestructive and destructive techniques. Furthermore, the damage has been considered and evaluated by using numerical methods. In addition, different lifetime assessment methods of standards and recommendations with focus on creep-fatigue damage were used and evaluated. The different lifetime models are applied to the header and the results were compared to the results of metallographic investigations and damage observations.

The A286 is one of the earliest superalloys developed. It has been used for manufacturing different components of turbo machineries because of its balanced high temperature properties. These components include shafts, discs, spacers, blades and fasteners. This paper reviews some of the issues and recent field experiences related to metallurgy, fabrication, in-service evaluation and failure of some of these components. The fabrication aspects including the effects of alloy melting processes, forging parameters and different types of heat treatments on the processed parts are discussed. The importance of these factors on the microstructure and properties of A286 are highlighted. The effects of service exposure on some of these parts are also discussed. In service evaluation involves checking for service induced damage or changes in microstructures and properties so that the suitability of the part for continued service can be determined. The failure analysis section of the paper briefly discusses failures of two expander wheels and an expander disc made out of A286 to pinpoint some of the salient features of damage accumulation and fracture during service.

A material test loop has been installed at GKM Mannheim, which enables thick-walled components of future highly-efficient power plants to be exposed to steam temperatures of up to 725 °C. The project goal was to demonstrate the feasibility of a 700 °C power plant.

9-12%Cr martensitic steels can be applied to the next highest temperature components such as boiler tracts, steam pipelines and turbines of advanced ultra-supercritical power plants with steam temperatures of 650°C. New 10%Cr martensitic steels with high B and low N contents can be a worthy candidate for use in production because it has superior creep resistance. At the same time, resistance to cyclic and dynamic loads is very important. In this work, we studied the low cycle fatigue (LCF) properties at room and elevated (500-650°C) temperatures and Charpy impact toughness at temperatures ranging from -196…100°C of advanced 10% Cr martensitic steel with high B and low N contents. The effect of new alloying scheme and corresponding peculiarities of M 23 C 6 carbides on the low cycle fatigue resistance and impact toughness of the 10%Cr martensitic steel is analyzed. It is revealed that fine and densely distributed carbides has no effect on the fatigue resistance except for the slight improvement of fatigue life at small strain amplitudes and shift the ductile-brittle transition temperature (DBTT) to higher but satisfactory value of +10°C as compared to other high-chromium martensitic steels.

Driven by the need to reduce CO 2 emissions through increased steam temperature and pressure in new power plants, research in Europe led to the development of enhanced high-chromium steels with improved creep resistance and service temperature stability. After years of development, Rotor E, a steel composition created during the COST programs (501, 522, and 536), has become a commercially available product. While traditionally forged and remelted using electroslag remelting (ESR), this paper demonstrates the successful production of large rotor components using a conventional process without ESR, achieved through tailored process control. This paper details Società delle Fucine's (SdF) current production of Rotor E using a conventional route based on ladle furnace and vacuum degassing, as well as the mechanical and creep behaviors of the resulting forged products. Additionally, SdF produced a prototype FB2 rotor using a conventional process. FB2, a 10% Cr steel containing cobalt and boron but lacking tungsten, emerged from the COST 522 program as the best candidate for scaling up from a laboratory experiment to a full-sized industrial component. Notably, the addition of boron effectively improved the microstructure's stability and consequently enhanced the creep resistance of these new, advanced martensitic steels. Finally, the paper will present updates on the long-term characterization program for the FB2 steel trial rotor.