Long-term creep rupture tests up to 10 5 hours at 600℃ and 650℃ were carried out on mod.9Cr- 1Mo steel base metal and weldments from five different materials, consisting of various chemical compositions and heat treatments as well as welding conditions. As a result, positive correlations of creep rupture strength were clarified between the base metal and weldments from the same materials. Microstructural observations and thermokinetic calculations revealed that the strength correlations were attributed to the precipitation strengthening behavior of finely dispersed M 23 C 6 carbides and V-type MX carbonitrides, where their precipitation distribution characteristic in the fine-grained HAZ microstructures partially or almost entirely took over those in base metal. This finding implies that the long-term creep rupture strength of mod.9Cr-1Mo steel weldment might be able to be evaluated as long as the corresponding base metal strength is obtained.

Creep strength degradation behavior of normalized and tempered 2.25Cr-1.6W-V-Nb(Gr.23) steel was investigated by conducting extra long-term creep rupture tests. Creep strength drop was observed in long-term creep range at 600°C and above, while signs of a creep strength drop were not identified at 550°C and 575°C. Creep strength drop of around 110 MPa at 600°C was caused not by the effect of oxidation but rather by a change of the deformation mechanism or the weakening of deformation resistance by the microstructural change during creep. The effect of oxidation was significant for causing a further creep strength drop in the range which exceeded 20,000 h in rupture time at 600°C. As a result, the creep strength at 60 MPa and 600°C was almost the same regardless of long tempered or aged steel.

18Cr-9Ni-3Cu-Nb-N steel is widely used for heat exchanger tubes such as super-heaters and reheaters of ultra-super critical power generation boilers. In this study, long-term creep rupture tests were carried out on 18Cr-9Ni-3Cu-Nb-N seamless steel tubes of 7 heat materials, and the specimens of 2 heat materials with different creep rupture strengths were observed by ultra-low voltage scanning electron microscope after creep rupture tests. The results of the investigation of the creep rupture specimens and the coverage ratios of M 23 C 6 on grain boundary were different. The cause of this was estimated to be the difference in B content between the 2 heat materials. Creep rupture tests with different final ST temperatures were also carried out using the same heat material, and it was revealed that the higher final ST temperature, the higher the creep rupture strength. As the final ST temperature is higher, the amount of Nb(C, N) solid solution in the matrix increases, and the amount of precipitation of NbCrN and M 23 C 6 increases during creep, therefore it is assumed that the creep rupture strength increases.

This study aims to elucidate the chemical compositions and microstructural factors that affect longterm creep rupture strength and creep rupture ductility using multiple heats of Gr.92 steel. Evaluating the reduction behavior in long-term creep rupture strength, we propose a relative creep rupture strength value, which is expressed as the logarithmic ratio of the estimated creep strength for each rupture time exceeding 10,000 hours, with 10,000 hours as the reference. Higher initial hardness correlates with greater pronounced strength reduction in the long-term regime. While smaller prior austenite grain sizes lead to greater reductions in creep rupture strength, this effect diminishes above 30 μm. However, no clear correlation was observed between Cr content and creep strength reduction in this study. Brittle creep ruptures with smooth test specimens were observed just below the extensometer ridge in the parallel section of test specimen, indicating notch weakening. Even in heats with excellent creep ductility, the amount of inclusions tended to be higher than in heats with lower creep ductility. Factors other than inclusions also seem to influence long-term creep ductility.

The reasonable procedures for estimation of 100,000 h creep rupture strength have been investigated for Alloy 617 and Alloy 740 for A-USC power plants by Larson Miller method. The creep rupture data of longer duration than 500 h in the temperature range between 593 and 816 °C and between 600 and 850 °C were used for the analysis on Alloy 617 and Alloy 740, respectively. The data were obtained by Special Metals. In these temperature ranges, Ni3Al-γ’ can precipitate in Alloy 617 and Alloy 740 during creep. The maximum time to rupture was 40,126.7 and 24,066 h for Alloy 617 and Alloy 740, respectively. The rupture data for Alloy 617 exhibit large scattering, especially at 760 °C, showing a split into two groups. After eliminating the shorter time to rupture data at 760 °C, the regression analysis using the second order equation of Larson-Miller parameter gives us the Larson-Miller constant C of 12.70 and the 100,000 h creep rupture strength of 100 MPa at 700 °C. The regression analysis underestimates the constant C and corresponding 100,000 h creep rupture strength of Alloy 617, as shown by the regression curves locating below the rupture data at long times, while those locating above the rupture data at short times. The underestimation of constant C is caused by large data scattering. The linear extrapolation of log tr versus reciprocal temperature 1/T plot to 1/T = 0 at constant stresses gives us the constant C of 18.5, which is much larger than that by the regression analysis. Using an appropriate constant C of 18.45, the 100,000 h creep rupture strength of Alloy 617 is estimated to be 123 MPa at 700 °C. On the other hand, the rupture data for Alloy 740 exhibit only a little bit scattering. The regression analysis gives us C = 18.45, which agrees very well with that by the linear extrapolation of log tr versus 1/T plot to 1/T = 0. The 100,000 h creep rupture strength of Alloy 740 is estimated to be 214 and 109 MPa at 700 and 760 °C, respectively.

The influence of holding time during tempering on the long-term creep rupture strength of mod.9Cr-1Mo steel was investigated in this study, so as to elucidate proper heat treatment for boiler applications. Tempering was conducted at 770°C for 0.5h, 1h, 3h, 10h and 100h for the test materials, after re-normalization at 1050°C for 1h in all cases. Creep rupture tests were conducted at 600°C, and ruptured specimens were investigated to better understand the microstructural changes, including changes in the number density of precipitates, in order to observe and discuss their creep strength. All creep rupture test results for materials tempered within 10h exceeded the average creep strength of T91. Shorter tempering times such as 0.5h and 1h were clearly correlated with longer time to rupture at 600°C under 80MPa to 100MPa stress conditions. Reduction of area in creep-ruptured specimens decreased principally with lowered creep stress. Materials tempered for 0.5h and 100h showed the lowest reduction of area at 90MPa and 100MPa respectively, and their reduction of area recovered at lower than those stress levels. These stresses, showing minimum reduction of area, met inflection stress in the creep rupture strength curve.

As flux cored wires for gas metal arc welding offer several technical and economic advantages they are becoming more and more popular. Matching flux cored wires for welding P92 have already been available for several years. A matching flux cored wire for welding the Co-alloyed cast steel CB2, which is used for turbine and valve casings operating at steam temperatures of up to 620°C, was developed recently. To connect casings with P92 pipes, dissimilar welding of CB2 to P92 is necessary. This can be done with filler metal that matches either CB2 or P92. Pre-tests have confirmed that flux cored arc welding (FCAW) can generally be used for dissimilar joint welding of CB2 to P92. To evaluate creep rupture strength dissimilar welds were performed with filler metal matching CB2 and P92, respectively. TIG welding was used for the root and the second pass and FCAW for the intermediate and final passes. Cross-weld tensile tests, side bend tests and impact tests of weld metals and heat-affected zones were carried out at ambient temperatures after two post-weld heat treatments (PWHT), each at 730°C for 12 hours. Creep rupture tests of cross-weld samples were performed at 625°C. This study compares the results of the mechanical tests at ambient temperature and the creep rupture tests, and discusses why P92 filler metals are preferred for such welds.

Large heat-to-heat variation of creep rupture strength in weldments of mod.9Cr-1Mo steels was observed in the creep rupture tests conducted for two different heats at 600°C and 650°C. One heat showed consistently lower time-to-rupture than the other for 130-60MPa at 600°C. Detailed microstructural investigations revealed that the number density of precipitates in the weaker heat was remarkably lower than that associated with the stronger heat through most of the creep region. Accordingly, heat-to-heat variation of creep rupture strength was attributed to the difference in the precipitate strengthening effects throughout creep. Equilibrium calculation predicted that the smaller phase fraction of M 23 C 6 and VN precipitates due to the lower content of chromium and lower ratio of nitrogen/aluminum in the weaker heat. However, given that long-term creep rupture strength at 650°C converged for the two heats, the microstructure including precipitates may settle into a similar level for subsequent longer hours even at 600°C.

This study examines the influence of carbon and austenite stabilizing elements (Ni, Mn, Co, Cu) on Laves phase precipitation, Fe 2 W formation, and creep rupture strength (CRS) in 9-12% Cr steels at 600-700°C. Nickel and manganese had minimal impact on Laves phase and coarse carbide formation up to 1% content. While cobalt increased Laves phase fraction at 650°C, it did not improve long-term CRS and even caused a rapid decrease in short-term CRS. Copper, on the other hand, promoted the precipitation of fine Cu-rich particles that acted as nucleation sites for Laves phase and M 23 C 6 carbide. This resulted in a different needle-like Laves phase morphology compared to the globular type observed in nickel and cobalt alloys, leading to improved CRS in the copper alloy. Increasing carbon content from 0.1% to 0.2% effectively suppressed Laves phase formation, as confirmed by Thermo-Calc calculations. Notably, for cobalt alloys with higher tungsten content, higher carbon content (0.09% to 0.19%) improved CRS at 650°C, whereas the opposite effect was observed in nickel and nickel-manganese alloys. Copper alloys maintained improving CRS trends even with increased carbon, leading to the overall best CRS performance among the tested alloys with 0.2% carbon.

The effects of Cr and W on the creep rupture life of 8.5-11.5Cr steels at 650°C were evaluated. Throughout this paper the specimen composition is expressed in mass percent. The creep rupture life of 8.5Cr steel is the longest in 8.5-11.5Cr steels at 650°C under the stress of 78MPa. The creep rupture life of 9Cr steel at 650°C was extended with increasing W content. The creep strength of the modified steel, 9Cr-4W-3Co-0.2V-NbBN steel, at 650°C did not decrease sharply up to 32000h. The 105h creep rupture temperature of this steel under the stress of 100MPa was estimated to be approximately 635°C using Larson-Miller parameter. M 23 C 6 type carbides and VX type carbonitrides were observed on the lath boundary of the modified steel. The stability of these precipitates in the modified steel is likely to suppress the degradation of the long term creep strength at 650°C.

A Japanese national project has been undertaken since Aug. 2008 with the objective of developing an advanced ultra-supercritical power plant (A-USC) with a steam temperature of 700°C. Fe-Ni and Ni-based alloys, namely HR6W, HR35, Alloy617, Alloy740, Alloy263 and Alloy141, were taken as candidate materials for piping and superheater/reheater tubes in an A-USC boiler. Weldments of these alloys were manufactured by GTAW, after which long term creep rupture tests were conducted at 700°C, 750°C and 800°C. Weldments of HR6W, HR35 and Alloy617 showed similar creep strength as compared with these base metals. Weldments of Alloy740 tended to fail in the HAZ, and it is considered that voids and cracks preferentially formed in the small precipitation zone along the grain boundary in the HAZ. The creep strength of Alloy263 in weldments exhibited the highest level among all the alloys, although HAZ failure occurred in the low stress test condition. A weld strength reduction factor will be needed to avoid HAZ failure in Alloy740 and Alloy263. Also, to prevent premature failure in weld metal, optimization of the chemical composition of weld filler materials will be required.

In recent years continuous and extensive research and development activities have been being done worldwide on 700°C A-USC (Advanced Ultra Super Critical) power plants to achieve higher efficiency and reduce the CO 2 emission. Increasing steam temperature and pressure of such A-USC boilers under consideration require the adoption of Ni based alloys. In the Japanese national project launched in 2008, Ni based alloy HR6W (45Ni-23Cr-7W-Ti, ASME Code Case 2684) is one of the candidate materials for boiler tube and pipe as well as Alloy617, Alloy263 and Alloy740H. The most important issues in A-USC boiler fabrication are the establishment of proper welding process for thick wall components of these alloys and verification of the long term reliability of their weldments. In our previous study, the weldability of HR6W was investigated and the welding process for Ni based thick wall pipe was established with the narrow gap HST (Hot wire Switching TIG) welding procedure originally developed by Babcock-Hitachi K.K. In this paper, creep rupture strengths of HR6W weldment were verified by the long term test up to 60,000 hours for tube and 40,000 hours for pipe. In Japanese national project, narrow gap HST welding process was also applied to the welding test for the other Ni based candidate pipe materials. Furthermore, as the practical A-USC boiler manufacturing trials, header mockup test was conducted and qualified for HR6W.

Recent years high strength 9Cr1MoNbV steel developed in USA has been major material in boiler high temperature components with the increase of steam parameters of coal fired thermal power plants. As the microstructure of this steel is tempered martensite, it is known that the softening occurs in HAZ of the weldment. In the creep rupture test of these welded joints the rupture strength is lower than that of the parent metal, and sometimes this reduction of strength is caused by TypelV cracking. To develop an effective method to improve the rupture strength of welded joint, advanced welding procedure and normalizing-tempering heat treatment after weld was proposed. 9Cr1MoNbV plates with thickness of 40-50mm were welded by 10mm width automatic narrow gap MAG welding procedure using specially modified welding material. After normalizing at 1,050°C and tempering at 780°C, material properties of the welded joints were examined. Microstructure of HAZ was improved as before weld, and rupture strength of the welded joints was equal to that of the parent metal. The long term rupture strength of the welded joints was confirmed in the test exceeded 30,000hours. This welding procedure has been applied to seam weld of hot reheat piping and headers in USC boilers successfully.

10CrMoWVNbN (X 12 CrMoWVNbN 10 1 1) steel trial forgings has been manufactured to clarify the effect of austenitizing temperature on the creep rupture strength and microstructure. From the results of creep rupture tests up to 30,000 hours, higher austenitizing temperature improves the rupture strength without large degradation of the rupture ductility. The microstructural investigations demonstrate that the prior austenite grain size and the precipitation behavior of fine M2X particles are presumed to contribute to the improvement of creep rupture strength.

Continuous and active works have been going to develop 700°C A-USC (Advanced Ultra Super Critical) power plants in Europe, United States and also Japanese national project has launched in 2008. In this new Japanese project Fe-Ni based alloy HR6W (45Ni-24Fe-23Cr-7W-Ti) is one of the candidate materials for boiler tube and pipe as well as Ni based alloys such as well-known Alloy617, Alloy263 and Alloy740. The most important issue in boiler fabrication is the welding process of these alloys and long-term reliability of their weldments. Authors investigated the weldability of HR6W thick-wall pipe. The integrity of the weldment was confirmed with metallurgical investigation, mechanical testing and long term creep rupture test. It is proved that the narrow gap HST welding procedure can meet the requirements for Ni based or Fe-Ni based alloys and provides excellent strength properties.

The long-term creep strength of creep strength-enhanced ferritic steels has been overestimated due to changes in the stress dependence of creep rupture life at lower stress levels. To address this, creep rupture strength has been reassessed using a region-splitting analysis method, leading to reductions in the allowable tensile stress of these steels as per Japan’s METI Thermal Power Standard Code in December 2005 and July 2007. This method evaluates creep rupture strength separately in high and low stress regimes, divided at 50% of the 0.2% offset yield stress, which corresponds approximately to the 0% offset yield stress in ASME Grade 122-type steels. In the high-stress regime, the minimum creep rate follows the stress dependence of flow stress in tensile tests, with the stress exponent (n) decreasing from 20 at 550°C to 10 at 700°C. In contrast, the low-stress regime exhibits an n value of 4 to 6 for tempered martensitic single-phase steels, while dual-phase steels containing delta ferrite show an even lower n value of 2 to 4. The significant stress dependence of creep rupture life and minimum creep rate in the high-stress regime is attributed to plastic deformation at stresses exceeding the proportional limit. Meanwhile, creep deformation in the low-stress regime is governed by diffusion-controlled mechanisms and dislocation climb as the rate-controlling process.

Conventional time-temperature-parameter (TTP) methods often overestimate long-term creep rupture life of creep strength enhanced high Cr ferritic steels. The cause of the overestimation is studied on the basis of creep rupture data analysis on Gr.91, 92 and 122 steels. There are four regions with different values of stress exponent n for creep rupture life commonly in stress-rupture data of the three ferritic steels. Activation energies Q for rupture life in the regions take at least three different values. The values of n and Q decrease in a longer-term region. The decrease in Q value is the cause of the overestimation of long-term rupture life predicted by the conventional TTP methods neglecting the change in Q value. Therefore, before applying a TTP method creep rupture data should be divided into several data sets so that Q value is unique in each divided data set. When this multi-region analysis is adopted, all the data points of the steels can be described accurately, and their long-term creep life can be evaluated correctly. Substantial heat-to-heat and grade-to-grade variation in their creep strength is suggested under recent service conditions of USC power boilers.

Creep strength of Grade 91 steels has been reviewed and allowable stress of the steels has been revised several times. Allowable stress regulated in ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code of the steels with thickness of 3 inches and above was reduced in 1993, based on the re-evaluation with long-term creep rupture data collected from around the world. After steam leakage from long seam weld of hot reheat pipe made from Grade 122 steel in 2004, creep rupture strength of the creep strength enhanced ferritic (CSEF) steels has been reviewed by means of region splitting method in consideration of 50% of 0.2% offset yield stress (half yield) at the temperature, in the committee sponsored by the Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry (METI) of Japanese Government. Allowable stresses in the Japanese technical standard of Grade 91 steels have been reduced in 2007 according to the above review. In 2010, additional long-term creep rupture data of the CSEF steels has been collected and the re-evaluation of creep rupture strength of the steels has been conducted by the committee supported by the Federation of Electric Power Companies of Japan, and reduction of allowable stress has been repeated in 2014. Regardless of the previous revision, additional reduction of the allowable stress of Grade 91 steels has been proposed by the review conducted in 2015 by the same committee as 2010. Further reduction of creep rupture strength of Grade 91 steels has been caused mainly by the additional creep rupture data of the low strength materials. A remaining of segregation of alloying elements has been revealed as one of the causes of lowered creep rupture strength. Improvement in creep strength may be expected by reducing segregation, since diffusional phenomena at the elevated temperatures is promoted by concentration gradient due to segregation which increases driving force of diffusion. It has been expected, consequently, that the creep strength and allowable stress of Grade 91 steels can be increased by proper process of fabrication to obtain a homogenized material free from undue segregation.

Developed 9Cr-3W-3Co-Nd-B heat-resistant steel SAVE12AD (Recently designated as ASME Grade 93) pipes and tubes have higher creep strength in both base metal and welded joints than conventional high Cr ferritic steels such as ASME Grades 91, 92 and 122. The welded joints of SAVE12AD tubes with commercial filler wire for W62-10CMWV-Co (Gr. 92) or Ni base filler wire ERNiCr-3 (Alloy82) also have much better creep rupture strength than those of conventional steels because of suppression of refining in the Heat-Affected-Zone (HAZ). However, the creep rupture strength of weld metal of W62-10CMWV-Co was marginal. Additionally, the hot cracking susceptibility of weld metal using Ni base filler wire ERNiCr-3 was occasionally below the required level. Similar welding consumable for SAVE12AD has been developed to solve these problems. Optimization of nickel, neodymium and boron contents on similar welding consumable enables to obtain both the good long-term creep rupture strength and low enough hot cracking susceptibility of weld metal. Consequently, SAVE12AD welded joint is expected to be applied of piping and tubing above 600°C in USC power plants because of its good properties with similar welding consumable.

Microstructural change of 10 % Cr steel trial forgings subjected to different heat treatment conditions which aim to improve the creep rupture strength and microstructural stability during creep was investigated. Creep rupture strength of the forging subjected to the quality heat treatment with the austenitizing temperature of 1090° C is higher than that of the forging solution treated at 1050°C, however, the difference of creep rupture strength is reduced in the long-term region around 40,000 h. Decrease in creep rupture ductility of the forging until 43,300 h is not observed. Progress of the martensite lath recovery in the forging solution-treated at 1090°C is slower than that in the forging austenitized at 1050°C. Higher temperature solution treatment suppresses the recovery of lath structures. Formations of Z-phase are found in the specimens creep-ruptured at 37,300 h in the forging solution-treated at 1050°C and at 43,400 h in the forging austenitized at 1090°C. Z-phase precipitation behavior in this steel is delayed in comparison with the boiler materials, regardless of austenitizing temperature.