The construction of highly efficient, coal-burning Ultra Supercritical (USC) boiler systems to operate with steam temperatures up to 760°C (1400°F) and with steam pressures up to 35 MPa (5000 psi) will require the use of advanced high temperature, high strength materials. As part of a 5-year project to develop boiler materials for advanced USC power plants, principally funded by the Department of Energy (U.S. DOE No. DE-FG26-01NT41175) and the Ohio Coal Development Office (OCDO No. D-00-20), six alloys have been selected for development and implementation in USC boiler systems. The selected alloys are Haynes 230 (produced by Haynes International), Inconel 740 (produced by Special Metals Corp.), CCA 617 (produced by Krupp VDM GMBH), HR6W, Super 304H, and SAVE 12 (all three produced by Sumitomo Metal Industries). In this project, one of the goals has been to establish boiler fabrication guidelines for the use of these alloys. The principal objectives have been 1) to understand the behavior of these materials when subjected to conventional boiler fabrication processes, 2) to determine the thermomechanical treatments or other actions necessary to restore material properties which might degrade due to fabrication operations, and 3) to investigate prototypical manufacturing operations for producing both thick wall components (such as headers) and thin wall components (such as superheaters) from the USC alloys. This paper discusses some of the characteristics of these alloys, describes the technical approach used to assess their fabricability, and presents some of the results that have thus far been generated in this task effort.

To enhance long-term creep strength at 650°C, stabilization of the lath martensitic microstructure near prior austenite grain boundaries has been investigated for a 9Cr-3W-3Co-0.2V-0.05Nb steel. This was achieved by adding boron to stabilize M 23 C 6 carbides and dispersing fine MX nitrides. Creep tests were conducted at 650°C for up to approximately 3 × 10 4 hours. Adding a large amount of boron exceeding 0.01%, combined with minimized nitrogen, effectively stabilized the martensitic microstructure and improved long-term creep strength. The amount of available boron, free from boron nitrides and tungsten borides, is crucial for enhancing long-term creep strength. Reducing the carbon concentration below 0.02% led to a dispersion of nano-sized MX nitride particles along boundaries and in the matrix, resulting in excellent creep strength at 650°C. A critical issue for the 9Cr steel strengthened by MX nitrides is the formation of Z-phase, which degrades long-term creep strength. Excess nitrogen additions of 0.07 and 0.1% promoted Z-phase formation during creep. The formation of a protective Cr-rich oxide scale was achieved through a combination of Si addition and pre-oxidation treatment in argon, significantly improving the oxidation resistance in steam at 650°C.

Components in ultrasupercritical steam (USC) boilers will operate under significantly more severe conditions than current subcritical and supercritical steam boilers. Existing construction rules for power boilers lack design guidance or criteria to assess the adequacy of designs for USC conditions. A Department of Energy (DOE) project addresses this by evaluating advanced materials under conditions similar to potential USC service environments. The project focuses on six tubing alloys and four thick-section alloys. Testing is underway for pressurized tube bends, notched thick-section bars, fatigue, and thermal shock on thick-section tubing made of materials like CCA617, Alloy 230, and Alloy 740. Further testing is planned for pressurized tubes, dissimilar metal welds, and thick-section weldments. This paper summarizes the status of this initial testing program aimed at enabling USC boiler material qualification.

In recent years continuous and extensive research and development activities have been being done worldwide on 700°C A-USC (Advanced Ultra Super Critical) power plants to achieve higher efficiency and reduce the CO 2 emission. Increasing steam temperature and pressure of such A-USC boilers under consideration require the adoption of Ni based alloys. In the Japanese national project launched in 2008, Ni based alloy HR6W (45Ni-23Cr-7W-Ti, ASME Code Case 2684) is one of the candidate materials for boiler tube and pipe as well as Alloy617, Alloy263 and Alloy740H. The most important issues in A-USC boiler fabrication are the establishment of proper welding process for thick wall components of these alloys and verification of the long term reliability of their weldments. In our previous study, the weldability of HR6W was investigated and the welding process for Ni based thick wall pipe was established with the narrow gap HST (Hot wire Switching TIG) welding procedure originally developed by Babcock-Hitachi K.K. In this paper, creep rupture strengths of HR6W weldment were verified by the long term test up to 60,000 hours for tube and 40,000 hours for pipe. In Japanese national project, narrow gap HST welding process was also applied to the welding test for the other Ni based candidate pipe materials. Furthermore, as the practical A-USC boiler manufacturing trials, header mockup test was conducted and qualified for HR6W.

Since 2008, Japanese boiler, turbine and valve manufacturers, research institutes and utility companies have been working together to develop 700V A·USC technology, with support from the Japanese government. The key areas of discussion are technology development of high temperature materials such as nickel-based alloys and advanced 9Cr steels, and their application to actual power plants. At the EPRI conference in 2013, our report mainly focused on the development of fundamental material and manufacturing technology during the first five years of the project, and the preparation status of the boiler component test and turbine rotor test for the latter four years of the project. The boiler component test, using a commercially-operating boiler, began in May 2015 and is scheduled to be finished by the end of 2016. The turbine rotor test at 700°C with actual speed will be carried out from September 2016 to March 2017. At this year’s conference, we will: l) briefly summarize the development of fundamental material and manufacturing technology and 2) provide an update on the progress of the boiler component test and the turbine rotor test.

CO 2 emission reduction from coal power plants is still a serious issue to mitigate the impact of global warming and resulting climate change, though renewables are growing today. As one of the solutions, we developed A-USC (Advanced Ultra Super Critical steam condition) technology to raise the thermal efficiency of coal power plants by using high steam temperatures of up to 700℃ between 2008 and 2017 with the support of METI (Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry) and NEDO (New Energy and Industrial Technology Development Organization). The temperature is 100℃ higher than that of the current USC technology. Materials and manufacturing technology for boilers, turbines and valves were developed. Boiler components, such as super heaters, a thick wall pipe, valves, and a turbine casing were successfully tested in a 700℃-boiler component test facility. Turbine rotors were tested successfully, as well, in a turbine rotating test facility under 700℃ and at actual speed. The tested components were removed from the facilities and inspected. In 2017, following the component tests, we started a new project to develop the maintenance technology of the A-USC power plants with the support of NEDO. A pressurized thick wall pipe is being tested in a 700℃ furnace to check the material degradation of an actual sized component.

Addressing the growing concern of supercritical and ultra-supercritical boilers as potential safety hazards in power plants, a new Boiler Risk Management and Life Prediction System (BRMLPS) has been developed. This system leverages risk-based inspection and assessment techniques alongside life prediction and management methods. The BRMLPS focuses on evaluating and ranking the risk associated with critical boiler components, such as heating surfaces, headers, and drums. This risk assessment allows for the development of targeted and efficient inspection plans and repair strategies, ultimately aiming to minimize accident rates, reduce potential losses, and optimize safety investments. By implementing this system, power plants can achieve maintenance optimization, balancing safety and economic considerations for their specialized equipment.

We have reported on the effort being done to develop the A-USC technology in Japan, which features the 700 deg-C steam condition, since the 2007 EPRI conference. Our 9 year project began in 2008. There have been some major changes in the electricity power market in the world recently. At first, the earthquake changed the power system violently in Japan. Almost all nuclear power plants have been shut down and natural gas, oil and coal power plants are working fully to satisfy the market's demands. In the USA, the so called ‘Shale gas revolution’ is going on. In Europe, they are working toward the target of reducing CO 2 emissions by the significant use of renewables with the backup of the fossil fuel power systems and enhancing power grids. A very rapid increase in power generation by coal is being observed in some countries. Despite some major changes in the electric sector in the world and the CO 2 problem, the global need for coal power generation is still high. We can reconfirm that the improvement of the thermal efficiency of coal power plants should be the most fundamental and important measure for the issues we are confronting today, and that continuous effort should be put towards it. Based on the study we showed at the 2007 conference, we developed 700 deg-C class technology mainly focusing on the material and manufacturing technology development and verification tests for key components such as boilers, turbines and valves. Fundamental technology developments have been done during the first half of the project term. Long term material tests such as creep rupture of base materials and welds will be conducted for 100,000hrs continuing after the end of the project with the joint effort of each participating company. Today, we are preparing the plan for the second half of the project, which is made up of boiler components test and the turbine rotating tests. Some boiler superheater panels, large diameter pipes and valves will be tested in a commercially operating boiler from 2015 to 2017. The turbine rotor materials which have the same diameter as commercial rotors will be tested at 700 deg-C and at actual speed.

Tempered martensitic 9-12%Cr steels bearing tungsten, such as P92 and P122 showing higher creep rupture strength than the conventional steel P91, have been developed for thick section components in ultra-supercritical (USC) boilers. However, their creep strength is not sufficient for applying at the steam condition of 650°C/35MPa or above, which is a recent target condition in order to increase plant efficiency. The research and development project in NIMS on advanced high-Cr steels which can be applied at the steam condition of 650°C/35MPa as boiler components with large diameter and thick section has been carried out since 1997. In this project, it has been revealed that the addition of boron more than 0.01 mass% to the 0.08C-9Cr- 3W-3Co-V,Nb-<0.00ЗN steel remarkably improves creep strength. The boron enriched in M 23 C 6 carbides near prior-austenite grain boundaries suppresses coarsening of these carbides during creep deformation, leading to excellent microstructural stability and creep strength. Further improvement of creep strength is achieved by the addition of appropriate amount of nitrogen which enhances precipitation of fine MX. Excess addition of nitrogen to the high-B containing steel reduces creep rupture lives and ductility. The highest creep strength is obtained in the 0.08C-9Cr-3W-3Co-0.2V-0.05Nb-0.0139B-0.0079N (mass%) steel, resulting in excellent creep strength in comparison with that of P92 and P122. This steel shows good creep ductility even in the long term. It is, therefore, concluded that this high-B bearing 9Cr-3W-3Co-V,Nb steel with the addition of nitrogen in the order of 0.008 mass% is the promising candidate which shows superior creep strength without impairing creep ductility for thick section components in the 650°C-USC plant.

Enhancement of the steam conditions is one of the most effective measures to achieve the goal of higher thermal efficiency. 700°C class A-USC (Advanced Ultra Super Critical Steam Conditions) power plant is one of the remarkable technologies to achieve the goal and reduce CO 2 emissions from fossil fuel power plants. Toshiba has been working on the A-USC development project with subsidy from METI (Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry) and NEDO (New Energy and Industrial Technology Development Organization). In this project, A-USC power plants with steam parameters of 35MPa 700/720/720°C were considered. To date, various materials have been developed and tested to verify their characteristics for use in A-USC power plants. And some of these materials are being investigated as to their suitability for use in long term. Together with members of the project, we carried out the boiler component test using a commercially-operating boiler. We manufactured a small-scale turbine casing made of nickel-based alloy, and supplied it for the test. In addition, we manufactured a turbine rotor for turbine rotation tests, and carried out the test at 700°C and rotating speed of 3,600rpm conditions. In this paper, we show the results of the A-USC steam turbine development obtained by the project.

Inconel alloy 740H was specifically developed for use in coal-fired AUSC boilers. This alloy displays a unique combination of steam and coal-ash corrosion resistance, microstructure stability, creep strength and heavy section weldability. During the past two years Special Metals and Wyman-Gordon have undertaken an intense effort to demonstrate their capability to manufacture full-size boiler components, characterize their properties and simulate field assembly welds. This work was performed according to the requirements of ASME Boiler Code Case 2702 that was recently issued. This paper covers manufacturing of tube and pipe products and property characterization including recent data on the effect of long time exposure on impact toughness of base and weld metal. New data will also be reported on coal ash corrosion of base metal and weld metal. An overview of welding studies focused on integrity of circumferential pipe joints and a discussion of remaining technical issues will be presented.

In order to reduce CO 2 emissions and improve power generation efficiency, a development project involving an advanced USC (A-USC) plant has been carried out in Japan since 2008. Nibased alloys are candidate materials for boiler components with high temperature steam conditions, which are much stronger than conventional heat resistant steel. However, Ni-based alloys have never been applied with respect to the high pressure parts and thick walled components of USC coal-fired power plants. In this study, therefore, fabrication and characteristic properties, such as weldability, the weld joint and bent part properties, and weld cracking susceptibilities of Ni-based alloys such as HR6W, HR35 and two types of Alloy617 (High B and Low B) pipes were evaluated. Additionally, two types of HR6W header mock-ups and a HR6W tube element mock-up were fabricated. With the exception of Alloy617 (High B), the fabrication trials of Ni-based alloy pipes were conducted successfully, and the long-term creep strength of weldments and bends of Ni-based alloy pipes were found to be nearly equivalent to those of base metal. In the case of Alloy617 (High B), hot cracking was observed.

Current demands of the power generation market require components with improved materials properties. The focus is not only on the higher operation temperatures and pressures but also more frequent cycling to accommodate the energy produced from renewable sources. Following the successful developments of steels within the COST 501, 522 and 536 programmes, further advances are being researched. As nickel superalloys remain an expensive option for coal power plants, there is a significant drive for improvements of 9-12% Cr steels to meet new demands. The most promising of the potential candidates identified for 650°C application is MarBN steel (9Cr-3Co-3W-V-Nb). This paper reviews the current state of European developments on MarBN steel. Work on this alloy has been carried out for the last 5 years. Initial projects focused on development of the cast components. UK IMPACT and following INMAP projects successfully demonstrated manufacturing capabilities of large casting components. More recent collaborations aim to develop full-size boiler components and large rotor forgings as well as further examine the properties in the operating conditions (i.e. corrosion and oxidation resistance, creep-fatigue behaviour). Additionally significant focus is placed on modelling the behaviour of MarBN components, in terms of both microstructural changes and the resulting properties.

In this study, a possibility of application of advanced 9%Cr steel containing 130 ppm boron for boiler components utilized at around 650 °C to higher temperature steam turbine rotor materials has been investigated by means of reduction in silicon promoting macro-segregation in the case of large size ingots, using laboratory heats. Tempered martensitic microstructure without proeutectoid ferrite in all steels studied is obtained even at the center position of a turbine rotor having a barrel diameter of 1.2 m despite lower amounts of nitrogen and silicon. The strength at room temperature is almost the same level of practical high Cr steels such as X13CrMoCoVNbNB 9-2-1 for ultrasuper critical steam turbine rotors. The toughness is sufficient for high temperature rotors in comparison with CrMoV steels utilized as sub-critical high pressure steam turbine components. The creep rupture strength of the steels is higher than that of the conventional 9-12Cr steels used at about 630 °C. The creep rupture strength of 9%Cr steel containing 130 ppm B, 95 ppm N, 0.07 % Si and 0.05 % Mn is the highest in the steels examined, and it is therefore a candidate steel for high temperature turbine rotors utilized at more than 630 °C. Co-precipitation of M 23 C 6 carbides and Laves phase is observed around the prior austenite grain boundaries after the heat treatments and the restraint of the carbide growth is also observed during creep exposure. An improvement in creep strength of the steels is presumed to have the relevance to the stabilization of the martensitic lath microstructure in the vicinity of those boundaries by such precipitates.

Inconel alloy 740/740H (ASME Code Case 2702) is an age-hardenable nickel-based alloy designed for advanced ultrasupercritical (A-USC) steam boiler components (superheaters, reheaters, piping, etc.). In this work, creep testing, beyond 40,000 hours was conducted a series of alloy 740 heats of varying product form, chemistry, and grain size. Long-term creep-rupture strength was found to be weakly dependent on grain size. Analysis of the time-to-rupture data was conducted to ensure long-term strength projections and development of ASME stress allowables. Testing was also conducted on welded joints in alloy 740 with different filler metal and heat-treatment combinations. This analysis shows the current weld strength reduction factor of 30% (Weld Strength Factor of 0.70) mandated by ASME Code Case 2702 is appropriate for 740 filler metal but other options exist to improve strength. Based on these results, it was found that alloy 740 has the highest strength and temperature capability of all the potential A-USC alloys available today.

The recently developed 12%Cr steel VM12-SHC is characterized by very good creep properties at temperatures up to 620°C. This new material development exhibits an excellent oxidation resistance in steam atmospheres at the typical application temperature but also at temperatures up to 650°C. In comparison to the existing 9% Cr grades T/P91 and T/P92, VM12-SHC steel opens due to its excellent oxidation behavior, new possibilities for its application as a heat exchanger boiler component. It was found that outside its application temperature range VM12-SHC also shows, as all 9-12%Cr steels, the appearance of the so called Z-phase. This effect was investigated to understand its influence on creep properties of this class of ferritic/martensitic steels aiming at controlling the microstructure stabilities for future grade developments. Creep testing has been carried out in the temperature range between 525°C and 700°C. Selected crept specimens have been investigated using light optical microscopy, SEM with EDX and TEM. In this study, the oxidation behavior of a number of typical martensitic 9-12%Cr steels was compared with the newly developed 12% Cr steel VM12-SHC. The compositions and morphologies of oxide scales formed after 5000 h exposure steels in simulated steam environments as function of temperature were characterized by light optical metallography and scanning electron microscopy (SEM) with energy dispersive X-ray analysis (EDX).

Tenaris’ High Oxidation Resistance (THOR) 115, or T115, is a creep strength-enhanced ferritic (CSEF) steel introduced in the past decade. It is widely used in constructing high-efficiency power plants and heat recovery steam generators (HRSGs) due to its superior steam oxidation resistance and long-term microstructural stability, making it a viable alternative to stainless steels at elevated steam temperatures. The creep damage tolerance of T115 has been recently validated under ASME BPVC CC 3048 guidelines, which address safety concerns related to creep damage in boiler components. Testing confirmed T115’s consistent creep damage-tolerant behavior, with cross-weld creep behavior reassessed through extensive metallographic examination of specimens from a 1.5-inch thick pipe girth weld, providing insights into creep damage distribution and hardness, and its relative performance compared to Grade 91 CSEF steel.

Development of the advanced USC (A-USC) boiler technology has been promoted in recent years, which targets 700°C steam condition. HR6W (Ni-23Cr-7W-Ti-Nb-25Fe) and HR35 (Ni-30Cr-6W-Ti-15Fe) have been developed for A-USC boiler tubes and pipes. The former alloy is mainly strengthened by Fe 2 W type Laves phase. The latter one employs precipitation strengthening of α-Cr phase in addition to Laves phase. Characteristic alloy design of both alloys, which does not use precipitation strengthening of γ′ phase (Ni 3 Al), leads to superior ductility and resistance to stress-relaxation cracking. Stability of creep strength and microstructure has been confirmed by long-term creep rupture tests. The 100,000h average creep rupture strength of HR6W is 85MPa at 700C. That of HR35 is 126MPa at 700°C which is comparable with conventional Alloy617. Tubes of both alloys have been evaluated by the component test in Japanese national A-USC project with γ′ hardened Alloy617 and Alloy263. Detailed creep strength, deformation behavior and microstructural evolution of these alloys are described from the viewpoint of the difference in strengthening mechanisms. Capability of these alloys for A-USC boiler materials has been demonstrated by the component test in the commercial coal fired boiler as the part of the A-USC project.

For raising thermal efficiency and decreasing CO 2 emission, China had constructed the first 600°C ultra-supercritical(USC) fossil power plant in 2006. Now more than a hundred 600°C, 1000MW USC electric power units have been put in service. Recently, China has also developed 620°C USC power units and some of them have been put in service already. Meanwhile, more than fifty 620°C USC boilers will be produced by various China boiler companies. The austenitic steels TP347H, Super304H and HR3C are routinely used for 600°C USC boilers. Among these steels, a big amount of Super304H has been used for boiler superheater/reheater components application. However, Super304H is characterized by good stress-rupture strength but poor corrosion/oxidation resistance. On the other side, HR3C is characterized by very good corrosion/oxidation resistance but lower stress-rupture strength than Super304H. Now, the China 620°C USC project needs a new austenitic heat resisting steel with high stress-rupture strength and good corrosion/oxidation resistance to fulfill the superheater/reheater tube components application requirement. A new austenitic heat resisting steel SP2215 is based on 22Cr-15Ni with certain amount of Cu and also Nb and N for multiphase precipitation (MX, Cu-rich phase, NbCrN) strengthening in Fe-Cr-Ni austenitic matrix and M 23 C 6 carbide precipitation at grain boundaries. This SP2215 new austenitic steel is characterized by high stress-rupture strength (650°C, 105h>130MPa) and good corrosion/oxidation resistance. SP2215 austenitic steel has been commercially produced in tube product form. This SP2215 new austenitic heat-resisting steel is recommended to be used as superheater/reheater components for 620°C USC boiler application.

This paper presents an overview of China’s electric power development and the National 700°C Ultra-Supercritical (USC) Coal-Fired Power Generation Technology Innovation Consortium. Besides, the R&D plan and latest progress of China 700°C USC coal-fired power generation technology is also introduced in this paper.