Search Results for abrasion resistance

Competitive pressures throughout the power generation market are forcing individual power plants to extend time between scheduled outages, and absolutely avoid costly forced outages. Coal fired power plant owners expect their engineering and maintenance teams to identify, predict and solve potential outage causing equipment failures and use the newest advanced technologies to resolve and evade these situations. In coal fired power plants, erosion not only leads to eventual failure, but during the life cycle of a component, affects the performance and efficiency due to the loss of engineered geometry. “Wear” is used very generally to describe a component wearing out; however, there are numerous “modes of wear.” Abrasion, erosion, and corrosion are a few of the instigators of critical component wear, loss of geometry, and eventual failure in coal fired plants. Identification of the wear derivation is critical to selecting the proper material to avoid costly down-times and extend outage to outage goals. This paper will focus on the proper selection of erosion resistant materials in the severe environment of a coal fired power plant by qualifying lab results with actual field experiences.

Inconel Filler Metal 72 (FM 72) and Incoclad 671/800H co-extruded tubing have been successfully used for over 20 years to protect boiler tubing from high-temperature degradation. A newer alloy, FM 72M, offers superior weldability and the lowest corrosion rate in simulated low NOx environments. Both FM 72 and 72M show promise in addressing challenges like circumferential cracking and corrosion fatigue in waterwall tubing overlays. Additionally, 72M’s superior wear resistance makes it ideal for replacing erosion shields in superheater and reheater tubing. Beyond improved protection, these alloys exhibit increased hardness and thermal conductivity over time, leading to reduced temperature difference across the tube wall and consequently, enhanced boiler efficiency and lower maintenance costs. This paper discusses the historical selection of optimal alloys for waterwall and upper boiler tubing overlays, analyzes past failure mechanisms, and highlights the key properties of successful choices like FM 72 and 72M.

Steam oxidation of a novel austenitic steel, of which composition is Fe-20Cr-30Ni-2Nb (at.%), has been conducted at 973 K to evaluate steam oxidation resistance based on detail analyses of scale morphology and scale growth. Two types of scale morphologies were observed in the solution treated sample, depending on the grain of the steel. Although thin duplex scale with the Cr-rich layer was formed in the early stage, most of the surface was covered with thick duplex scale which consists of magnetite as the outer scale and the mixture of Fe-Cr spinel and metallic Ni as the inner scale. On the other hand, surface morphology of the oxide scale was independent of grain of the steel and thick duplex scale as seen on the solution treated sample was formed on the pre-aged sample. Steam oxidation resistance of the steel is almost the same as that of commercial austenitic steels and it can be improved by the surface treatment such as shot peening. Based on the results, this steel has both enough creep rupture strength and good steam oxidation resistance for A-USC power plants.

To save fossil fuel resources and to reduce CO 2 emissions, considerable effort has been directed toward researching and developing heat-resistant materials that can help in improving the energy efficiency of thermal power plants by increasing their operational temperature and pressure conditions. Instead of conventional 9-12Cr ferritic heat-resistant steels with a tempered martensitic microstructure, we developed “Precipitation Strengthened 15Cr Ferritic Steel” based on a new material design concept: a solid-solution treated ferrite matrix strengthened by precipitates. Creep tests for 15Cr-1Mo-6W-3Co-V-Nb steels with ferrite matrix strengthened by a mainly Laves phase (Fe 2 W) showed that the creep strengths of 15Cr ferritic steel at temperatures ranging from 923 K to 1023 K were twice as high as those of conventional 9Cr ferric heat-resistant steel. 15Cr steels have higher steam oxidation resistance than that of conventional steel in the same temperature range as the creep tests. Thus, the new material design concept of heat-resistant steel pro- vides improved creep strength and steam oxidation resistance. We are attempting to determine the optimum compositions, especially that of carbon, in order to improve the high-temperature creep strength.

Hardfacing alloys are commonly used for wear- and galling-resistant surfaces for mechanical parts under high loads, such as valve seats. Cobalt-based Stellite, as well as, stainless-steel-based Norem02 and Tristelle 5183 alloys show similar microstructural features that correlate with good galling resistance. These microstructures contain hard carbides surrounded by a metastable austenite (fcc) phase that transform displacively to martensite (hcp or bcc or bct) under deformation. As a result, the transformed wear surface forms a hard layer that resists transition to a galling wear mechanism. However, at elevated temperature (350°C), the stainless steel hardfacing alloys do not show acceptable galling behavior, unlike Stellite. This effect is consistent with the loss of fcc to bcc/bct phase transformation and the increase in depth of the heavily deformed surface layer. Retention of high hardness and low depth of plastic strain in the surface tribolayer is critical for retaining galling resistance at high temperature.

Reducing emissions and increasing economic competitiveness require more efficient steam power plants that utilize fossil fuels. One of the major challenges in designing these plants is the availability of materials that can stand the supercritical and ultra-supercritical steam conditions at a competitive cost. There are several programs around the world developing new ferritic and austenitic steels for superheater and reheater tubes exposed to the advanced steam conditions. The new steels must possess properties better than current steels in terms of creep strength, steamside oxidation resistance, fireside corrosion resistance, and thermal fatigue resistance. This paper introduces a series of experimental 9%Cr steels containing Cu, Co, and Ti. Stability of the phases in the new steels is discussed and compared to the phases in the commercially available materials. The steels were tested under both the dry and moist conditions at 650°C for their cyclical oxidation resistance. Results of oxidation tests are presented. Under the moist conditions, the experimental steels exhibited significantly less mass gain compared to the commercial P91 steel. Microstructural characterization of the scale revealed different oxide compositions.

A new ferritic steel branded as Thor 115 has been developed to enhance high-temperature resistance. The steel design combines an improved oxidation resistance with long-term microstructural stability. The new alloy was extensively tested to assess the high-temperature time- dependent mechanical behavior (creep). The main strengthening mechanism is precipitation hardening by finely dispersed carbide (M 23 C 6 ) and nitride phases (MX). Information on the evolution of secondary phases and time-temperature-precipitation behavior of the alloy, essential to ensure long-term stability, was obtained by scanning transmission electron microscopy with energy dispersive spectroscopy, and by X-ray powder diffraction on specimens aged up to 50,000 hours. The material behavior was also tested in service conditions, to validate the laboratory results: Thor 115 tubing was installed in a HRSG power plant, directly exposed to turbine flue gasses. Tubing samples were progressively extracted, analyzed and compared with laboratory specimens in similar condition. This research shows the performance of Thor 115 regarding steam oxidation and microstructure evolution up to 25,000 exposure hours in the field. So far, no oxide microstructure difference is found between the laboratory and on field tubing: in both cases, the oxide structure is magnetite/hematite and Cr-spinel layers and the oxide thickness values lay within the same scatter band. The evolution of precipitates in the new alloy confirms the retention of the strengthening by secondary phases, even after long-term exposure at high temperature. The deleterious conversion of nitrides into Z phase is shown to be in line with, or even slower than that of the comparable ASME grade 91 steel.

High Cr ferritic steels have been developed for the large components of fossil power plants due to their excellent creep resistance, low thermal expansion, and good oxidation resistance. Development works to improve the operating temperature of these steels mainly focused on the high mechanical properties such as solid solution strengthening and precipitation hardening. However, the knowledge of the correlation between Laves phase precipitation and oxidation behavior has not clarified yet on 9Cr ferritic steels. This research will be focused on the effect of precipitation of Laves phase on steam oxidation behavior of Fe-9Cr alloy at 923 K. Niobium was chosen as the third element to the Fe- 9Cr binary system. Steam oxidation test of Fe-9Cr (mass%) alloy and Fe-9Cr-2Nb (mass%) alloy were carried out at 923 K in Ar-15%H 2 O mixture for up to 172.8 ks. X-ray diffraction confirms the oxide mainly consist of wüstite on the Fe-9Cr in the initial stage while on Nb added samples magnetite was dominated. The results show that the Fe-9Cr- 2Nb alloy has a slower oxidation rate than the Fe-9Cr alloy after oxidized for 172.8 ks

Advanced martensitic 9% chromium steels have been identified as the most favored group of materials for high temperature applications in thermal power plants. To extend the temperature range of martensitic steels up to 650°C large effort was put on the development of new alloy concepts. The so-called MARBN concept (Martensitic steel with defined Boron/Nitrogen relation) provides increased creep rupture strength due to higher solid solution strengthening and improved microstructural stability. The major improvement is the reduction of type IV cracking in welded joints, which shifts the focus to the creep rupture strength of the weld metal. This paper illustrates the process experience of the steel foundry for production of heavy cast components in latest state of the art 9-12%Cr-MoCoVNbNB-alloyed cast steel grades and the newest state of development and prototype components in MARBN cast steel grades. Metallurgy, solidification, heat treatment and welding are main items to be considered for development of new, complex steel grades for foundry processing with the help of empiric processing in test programs and thermo-physical simulation. As welding is an essential processing step in the production of heavy steel cast components a good out-of-position weldability is required. Moreover a stress-relieve heat-treatment takes place subsequently after welding for several hours. This contribution also deals with the development of matching welding consumables for the production of heavy cast components and discusses the challenges of defining appropriate welding and heat treatment parameters to meet the requirements of sufficient strength and toughness at ambient temperature. Additionally, first results of creep rupture tests are presented.

Steam turbine is one of the critical equipments in coal-fired power plants, steel P91 is a common material of its control valves. CoCr-based hardfacing on valve seats can resist long time exposure to water vapor with high temperature, thermal fatigue and solid particles erosion under high pressure. However, these hardfacing can crack and disbond during operation, which generates high risks for turbine systems and power plants. This article discussed the failure reasons of CoCr-based hardfacing, and introduced a method and practical experience of on-site repairing steam turbine valve seats with laser cladding NiCr coating.

Creep brittle behaviour in tempered martensitic, creep strength enhanced ferritic (CSEF) steels is linked to the formation of micro voids. Details of the number of voids formed, and the tendency for reductions in creep strain to fracture are different for the different CSEF steels. However, it appears that the susceptibility for void nucleation is related to the presence of trace elements and hard non-metallic inclusions in the base steel. A key factor in determining whether the inclusions present will nucleate voids is the particle size. Thus, only inclusions of a sufficient size (the critical inclusion size is directly linked to the creep stress) will act directly as nucleation sites. This paper compares results from traditional uniaxial laboratory creep testing with data obtained under multiaxial conditions. The need to understand and quantify how metallurgical and structural factors interact to influence creep damage and cracking is discussed and the significant benefits available through the use of high quality steel making and fabrication procedures are highlighted. Details of component behaviour are considered as part of well-engineered, Damage Tolerant, design methods.

The use of high-nickel superalloys has greatly increased among many industries. This is especially the case for advanced coal-fired boilers, where the latest high temperature designs will require materials capable of withstanding much higher operating temperatures and pressures than current designs. Inconel alloy 740H (UNS N07740) is a new nickel- based alloy that serves as a candidate for steam header pipe and super-heater tubing in coal-fired boilers. Alloy 740H has been shown to be capable of withstanding the extreme operating conditions of an advanced ultra-super-critical (AUSC) boiler, which is the latest boiler design, currently under development. As with all high nickel alloys, welding of alloy 740H can be very challenging, even to an experienced welder. Weldability challenges are compounded when considering that the alloy may be used in steam headers, where critical, thick-section and stub-to-header weld joints are present. This paper is intended to describe the proper procedures developed over years of study that will allow for ASME code quality welds in alloy 740H with matching composition filler metals.

In this work, the effects of phosphorus addition on the creep properties and microstructural changes of wrought γ’-strengthened Ni-based superalloys (Haynes 282) were investigated, focusing on the effects of carbides precipitation. In an alloy with a phosphorus content of 8 ppm, precipitation of M 23 C 6 carbides was observed in both grain boundaries and the grain interior prior to the creep tests. Grain boundary coverage by carbide increased with phosphorus content up to approximately 30 ppm. On the other hand, the amount of M 23 C 6 in the grain interior decreased with phosphorus content. The results of the creep tests revealed the relationship between the time to rupture and the grain boundary coverage by carbides. The microstructure of the crept specimens showed the existence of misorientation at the vicinity of grain boundaries without carbides, as demonstrated via electron backscattered diffraction (EBSD) analysis. These results suggest that the observed improvement in the time to rupture is due to a grain-boundary precipitation strengthening mechanism caused by grain boundary carbides and that phosphorus content affects the precipitation behavior of M 23 C 6 carbides in the grain interior and grain boundaries. These behaviors were different between alloys with the single addition of phosphorus and alloys with the multiple addition of phosphorus and niobium.

Materials are the key to develop advanced ultra-supercritical (A-USC) steam generators. Operating at temperature up to 760°C and sustained pressure up to 4500 psi. Pressure vessel and piping materials may fail due to creep, oxidation, and erosion. Valves are particularly subjected to loss of function and leakage due to impermeant of the sealing surfaces. New materials, less susceptible to the above damage modes are needed for A-USC technology. Two Ni-based superalloys have been identified as prime candidates for valves based materials. Hardfacing is applied to sealing surfaces to protect them from wear and to reduce friction. Stellite 6 (Cobalt-based alloy) is the benchmark hardfacing owing to its anti-galling properties. However, the latest results tend to indicate that it is not suitable for high pressure application above 700°C. An alternative hardfacing will be required for A-USC. New Ni- and Co- based alloys are being developed for applications where extreme wear is combined with high temperatures and corrosive media. Their chemistry accounts for the excellent dry-running properties of these alloys and makes them very suitable for use in adhesive (metal-to- metal) wear. These new alloys have better wear, erosion, and corrosion resistance than Stellite 6 in the temperature range 800°C ~ 1000°C. As such, they have the potential to operate in A-USC. Velan recently developed an instrumented high temperature tribometer in collaboration with Polytechnique Montreal to characterize new alloys including static and dynamic coefficients of friction up to 800°C. We present herein the methodology that has been devolved to explore the effects of elevated temperature on the tribological behavior of those advanced material systems, with the goal of capturing the basis for the specification, design, fabrication, operation, and maintenance of valves for A-USC steam power plants.

18Cr-9Ni-3Cu-Nb-N steel is widely used for heat exchanger tubes such as super-heaters and reheaters of ultra-super critical power generation boilers. In this study, long-term creep rupture tests were carried out on 18Cr-9Ni-3Cu-Nb-N seamless steel tubes of 7 heat materials, and the specimens of 2 heat materials with different creep rupture strengths were observed by ultra-low voltage scanning electron microscope after creep rupture tests. The results of the investigation of the creep rupture specimens and the coverage ratios of M 23 C 6 on grain boundary were different. The cause of this was estimated to be the difference in B content between the 2 heat materials. Creep rupture tests with different final ST temperatures were also carried out using the same heat material, and it was revealed that the higher final ST temperature, the higher the creep rupture strength. As the final ST temperature is higher, the amount of Nb(C, N) solid solution in the matrix increases, and the amount of precipitation of NbCrN and M 23 C 6 increases during creep, therefore it is assumed that the creep rupture strength increases.

Grade 92 steel has been widely applied in the power generation industry for use as steam pipes, headers, tubes, etc. owing to a good combination of creep and corrosion resistance. For the welding of thick section pipes, a multi-pass submerged arc welding process is typically used to achieve sufficient toughness in the weld. To relieve the internal stress in the welds and to stabilise their microstructures, a post weld heat treatment (PWHT) is commonly applied. The heat treatment conditions used for the PWHT have a significant effect on both the resulting microstructure and the creep behaviour of the welds. In this study, interrupted creep tests were carried out on two identical Grade 92 welds that had been given PWHTs at two different temperatures: 732°C and 760°C. It was found that the weld with the lower PWHT temperature had a significantly reduced stain rate during the creep test. In addition, microstructural examination of the welds revealed that the primary location of creep damage was in the heat affected zone in the sample with the lower PWHT temperature, whereas it was in the weld metal in the sample with the higher PWHT temperature. To understand the effect of the different PWHT temperatures on the microstructure, initially the microstructures in the head portions of the two creep test bars were compared. This comparison was performed quantitatively using a range of electron/ion microscopy based techniques. It was apparent that in the sample subjected to the higher PWHT temperature, larger Laves phase particles occurred and increased matrix recovery was observed compared with the sample subjected to the lower PWHT temperature.

Solid particle erosion (SPE) harms steam and gas turbines, reducing efficiency and raising costs. The push for ultra-supercritical turbines reignited interest in SPE’s impact on high-temperature alloys. While the gas turbine industry researches methods to improve erosion resistance, a similar need exists for steam turbines. Existing room-temperature SPE test standards are insufficient for evaluating turbine materials. To address this gap, an EPRI program is developing an elevated-temperature SPE standard. This collaborative effort, involving researchers from multiple countries, has yielded a draft standard submitted to ASTM for approval. This presentation will detail the program, test conditions, and the draft standard’s development.

In order to comprehensively assess creep damage of 18Cr-9Ni-3Cu-Nb-N steel (ASME SA-213 S30432), which is widely used in critical high-temperature regions of heat transfer tubes of ultrasupercritical (USC) boilers, our investigation centered on the σ phase. This phase undergoes formation and coarsening during prolonged thermal exposure. We developed a technique to estimate operational heating metal temperatures by analyzing average particle size of the σ phase (MLAS-EX). By extracting a certain number of σ phase from the largest particle size, it is possible to select the σ phase that nucleated and grew in the early stage of heating. The correlation between the average particle size and the Hollomon-Jaffe Parameter (HJP), a parameter of heating temperature and time, allows precise estimation of the heating metal temperature. Our validation demonstrates that the replica method, which is a nondestructive method and effective for evaluating actual plants, is also applicable. Using our newly developed technique for estimating heating metal temperature, it is possible to predict the remaining creep life of heat transfer tubes based on data related to creep rupture characteristics, working stress and operating time. The developed method has already been successfully applied to evaluate the creep life of several actual boilers.

Inconel 718 is a nickel-based superalloy known for its excellent combination of high-temperature strength, corrosion resistance, and weldability. Additive Manufacturing (AM) has revolutionized traditional manufacturing processes by enabling the creation of complex and customized components. In this work, three prominent AM techniques: Laser-Based Powder Bed Fusion (PBF), Wire Direct Energy Deposition (DED), and Binder Jet (BJ) processes were explored. A thorough metallographic analysis and comparison of samples was conducted after short-term creep testing originating from each of the three aforementioned techniques in addition to wrought material. Detailed electron microscopy unveiled equiaxed grains in both BJ and wrought samples while PBF samples displayed elongated finer grain structures in the build direction, characteristic of PBF. The DED samples revealed a more bimodal grain distribution with a combination of smaller equiaxed grains accompanied by larger more elongated grains. When assessing the three processes, the average grain size was found to be larger in the BJ samples, while the PBF samples exhibited the most significant variation in grain and sub-grain size. Number density, size, and shape of porosity varied between all three techniques. Post-creep test observations in PBF samples revealed the occurrence of wedge cracking at the failure point, accompanied by a preference for grain boundary creep void formation while BJ samples exhibited grain boundary creep void coalescence and cracking at the failure location. In the DED samples, void formation was minimal however, it seemed to be more prevalent in areas with precipitates. In contrast, the wrought sample showed void formation at the failure site with a preference for areas with primary carbide formation. Despite BJ samples demonstrating similar or even superior rupture life compared to other AM techniques, a noteworthy reduction in rupture ductility was observed. While a coarse, uniform grain size is generally linked to enhanced creep resistance and rupture life, the combination of pre-existing voids along grain boundaries and the formation of new voids is hypothesized to accelerate rapid fracture, resulting in diminished ductility. This research shows careful consideration is needed when selecting an AM technology for high- temperature applications as creep behavior is sensitive to the large microstructural variations AM can introduce.

Type IV creep damage is a problem in high-temperature steam piping made of high chromium steel at thermal power plants, and a method for evaluating the remaining life is required. In this study, we considered that void’s initiation and growth can be expressed by initiation rate f, growth rate h, and initiation start time t 1 , and that stress and TF affect f, h and t 1 . We also proposed the method to estimate f, h and t 1 by measuring the change of the distribution of radius of voids during creep test. The creep test conditions are (1) test temperature of 650 C, maximum principal stress σ 1 of 79.5MPa, and TF of 2.5 ~ 3.0, and (2) test temperature of 650C, maximum principal stress of 71.5MPa, and TF of 2.5 ~ 3.0. The influence of σ 1 to f, h and t 1 was quantified by comparing the result of test (1) and that of test (2).