Main steam control valves are crucial components in power plants, as they are the final elements in the steam piping system before the steam enters the turbine. If any parts of these valves become damaged, they can severely harm the steam turbines. Recently, power plants have been required to operate under cyclical loading, which increases the risk of cracks in the control valve seats. This is due to the different rates of expansion between the Stellite surface and the underlying Grade 91 steel surface when exposed to high temperatures. To ensure a reliable power supply, power plants cannot afford long downtimes, making on-site service essential. This paper presents an on-site technique for post-weld heat treatment (PWHT) of Stellite seats. By using a heating pad arrangement and an induction heater, the required PWHT temperature of 740°C, as specified in the welding specification procedure (WPS), can be achieved. This method allows for on-site valve seat repair and can be applied to other power plants as well.

The effects of chemical composition and heat treatment on the creep properties of ASME Grade 91 type steel were experimentally investigated using materials whose chemical compositions and heat treatment conditions in the steel making process were completely controlled. Regarding chemical composition, only the Al, Cr, and Ni contents were systematically varied while keeping the contents of the other elements and heat treatment conditions constant. Regarding heat treatment, the normalizing and tempering temperatures were varied while keeping the contents of chemical components constant. The creep tests of materials were performed for approximately up to 50,000 h at 650°C. The creep strength of Grade 91 type steel decreased with increasing Al content under the test conditions of short-term to long-term range. On the other hand, the effect of Cr content on the creep life of Grade 91 type steel depended on the stress or time range, and the creep strength of the steel decreased at high Cr contents under test conditions of only the longterm range. No effect of Ni content on the creep life of the materials was observed in the test data obtained in this study. As creep tests are currently being conducted at 625°C and 60 MPa, which are conditions closer to the actual service conditions of main steam piping at ultra-super critical power plants, the creep deformation data at present indicate that the above trends hold true in the long-term range. Regarding the effect of heat treatment, the creep life of the materials tended to increase with increasing normalizing temperature or decreasing tempering temperature. The results obtained in this work indicate that within the scope of the material standards for Grade 91 type steel, the effect of chemical composition on creep life is greater than that of heat treatment.

The creep strength of the base metals and welded joints of ASME Grade 91 type steel under actual service conditions was investigated using long-term used materials in this study. Creep tests were conducted on the materials used for hot reheat or main steam piping at power plants. The remaining creep life of each material under actual service conditions was evaluated using the Larson-Miller parameter for the test result. Then, the creep life of each material under the service condition was estimated as a summation of the service time at the plants and the remaining creep life. The estimation results were useful for examining the validity of the life evaluation formula in the long-term region because it is extremely difficult to obtain creep rupture data under such conditions owing to the long test duration. The estimated creep lives were compared with creep life evaluation curves, which were regulated for Grade 91 type steel in Japan. Regarding the base metals, the estimation results suggest that Grade 91 pipe-type steel tends to exhibit a shorter life than the 99% confidence lower limit of the evaluation curve of the material. This finding indicated that the life evaluation formula for the Grade 91 type steel base metals should be reviewed. On the other hand, the estimation results suggest that the welded joints of Grade 91 type steel generally exhibit a longer life than the 99% confidence lower limit of the evaluation curve of the material, indicating that there is no need to review the life evaluation formula for the Grade 91 type steel welded joints.

Inconel 740H is one of the most promising candidate Ni-base superalloys for the main steam pipe of 700 °C advanced ultra-supercritical (A-USC) coal-fired power plants. After processing and welding in manufacturing plant in solution-annealed state, large components was commonly suggested to have an extra aging treatment at 800 °C for 16 h, in order to obtain homogeneous γ′ precipitates. In this present work, creep tests and microstructure analyses were conducted on Inconel 740H pipe specimens under two different heat treatments to verify the necessity of aging process. Here we show that aging treatment has limited effect on the creep rupture life of Inconel 740H pipe. Both in grain interiors and along grain boundaries, crept specimens under two different heat treatments have the same precipitates. But the shape and distribution of γ′ in solution annealed sample is not as regular as the aged ones. Our results provide the underlying insight that aging treatment is not so necessary for the straight pipes if the on-site condition was hard to control. But for both groups of specimens, a small amount of h particles and some banded like M 23 C 6 were emerged during creep, which would be harmful to mechanical properties for the long run.

The spalling of oxide scales at the steam side of superheater and reheater of ultra-supercritical unit is increasingly serious, which threatens the safe and economic operation of the boiler. However, no effective monitoring method is proposed to provide an on-line real-time detection on the spalling of oxide scales. This paper proposes an on-line magnetic non-destructive testing method for oxide granules. The oxide scale-vapor sample from the main steam pipeline forms liquid-solid two-phase flow after the temperature and pressure reduction, and the oxide granules are separated by a separator and piled in the austenitic pipe. According to the difference of the magnetic features of the oxide scales and the austenitic pipe, the oxide granule accumulation height can be detected through the spatial gradient variations of the magnetic induction. The laboratory test results show that the oxide scale accumulation can be accurately calculated according to the spatial gradient changes around the magnetized oxide granules, with the detection error not exceeding 2%.

The oxide exfoliation is one of the main problems that cause the explosion of superheater or reheater, which threaten the safety of power plant units, but there is no direct test method of the particle concentration of the scales in high temperature steam. Based on the study of ferromagnetic and optical characteristics of scales, the technology and equipment were developed for on-line measurement based on magnetic sensitivity and granularity behavior. Through numerical simulation and dynamic simulation experiments of scale movement under high temperature and high pressure steam, calculating method of the particle concertation of scales in the main steam or reheated steam pipeline was retrieved by local sampling concentration.

Type IV creep damage is a problem in high-temperature steam piping made of high chromium steel at thermal power plants, and a method for evaluating the remaining life is required. In this study, we considered that void’s initiation and growth can be expressed by initiation rate f, growth rate h, and initiation start time t 1 , and that stress and TF affect f, h and t 1 . We also proposed the method to estimate f, h and t 1 by measuring the change of the distribution of radius of voids during creep test. The creep test conditions are (1) test temperature of 650 C, maximum principal stress σ 1 of 79.5MPa, and TF of 2.5 ~ 3.0, and (2) test temperature of 650C, maximum principal stress of 71.5MPa, and TF of 2.5 ~ 3.0. The influence of σ 1 to f, h and t 1 was quantified by comparing the result of test (1) and that of test (2).

Following the successful completion of a 14-year effort to develop and test materials which would allow advanced ultra-supercritical (A-USC) coal-fired power plants to be operated at steam temperatures up to 760°C, a United States-based consortium has started on a project to build an A-USC component test facility, (A-USC ComTest). Among the goals of the facility are to validate that components made from the advanced alloys can perform under A-USC conditions, to accelerate the development of a U.S.-based supply chain for the full complement of A-USC components, and to decrease the uncertainty for cost estimates of future commercial-scale A-USC power plants. The A-USC ComTest facility will include a gas fired superheater, thick-walled cycling header, steam piping, steam turbine (11 MW nominal size) and valves. Current plans call for the components to be subjected to A-USC operating conditions for at least 8,000 hours by September 2020. The U.S. consortium, principally funded by the U.S. Department of Energy and the Ohio Coal Development Office with co-funding from Babcock & Wilcox, General Electric and the Electric Power Research Institute, is currently working on the Front-End Engineering Design phase of the A-USC ComTest project. This paper will outline the motivation for the project, explain the project’s structure and schedule, and provide details on the design of the facility.

Early supercritical units such as American Electric Power (AEP) Philo U6, the world’s first supercritical power plant, and Eddystone U1 successfully operated at ultrasupercritical (USC) levels. However due to the unavailability of metals that could tolerate these extreme temperatures, operation at these levels could not be sustained and units were operated for many years at reduced steam (supercritical) conditions. Today, recently developed creep strength enhanced ferritic (CSEF) steels, advanced austenitic stainless steels, and nickel based alloys are used in the components of the steam generator, turbine and piping systems that are exposed to high temperature steam. These materials can perform under these prolonged high temperature operating conditions, rendering USC no longer a goal, but a practical design basis. This paper identifies the engineering challenges associated with designing, constructing and operating the first USC unit in the United States, AEP’s John W. Turk, Jr. Power Plant (AEP Turk), including fabrication and installation requirements of CSEF alloys, fabrication and operating requirements for stainless steels, and life management of high temperature components

Recent advances in materials technology for boilers materials in the advanced USC (A-USC) power plants have been reviewed based on the experiences from the strengthening and degradation of long term creep properties and the relevant microstructural evolution in the advanced high Cr ferritic steels. P122 and P92 type steels are considered to exhibit the long term creep strength degradation over 600°C, which is mainly due to the instability of the martensitic microstructure strengthened too much by MX carbonitrides. This can be modified by reducing the precipitation of VN nitride and by optimizing the Cr content of the steels. An Fe-Ni based alloy, HR6W strengthened by the Fe2W type Laves phase is found to be a marginal strength level material with good ductility at high temperatures over 700°C and to be used for a large diameter heavy wall thick piping such as main steam pipe and hot reheat pipe in A-USC plants, while Ni-Co based alloys such as Alloys 617 and 263 strengthened by a large amount of the y’ phase are found to be the high strength candidate materials for superheater and reheater tubes, although they are prone to relaxation cracking after welding and to grain boundary embrittlement during long term creep exposure. A new Ni based alloy, HR35 strengthened by a-Cr phase and other intermetallic phases has been proposed for piping application, which is specially designed for a good resistance to relaxation cracking as well as high strength and a good resistance to steam oxidation and fire-side corrosion at high temperatures over 700°C.

Creep strength enhanced ferritic (CSEF) steels, particularly modified 9Cr steels Grade 91 and 92, are increasingly used in advanced coal-fired power plants for header and steam piping construction. While these materials typically enter service after receiving a standard high-temperature normalizing treatment followed by lower temperature tempering to achieve optimal microstructure, practical situations like welding operations may expose components to additional heat treatment exceeding the Ac 1 , and potentially the Ac 3 , temperature before returning to tempering temperature. This research examines the effects of simulated post weld heat treatments (PWHT) on Grade 91 and 92 materials using dilatometer-controlled heating and cooling rates, with peak temperatures below Ac 1 , between Ac 1 and Ac 3 , and above Ac 3 , followed by heat treatment at 750°C for 2 hours. Hardness measurements revealed significant reduction when exceeding the Ac 1 temperature, while advanced electron microscopy, including electron back scatter diffraction, was employed to analyze changes in martensite laths and grain structure, along with detailed carbide size distribution analysis using both scanning and transmission electron microscopy. The findings are discussed in terms of how such PWHT overshoots might affect mechanical properties during high-temperature service.

Dissimilar metal welds (DMWs) between ferritic and austenitic materials at elevated temperatures have long posed challenges for boiler manufacturers and operators due to their potential for premature failure. As the industry moves towards higher pressures and temperatures to enhance boiler efficiencies, there is a need for superior weld metals and joint designs that optimize the economy of modern boilers and reduce reliance on austenitic materials for steam headers and piping. EPRI has developed a new filler metal, EPRI P87, to enhance the performance of DMWs. Previous work has detailed the development of EPRI P87 for shielded metal arc welding electrodes, gas-tungsten arc welding fine-wire, and its application in an ultra-supercritical steam boiler by B&W. This study examines the weldability of EPRI P87 consumables through various test methods, including Varestraint testing (both trans and spot), long-term creep testing (approximately 10,000-hour running tests), procedure qualification records for tube-to-tube weldments between traditional/advanced austenitic steels and creep-strength enhanced ferritic steels, and elevated temperature tensile testing. Macroscopic examinations from procedure qualification records using light microscopy confirmed the weldability and absence of cracking across all material combinations. The findings demonstrate that EPRI P87 is a weldable alloy with several advantages for DMW applications and highlight that specific weld joint configurations may necessitate the use of high-temperature tensile data for procedure qualifications.

The toughness of girth welds in 9Cr-1Mo-V and 9Cr-0.5Mo-V steel seamless pipe (ASME SA-335 Grades P91 and P92, respectively) made using the flux-cored arc welding (FCAW) process was evaluated. Electrodes from two different suppliers were used for production quality welding of each steel. The welds received post-weld heat-treatment (PWHT) in accordance with the requirements of the ASME Code. The objective of the work was to determine if the fracture toughness of the FCAW welds was acceptable for high-temperature steam piping. Toughness was measured using standard sized Charpy V-notch impact specimens. The specimens were oriented transverse to the weld seam with notch located approximately in the center of the weld metal and parallel to the direction of weld seam. Full-range (lower to upper shelf) Charpy impact energy and shear area curves were developed for each weld joint. These were used to estimate the temperatures corresponding to 30 ft-lb average impact energy. The estimated temperatures were well below the service temperature but were above the typical hydrostatic test temperature.

Power generation technology selection is driven by factors such as cost, fuel supply security, and environmental impact. Coal remains a popular choice due to its global availability, but efficient, reliable, and cost-effective methods are essential. In Europe, efforts focus on advancing coal-fired steam power plants to ultrasupercritical conditions, with boilers and turbines now operating at up to 600°C. This has improved efficiency and maintained reliability comparable to subcritical plants. Orders are in detailed planning for plants exceeding 600°C, thanks to improved high-temperature steels for components like turbine rotors, casings, steam pipes, and boiler tubes, which undergo rigorous development and testing. Further efficiency gains are expected by increasing steam temperatures to over 700°C using nickel-based alloys. Test facilities are being built for pilot components, leading to a full demonstration plant. This systematic approach to materials development and proven design principles ensures operational reliability.

Texas Genco requested Stress Engineering Services to assist in reviewing and assessing a failure that occurred in the cold reheat (CRH) steam line at the W.A. Parish Unit around 12:10 PM on July 15, 2003, resulting in a catastrophic failure scattering components within a 1,200-foot radius. Reliant Resources and Texas Genco conducted their own investigation involving metallographic examinations, fracture surface inspection, review of operating conditions at failure time, and studies related to the CRH line weld profile. Stress Engineering Services' efforts included computational fluid dynamics studies to address how attemperator droplet sizes might impact downstream piping system behavior, followed by mock-up testing and field monitoring using high-temperature strain gauges, accelerometers, and thermocouples. The field monitoring data, along with process data from Texas Genco, were used for finite element analyses calculating static stresses and transient stresses from attemperator cycling (thermal stresses) and line vibration (mechanical stresses). A consulting firm contracted by the Electric Power Research Institute (EPRI) performed a fracture mechanics evaluation of the line, though detailed results are not included. The work by Texas Genco, Stress Engineering Services, and EPRI points to the stress concentration factor associated with the internal weld profile near the failure as the primary cause, with the cyclic thermal shocks from frequent intermittent attemperator use being sufficient to initiate the crack.

To obtain the maximum life for fossil power plant high energy piping systems requires a management process that goes beyond a maintenance response to discovered damage or problems. The catastrophic failure of a cold reheat piping system in 2003 and the ongoing damage reported for feedwater and steam piping systems in other power plants suggest a need for a comprehensive process of life management This paper proposes a process based upon the successful EPRI program for boiler tube failure reduction. Key to this process is a structure that fully confirms the damage or failure mechanism, that identifies the root cause for the mechanism, and that establishes short and long-term corrective actions for the damage. Finally, the process must be implemented through a cross-functional team of plant staff covering maintenance, operations, and engineering disciplines to assure the most complete and cost effective actions to prevent future damage.

Numerous factors, including actual chemical composition, heat treatment, microstructure, dimensions, and service conditions, determine the lifetime of creep-exposed components. This creates a wide gap between the real condition of a given steel pipe and its project specification. For a 141MW unit main steam line, the remaining life calculated according to the German Boiler Code TRD 508 was found to be almost exhausted. It was recommended to remove a pipe sample with a circumference weld for laboratory examination. Stress rupture tests were performed on three types of specimens: tangential, longitudinal, and longitudinal with a heat-affected zone in the middle of the gauge length using the isostress testing method. Metallographic examination of the broken specimens was conducted. Linear extrapolation of the rupture times to the service temperature yielded a residual service life of more than 100,000 hours.

A new 12%Cr steel, VM12, has been developed with the combined strength and oxidation resistance characteristics desired for high-temperature applications. The steel increases chromium content by around 0.2% to improve oxidation properties while alloying with other elements such as cobalt, tungsten, and boron to meet a range of requirements, including extending fatigue life. The steel is designed to have the same creep strength as T/P92 but with better oxidation resistance due to the higher chromium content. It has about a 0.2% increase in mechanical properties compared to T/P92 steel. Results are presented for tubes and pipes cast with a variety of surface conditions. In addition, detailed results are provided on the effects of alloying elements on creep and oxidation resistance.