Diffusion bonded compact heat exchangers have exceptionally high heat transfer efficiency and might significantly improve the performance and reduce the cost of supercritical carbon-dioxide Brayton cycle power plants using high temperature heat sources, like high temperature nuclear reactors and concentrating solar power plants. While these heat exchangers have an excellent service history for lower temperature applications, considerable uncertainty remains on the performance of diffusion bonded material operating in the creep regime. This paper describes a microstructural modeling framework to explore the plausible mechanisms that may explain the reduced creep ductility and strength of diffusion bonded material, compared to wrought material. The crystal plasticity finite element method (CPFEM) is used to study factors affecting bond strength in polycrystals mimicking diffusion bonded microstructures. Additionally, the phase field method is also employed to simulate the grain growth and recrystallization at the bond line to model the bonding process and CPFEM is used to predict the resulting material performance to connect processing parameters to the expected creep life and ductility of the material, and to study potential means to improve the structural reliability of the material and the resulting components by optimizing the material processing parameters.

The time-dependent behavior of 9Cr creep strength enhanced ferritic (CSEF) steels has long fixated on the creep life recorded in uniaxial constant load creep tests. This focus is a consequence of the need to develop stress allowable values for use in the design by formulae approach of rules for new construction. The use of simple Design by Formula rules is justified in part by the assumption that the alloys used will invariably demonstrate high creep ductility. There appears to be little awareness regarding the implication(s) that creep ductility has on structural performance when mechanical or metallurgical notches (e.g., welds) are present in the component design or fabricated component. This reduced awareness regarding the role of ductility is largely because low alloy CrMo steels used for very many years typically were creep ductile. This paper focuses on the structural response from selected tests that have been commissioned or executed by EPRI over the last decade. The results of these tests demonstrate unambiguously the importance that creep ductility has on long-term, time-dependent behavior. The metallurgical findings from the selected tests are the focus of the Part II paper. The association of performance with notch geometry, weld strength, and other potential contributing factors will be highlighted with a primary objective of informing the reader of the variability, and heat-specific behavior that is observed among this class of alloys widely used in modern thermal fleet components and systems.

Steels have a proven track record of safe operation in steam power plants for decades. Interest in developing supercritical CO 2 power cycles as a more efficient and sustainable alternative to steam cycles has driven a need to understand steel performance in these new environments. In particular, the potential of the high temperature CO 2 environment to influence the creep behavior of the steel must be determined. Prior research on this topic between the 1960s and 1980s found conflicting conclusions, but nevertheless raised the possibility that carburization during CO 2 exposure may strongly affect the creep behavior. This raises concerns particularly for thin-sectioned components such as compact heat exchangers, where even small rates of carburization can become problematic over long operating lifetimes. To shed light on this issue, this research investigates the creep behavior of austenitic stainless steel 347H and 309H (a higher Cr alternative) at 650°C. Specimens of 0.5, 1.0, and 2.0 mm thickness were tested to further assess the effect of steel thickness. Both steels show a reduction in creep life in CO 2 relative to air, with 309H showing slightly better performance than 374H. Analysis is ongoing to determine the reason for degraded creep properties.

This study evaluates various nondestructive testing methods for detecting creep damage and assessing residual life in Grade 91 steel welds. Three primary detection techniques were investigated: phased array ultrasonic testing (PAUT), eddy current testing with high-temperature superconductor direct current and superconducting quantum interference device (ECT•HTS-dc-SQUID), and replica observation. PAUT detected creep damage between 60-80% of creep life, while ECT•HTS-dc-SQUID showed detection capability between 80-90% of creep life. Replica observation revealed creep voids only in the final stages before rupture. Additionally, three strain measurement methods were evaluated: capacitive strain sensors (providing continuous monitoring during creep exposure), laser displacement meters (used during test interruptions), and SPICA strain measurement. Both capacitive sensors and laser meters produced results comparable to conventional extensometer measurements. The SPICA method proved particularly effective in measuring heat-affected zone (HAZ) strain after creep exposure, revealing higher strain values in the HAZ compared to base and weld metal, with a consistent increase during creep exposure.

The time-dependent behavior of 9Cr creep strength enhanced ferritic (CSEF) steels has long fixated on the creep life recorded in uniaxial constant load creep tests. This focus is a consequence of the need to develop stress allowable values for use in the design by formulae approach of rules for new construction. The use of these simple rules is justified in part by the assumption that the alloys used will invariably demonstrate high creep ductility. There appears to be little awareness regarding the implication(s) that creep ductility has on structural performance when mechanical or metallurgical notches (e.g., welds) are present in the component design or fabricated component. This reduced awareness regarding the role of ductility is largely because low alloy CrMo steels used for very many years typically were creep ductile. This paper focuses on the structural response from selected tests that have been commissioned or executed by EPRI over the last decade. The results of these tests demonstrate unambiguously the importance that creep ductility has on long-term, time-dependent behavior. This is the second part of a two-part paper; Part I reviewed the selected tests and discussed them from a mechanical perspective. The association of performance with specific microstructural features is briefly reviewed in this paper and the remaining gaps are highlighted for consideration among the international community.

For future carbon neutral society, a novel thermal power generation system with no CO 2 emission and with extremely high thermal efficiency (~ 70 %) composed of the oxygen/hydrogen combustion gas turbine combined with steam turbine with the steam temperature of 700°C is needed. The key to realize the thermal power plant is in the developments of new wrought alloys applicable to both gas turbine and steam turbine components under higher temperature operation conditions. In the national project of JST-Mirai program, we have constructed an innovative Integrated Materials Design System , consisting of a series of mechanical property prediction modules (MPM) and microstructure design modules (MDM). Based on the design system, novel austenitic steels strengthened by Laves phase with an allowable stress higher than 100 MPa for 10 5 h at 700°C was developed for the stream turbine components. In addition, for gas turbine components, novel solid-solution type Ni-Cr-W superalloys were designed and found to exhibit superior creep life longer than 10 5 h under 10 MPa at 1000°C. The superior long-term creep strengths of these alloys are attributed to the “grain-boundary precipitation strengthening (GBPS)” effect due to C14 Fe 2 Nb Laves phase and bcc α 2 -W phase precipitated at the grain boundaries, respectively.

The effects of chemical composition and heat treatment on the creep properties of ASME Grade 91 type steel were experimentally investigated using materials whose chemical compositions and heat treatment conditions in the steel making process were completely controlled. Regarding chemical composition, only the Al, Cr, and Ni contents were systematically varied while keeping the contents of the other elements and heat treatment conditions constant. Regarding heat treatment, the normalizing and tempering temperatures were varied while keeping the contents of chemical components constant. The creep tests of materials were performed for approximately up to 50,000 h at 650°C. The creep strength of Grade 91 type steel decreased with increasing Al content under the test conditions of short-term to long-term range. On the other hand, the effect of Cr content on the creep life of Grade 91 type steel depended on the stress or time range, and the creep strength of the steel decreased at high Cr contents under test conditions of only the longterm range. No effect of Ni content on the creep life of the materials was observed in the test data obtained in this study. As creep tests are currently being conducted at 625°C and 60 MPa, which are conditions closer to the actual service conditions of main steam piping at ultra-super critical power plants, the creep deformation data at present indicate that the above trends hold true in the long-term range. Regarding the effect of heat treatment, the creep life of the materials tended to increase with increasing normalizing temperature or decreasing tempering temperature. The results obtained in this work indicate that within the scope of the material standards for Grade 91 type steel, the effect of chemical composition on creep life is greater than that of heat treatment.

The creep strength of the base metals and welded joints of ASME Grade 91 type steel under actual service conditions was investigated using long-term used materials in this study. Creep tests were conducted on the materials used for hot reheat or main steam piping at power plants. The remaining creep life of each material under actual service conditions was evaluated using the Larson-Miller parameter for the test result. Then, the creep life of each material under the service condition was estimated as a summation of the service time at the plants and the remaining creep life. The estimation results were useful for examining the validity of the life evaluation formula in the long-term region because it is extremely difficult to obtain creep rupture data under such conditions owing to the long test duration. The estimated creep lives were compared with creep life evaluation curves, which were regulated for Grade 91 type steel in Japan. Regarding the base metals, the estimation results suggest that Grade 91 pipe-type steel tends to exhibit a shorter life than the 99% confidence lower limit of the evaluation curve of the material. This finding indicated that the life evaluation formula for the Grade 91 type steel base metals should be reviewed. On the other hand, the estimation results suggest that the welded joints of Grade 91 type steel generally exhibit a longer life than the 99% confidence lower limit of the evaluation curve of the material, indicating that there is no need to review the life evaluation formula for the Grade 91 type steel welded joints.

Gas turbine blades are operated in a high temperature and a high pressure. In order to cope with that harsh condition, the blades are made of Nickel based superalloys which show excellent performance in such environment. Manufacturers of the blades usually provide the standards for the blade inspection and replacement. According to their guide, the blades are replaced after 3 times of operations and 2 times of refurbishments. Howsoever, purchase the new blades is always costly and burdensome to the power plant owners hence, the assessment of the blade lifespan and the rejuvenation of the degraded blades are indeed crucial to them. In this study, the optimal rejuvenation conditions for gas turbine blades were derived and verified. In addition to that, the creep durability was evaluated based on the actual blade inspection interval. LCF tests have been carried out on the rejuvenated blade and the result was compared with the fatigue life of the new blades. In order to secure the safety of the rejuvenated blade during operation, a heat flow analysis was performed to simulate the operating conditions of the gas turbine during operation, and the main stress and strain areas were investigated through the analysis results. And then LCF and creep considering the actual operating conditions were evaluated. The calculated life of fatigue and creep life is compared to the hot gas path inspection interval. For the rejuvenated blades, the creep life and the LCF interval were reviewed based on the temperature, stress, and strain acquired by computational analysis. The creep life was calculated as 59,363 hours by LMP curve, and the LCF was calculated as 2,560 cycles by the Manson Coffin graph.

The localized creep failure in the heat-affected zone (HAZ) of Grade 91 steel weldments has been identified as one of the most important factors causing significantly shortened service lifetime and structural integrity issues of welded components in advanced fossil and nuclear power plants. To conduct a reliable creep lifetime assessment, a new engineering assessment approach has been developed by incorporating the experimentally determined local properties of the heterogeneous HAZ. By creep testing a purposely simulated HAZ specimen with in situ digital image correlation (DIC) technique, the highly gradient creep properties across the HAZ of Grade 91 steel was quantitatively measured. A physical creep cavitation constitutive model was proposed to investigate the local creep deformation and damage accumulation within the heterogeneous HAZ, which takes into account the nucleation of creep cavities and their growth by both grain boundary diffusion and creep deformation. The relationship among the local material property, creep strain accumulation, and evolution characteristic of creep cavities was established. The approach was then utilized to investigate the creep response and subsequent life for an ex-service 9% Cr steel weldment by incorporating the effects of pre-existing damages which developed and accumulated during long-term services. The predicted results exhibited quantitative agreement with the DIC measurement in terms of both nominal/local creep deformation as well as the subsequent life under the test conditions at 650 and 80 MPa.

Modified 9Cr-1Mo steel (ASTM Gr.91) is widely used in components of fossil fueled power plants around the world today. This grade of steel has however been shown to exhibit significant variations in creep life and creep ductility, which has led to premature in-service failures. The aim of this work is to define potential metallurgical risk factors that lead to this variation in performance. To achieve this, a set of creep test samples that represent a wide range in this variation of creep behavior in this steel grade have been studied in detail. As a first stage in this characterization the macro-scale chemical homogeneity of the materials were mapped using micro-XRF. Understanding the segregation behavior also allows quantification of microstructural parameters in both segregated and non-segregated areas enabling the variations to be determined. For example this showed a significant increase in the number per unit area of Laves phase particles in high compared with low Mo content areas. To study the effect of MX particles on segregation a methodology combining SEM and TEM was employed. This involved chemically mapping the larger V containing particles using EDS in the SEM in segregated and unsegregated areas and then comparing the results to site-specific TEM analysis. This analysis showed that although the average size of the V containing samples is in the expected 0-50 nm size range, these particles in some samples had a wide size distribution range, which significantly overlaps with the M 23 C 6 size distribution range. This together with the segregation characteristics has important implications for determining meaningful quantitative microstructural data from these microstructurally complex materials.

The effect of boron nitrides (BN) and aluminum nitrides (AlN) on long-term creep life and rupture ductility has been investigated for martensitic 9 to 12Cr steels at 550 to 700 °C. The BN particles form in 9 to 12Cr steels during normalizing heat treatment at 1050 to 1150 °C, suggesting no change in the amount of BN particles during creep. On the other hand, the AlN particles gradually form during creep at 550 to 700 °C, decreasing the concentration of nitrogen free from the AlN particles. The degradation in creep life takes place more significantly with test duration in the steels containing high Al but not in those containing the BN particles. The rupture ductility is evaluated by using a semi-logarithmic diagram of the RA and total elongation, showing the necking dominant and void swelling dominant regions. The BN and AlN particles are responsible for the degradation in RA at low stresses and long times by accelerating the formation of creep voids at interfaces between the BN and AlN particles and alloy matrix.

A new method of creep life assessment was developed to consider heat-to-heat variations of welded joints of materials used in power plants. This paper explains a scheme of the assessment method and also describes an actual implementation of the method for Grade 91 steel. In the method, creep properties of the welded joints are related to those of each base metal because the heat-to-heat variations of welded joints strongly depend on the creep properties of the corresponding base metals. To estimate the creep properties of each base metal of the target pipe, microstructure analyses and small punch creep tests were conducted using small samples cut from the base metals in service, and evaluations were done on the basis of material data base obtained using standard test samples of long-term service exposed pipes. It is expected that the precision of the life assessment of pipes will be significantly improved using the developed method because it can consider the heat-to-heat variations of their materials, which are not considered in existing life assessment methods.

700°C advanced ultra-supercritical system and supercritical CO 2 turbine system are developed for high efficiency turbine systems for next generation. This study covered the feasibility of creep life assessment of γ’-Ni 3 (Al,Ti) precipitation strengthened Ni-based superalloy rotor material, TOS1X-2, a modified alloy of UNS N06617 for these systems, based on hardness measurement method. It was found that the hardness of TOS1X-2 was governed by the change in precipitation strengthening and strain hardening during creep. The clear relationship between hardness increase in crept portion and macroscopic creep strain was observed, suggesting that it might be possible to estimate the creep strain or initiation of acceleration from hardness measurement. Microstructure inhomogeneity and microstructure evolutions during creep especially focused on dispersion of creep strain were characterized by EBSD quantitative analysis. It was found that creep strain was accumulated along the grain boundary, while it was relatively absent in coarse grains with low Schmid factor of {111} <110> slip system in fcc structure. The upper limit of hardness scatter band is thought to be important, since it represents the local and critical creep damage of the alloy.

The effect of taking miniature sample scoops on the creep life of ASME Grade 91 steel pipes was experimentally and analytically assessed in this work. Internal pressure tests were conducted on tubular specimens having defects on their outer surface, which simulate sampling scoops. The creep life did not decrease until the depth ratio of the defect to the wall thickness of the specimens was about 5%, and the creep life decreased with increasing defect depth when the depth ratio exceeded about 5%. When the depth ratio was about 11%, the creep life decreased to four-fifths of that of a specimen with no defects. In addition, as a result of investigating the stress concentration around a defect with a depth ratio of about 5% by the finite element method, stress concentration was clearly observed around the defect. These results suggest that taking a miniature sample up to a depth of 5% of the thickness of a Grade 91 steel pipe in service has a negligible effect on the creep life of the pipe.

A creep resistant martensitic steel, CPJ7, was developed with an operating temperature approaching 650°C. The design originated from computational modeling for phase stability and precipitate strengthening using fifteen constituent elements. Approximately twenty heats of CPJ7, each weighing ~7 kg, were vacuum induction melted. A computationally optimized heat treatment schedule was developed to homogenize the ingots prior to hot forging and rolling. Overall, wrought and cast versions of CPJ7 present superior creep properties when compared to wrought and cast versions of COST alloys for turbines and wrought and cast versions of P91/92 for boiler applications. For instance, the Larson Miller Parameter curve for CPJ7 at 650°C almost coincides with that of COST E at 620°C. The prolonged creep life was attributed to slowing down the process of the destabilization of the MX and M 23 C 6 precipitates at 650°C. The cast version of CPJ7 also revealed superior mechanical performance, well above commercially available cast 9% Cr martensitic steel or derivatives. The casting process employed slow cooling to simulate the conditions of a thick wall full-size steam turbine casing but utilized a separate homogenization step prior to final normalization and tempering. To advance the development of CPJ7 for commercial applications, a process was used to scale up the production of the alloy using vacuum induction melting (VIM) and electroslag remelting (ESR), and underlined the importance of melt processing control of minor and trace elements in these advanced alloys.

The creep degradation/life assessment for high temperature critical component materials is absolutely needed to assure the long-term service operation and there is little experience with the service exposure of the high temperature components made of newly developed Ni-based alloys. In this study, therefore, the creep degradation assessment study on the Ni-based alloys, Alloy 617 and HR6W was conducted based on the hardness method, because the hardness measurement is a useful and simple technique for the materials characterization for any kind of high temperature-serviced steels and alloys. As the result, it was found that the hardness was increased by not only precipitation due to thermal aging but also creep stress/strain, and there existed linear relationship between the applied stress and creep-induced hardness increase. Also the hardness scatter measured was increased along with the progress of creep hardening and damage progressing in terms of creep life consumed. Those findings suggested that the creep life assessment of Ni-based alloys would be possible by means of hardness measurement. The paper also deals with the role and perspective development of non destructive damage detecting techniques, and life assessment issues on Ni-based alloys for A-USC power applications.

ASME Grade 91 steel seam-welded elbow pipe, which has been used in a USC plant (A-Plant) for about 6 × 10 4 h, was investigated to clarify the microstructure and remaining creep life of the material at long-term region. SEM and TEM observations were conducted on specimens cut from the welded portions of the intrados and extrados of the elbow, and the number density of creep voids in fine-grained HAZ was measured in the wall-thickness direction. Then, creep rupture tests were performed to examine the remaining life of each portion of the base metal and welded joint. On the basis of the results, it was suggested that the microstructural changes were small and that the cumulative creep damage was also small for the elbow pipe during its use at the USC plant for about 6 × 10 4 h. The present result was compared with the result of an investigation on Grade 91 steel elbow used in another USC plant (B-Plant) for about 5 × 10 4 h. The A-Plant material had a creep life about ten times longer than that of the B-Plant material for not only the base metals but also the welded joint. Through the comparison of the investigation results, it was suggested that the difference in the creep deformation property between the base metals of the elbows was the main reason for the difference in their creep lives.

A methodology is developed for evaluating its creep rupture life from analysis of an on-going creep curve with the aid of an Ω creep curve equation. The method is applied to on-going creep curves of grade 91 steel for evaluating their rupture lives. Quick decrease in creep rupture strength has been reported recently in long-term creep of grade 91 steel. The quick decrease of the steel is discussed by using the rupture lives evaluated. The quick decrease is confirmed in the present study in the time range longer than 3 x 10 4 h at 600°C.

Through inner wall oxidation scale thickness measurement, sampling tests and installation of wall temperature measuring device in the boiler, the equivalent wall temperature and its distribution of secondary high temperature reheater tube were estimated and verified, and the temperature field distribution of tube platen which is of single peak distribution in the direction vertical to tube platen and an apparent lower temperature distribution covered by the smoke shield at the side of boiler wall were both obtained. For the middlemost 10CrMo910, the wall temperature of individual tube was getting close to 600°C. Afterwards material state and residual creep life of tube platen were estimated and calculated. The results of estimate and calculation show that the tube platen in the middle is not suitable for further service due to its degraded material states and lower antioxidant ability. Thus with consideration of distribution characteristics of temperature field, parts of tube platens in the middle are proposed to be replaced with T91 tubes. Furthermore, to avoid onsite heat treatment, 10CrMo910 tube covered by the smoke shield in the boiler was reserved, and a small piece of 10CrMo910 tube was welded at the inlet and outlet ends respectively in the manufactory.