Developed 9Cr-3W-3Co-Nd-B heat-resistant steel SAVE12AD (Recently designated as ASME Grade 93) pipes and tubes have higher creep strength in both base metal and welded joints than conventional high Cr ferritic steels such as ASME Grades 91, 92 and 122. The welded joints of SAVE12AD tubes with commercial filler wire for W62-10CMWV-Co (Gr. 92) or Ni base filler wire ERNiCr-3 (Alloy82) also have much better creep rupture strength than those of conventional steels because of suppression of refining in the Heat-Affected-Zone (HAZ). However, the creep rupture strength of weld metal of W62-10CMWV-Co was marginal. Additionally, the hot cracking susceptibility of weld metal using Ni base filler wire ERNiCr-3 was occasionally below the required level. Similar welding consumable for SAVE12AD has been developed to solve these problems. Optimization of nickel, neodymium and boron contents on similar welding consumable enables to obtain both the good long-term creep rupture strength and low enough hot cracking susceptibility of weld metal. Consequently, SAVE12AD welded joint is expected to be applied of piping and tubing above 600°C in USC power plants because of its good properties with similar welding consumable.

Despite the significant progress achieved in power generation technologies in the past two decades, finding effective solutions to further reduce emissions of harmful gases from thermal power plant still remains the major challenge for the power generation industry as well as alloy material developers. In the European material programmes COST 522 and COST 536, based on the existing 9-12%Cr creep resisting steels, an advanced 9%Cr-Mo martensitic alloy, C(F)B2 (GX13CrMoCoVNbNB9-2-1) alloy has been developed. By modification through alloying of boron and cobalt and together with other micro-adjustment of the composition, C(F)B2 alloys has showed very encouraging properties. The current paper summaries the development and evaluation of the matching filler metals for C(F)B2 grade. The design of the filler metal composition is discussed and comparison is made with the parent materials in respect to the alloy additions and microstructure. The mechanical properties of the weld metals at ambient temperature are examined. Creep properties of both undiluted weld metals and cross-weld joints are examined through stress rupture test and the data are evaluated and compared with those of the base alloy and other existing 9%Cr-Mo creep resisting steels.

As flux cored wires for gas metal arc welding offer several technical and economic advantages they are becoming more and more popular. Matching flux cored wires for welding P92 have already been available for several years. A matching flux cored wire for welding the Co-alloyed cast steel CB2, which is used for turbine and valve casings operating at steam temperatures of up to 620°C, was developed recently. To connect casings with P92 pipes, dissimilar welding of CB2 to P92 is necessary. This can be done with filler metal that matches either CB2 or P92. Pre-tests have confirmed that flux cored arc welding (FCAW) can generally be used for dissimilar joint welding of CB2 to P92. To evaluate creep rupture strength dissimilar welds were performed with filler metal matching CB2 and P92, respectively. TIG welding was used for the root and the second pass and FCAW for the intermediate and final passes. Cross-weld tensile tests, side bend tests and impact tests of weld metals and heat-affected zones were carried out at ambient temperatures after two post-weld heat treatments (PWHT), each at 730°C for 12 hours. Creep rupture tests of cross-weld samples were performed at 625°C. This study compares the results of the mechanical tests at ambient temperature and the creep rupture tests, and discusses why P92 filler metals are preferred for such welds.

Creep properties of 9Cr heat resistant steels can be improved by the addition of boron and nitrogen to produce martensitic boron-nitrogen strengthened steels (MarBN). The joining of this material is a crucial consideration in the material design since welds can introduce relatively weak points in the structural material. In the present study, creep tests of a number of MarBN weld filler metals have been carried out to determine the effect of chemistry on the creep life of weld metal. The creep life of the weld metals was analysed, and the evolution of creep damage was investigated. Significant differences in the rupture life during creep have been observed as a function of boron, nitrogen and molybdenum concentrations in the weld consumable composition. Although the creep lives differed, the particle size and number in the failed creep tested specimens were similar, which indicates that there is a possible critical point for MarBN weld filler metal creep failure.

In 9~12% Cr containing martensitic stainless steels, Laves phase usually occurs after long term high temperature exposure, while in the present work, some sparse relatively large particles of (Fe,Cr)2Mo type Laves phase were observed in virgin FB2 steel. It is speculated that the large Laves phase particles formed in casting process due to dendritic segregation. Then the evolutionary behavior of Laves phase during welding thermal cycle was studied and constitutional liquation of Laves phase was found, suggesting a liquation crack tendency in FB2 steel. At last, the hot ductility tests showed that the area where constitutional liquation occurred would act as crack initiation site, and the tested specimen fractured without any obvious plastic deformation. This work provided some guidance for the practical production of welded turbine rotors made of FB2 steel.

The inspection and evaluation of defects in the welds of P92 high temperature reheater header with a diameter of about 1000mm and a wall thickness of about 100 mm have been done by means of hardness test, nondestructive testing on the surface, ultrasonic testing, metallographic and component sampling. By analyzing the results of on-site test and samples removed from the component, it is found that cracks existing in the welds are hydrogen induced delayed cracks. During the welding process and post-heating treatment (hydrogen bake-out), dehydrogenation was insufficient. This fact, combined with welding residual stresses resulted in the observed hydrogen induced cracking.

The presented work summarizes the results of more than 10 years of research at TU Graz and TU Chemnitz and partners on a martensitic boron and nitrogen stabilized 9Cr3W3Co (MARBN) steel grade. The design philosophy of MARBN steels is presented and critical issues regarding boron and nitrogen balance are discussed. Microstructural characterization of two different laboratory heats, is presented and efforts in European projects towards an upscaling of melts are presented. Base material creep testing data at 650 °C up to 50.000 hours is presented and assessed to commercial alloys such as ASTM grades P91 and P92. An increase of creep rupture stress of more than +20% was recorded. Oxidation tests in steam at 650°C revealed an anomalous response of the material. Several specimens exhibited excellent oxidation resistance commonly only seen for grades of higher chromium content. The anomalous oxidation behaviour is identified and discussed, although the causes remain yet unclear. Results of manufacturing, characterization and testing of different MARBN welds, including gas-tungsten-arc-, gas-metal-arc-, friction stir and electron beam welds reveal a microstructure memory effect in the heat affected zone, so that no uniform fine-grained zone is present. The behaviour of crosswelds during long-term creep testing at 650 °C up to more than 32.000 hours is assessed and the susceptibility to Type IV cracking is discussed. The manuscript summarizes research of more than 10 years, presents current research activities on MARBN and describes open questions for an alloy identified as a promising martensitic steel grade for elevated temperature components.

The efficiency of power plants is depending on the steam temperature and/or the steam pressure. Efficiency increasing from 35% to 42-45% require increasing of the steam temperature over 600°C and the pressure over 26 MPa. According to the designer opinion it is not profitable to use classical low alloy creep resistant steels 16Mo3, 13CrMo4-5 or 10CrMo9-10 for membrane waterwall construction for these service condition. New modified low alloy creep resistance T23 and T24 (7CrMoVTiB10-10) steels were developed for membrane waterwalls. Welding of these steels with small thickness (around 6.3 mm) should be enabled without preheating and post weld heat treatment (PWHT) due to the lower carbon content below 0.1%. High creep rupture strength (CRS) values are achieved by Ti, N and B elements alloyed to T24 steel. The original expectation that the welding small thickness without preheating was early overcome and was wrong. According to the present experience the T24 steel is welded with preheating at 150-250°C depending on the wall thickness and welded joint toughness in order to achieve required hardness and impact toughness values. Opinions on the T24 welded joints post weld heat treatment (PWHT) requirements are still inconsistent. Especially the membrane waterwalls of the supercritical power plants are still produced without PWHT.